1,944 Replies to “Darkest Night Spoiler Page”

  1. Echo of falling autumn leaves(echopaw)
    November 28, 2017 at 2:50 am

    OK it’s echopaw your resident lgbtq headcanon-person.
    SO.
    FERNSONG. SO VERY OBVIOUSLY TRANS YES.
    VIOLETSHINE. STILL LESBIAN.
    IVYPOOL. SHE CAN BE LESBIAN IF FERN IS TRANS
    yep i’m insane




    5
    • Sky
      November 28, 2017 at 3:24 am

      … Umm.. 😛


      'Tis the season to be JOLLY!!!




      5
      • Mobile Echopaw
        November 28, 2017 at 6:04 am

        haha don’t mind me




        1
    • Anonymous
      November 28, 2017 at 4:30 am

      I currently have practically no idea what you are implying.




      2
    • Jayfrost
      Jayfrost
      November 28, 2017 at 4:34 am

      I don’t see Fernsong as trans, mostly because I like the idea of a tom not needing to be trans or gay to be feminine or comfortable with being feminine for once, but I fully support the idea of lesbian!Violetshine. 😀


      BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




      4
      • Vixen the Fox-like Reindeer (Foxie)
        November 28, 2017 at 5:04 am

        Wut 😛 Um no to les Violet and Ivy and no to trans Fern, thk u vry mch 😉😛





        4
        • Jayfrost
          Jayfrost
          November 28, 2017 at 1:25 pm

          I dunno, I always thought Cioletpaw had a thing for Needletail, and she and Zelda would be cute together. ^^


          BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




          1
          • Elmwhisker
            November 28, 2017 at 5:21 pm

            I don’t think Violet had a thing for Needle. She was basically an older sister.




            7
            • Jayfrost
              Jayfrost
              November 28, 2017 at 6:03 pm

              Eh, it’s how I saw their relationship anyway. 😛


              BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




              1
      • Mobile Echopaw
        November 28, 2017 at 6:05 am

        Right, I understand. I just think we need a trans character.




        1
        • Jayfrost
          Jayfrost
          November 28, 2017 at 2:34 pm

          That’s fair. 🙂 Okay, but how about this idea that popped randomly into my head early… trans!Tree?


          BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




          1
          • Mobile Echopaw
            November 28, 2017 at 4:32 pm

            Ok sure




            1
            • Elmwhisker
              November 28, 2017 at 5:20 pm

              Tbh Trans would make zero sence with cats.




              5
              • Echo of falling autumn leaves(echopaw)
                November 29, 2017 at 3:21 am

                why? these cats are basically human anyway




                2
                • Elmwhisker
                  November 29, 2017 at 8:57 pm

                  Having a trans cat would turn Warriors in 2017. Cats asking it for pronouns would get repetitive with each new cat it meets. Cats can literally smell the gender of a cat so that would add confusion.It would take away from the plot and just become ridiculous. The cat no doubt would be portrayed ina way that would offend somebody. It wouldn’t just be accepted in the clans, its way too foreign a subject for them to really understand what to do with it.
                  Not trying to hate or anything, Warriors just isn’t the place for it.




                  11
                • Jayfrost
                  Jayfrost
                  November 30, 2017 at 11:55 pm

                  There’s no reason why Warriors shouldn’t be the place for it. I don’t know what you mean by it turning Warriors. Yes, cats can smell biological sex, but these cats have monogamous relationships and strict hierarchies unlike real cats – an understanding of gender doesn’t seem that out of place compared to that. How would it be ridiculous for a cat just to have to mention their gender once to any new cat they meet? It’s the same as having to introduce their name once to every new cat they meet. And within the Clans they only have to introduce themselves a few times. And there’s no reason the Clans wouldn’t be able to be accepting. Some cats might be bigoted, as they are with kittypets and halfClan cats, but others would be accepting as they are of those things.


                  BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




                  1
                • Sky
                  December 1, 2017 at 12:17 am

                  I agree with Elmwhisker. I have nothing against LGBT+, but what he/she says makes sense.


                  'Tis the season to be JOLLY!!!




                  5
            • Vixen the Fox-like Reindeer (Foxie)
              November 28, 2017 at 5:32 pm

              How would a cat become trans anyway? There’s no Cutter to “change” them, and they’ll always be male or female no matter what so……or just say “oh I’m trans now” and that’s that? 😐😛

              Also hold on, is Zelda female or male? Yeah I still haven’t read AVOS yet…..*sighs*





              1
              • Jayfrost
                Jayfrost
                November 28, 2017 at 6:07 pm

                You don’t have to transition physically to be trans. It’s about how you identify. Not everyone who is trans is able to, or wants to, transition. It’s about respecting their identity and pronouns regardless of their physical traits. 🙂 I see no reason why that wouldn’t work for cats.

                Zelda is female. 🙂 She’s (presumably) named after Princess Zelda from the Legend of Zelda video game series.


                BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




                2
                • Vixen the Fox-like Reindeer (Foxie)
                  November 28, 2017 at 7:37 pm

                  Ohh okay thx





                  1
                • Jayfrost
                  Jayfrost
                  November 28, 2017 at 8:40 pm

                  No problem. 🙂


                  BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




                  1
      • Elmwhisker
        November 28, 2017 at 8:09 pm

        I wouldn’t say Fern is feminine, he is just taking on a role that is usually done be females. He doesn’t have a feminine demeanor imo.




        3
        • Jayfrost
          Jayfrost
          November 28, 2017 at 9:14 pm

          He has what tends to be considered a typically femenine name, seems more on the gentle and sweet side than most toms in the series, and has taken on what is seen in the Clans as a more traditionally feminine role. He seems kinda feminine to me in that way. It’s kinda looked down on in Society when men act feminine or take on feminine roles or traits, so I just think it’s kinda nice to have a male character be feminine without it being seen as shameful or anything.


          BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




          5
    • Wildstar
      November 29, 2017 at 10:17 pm

      SCUSE ME DID YOU EVER BELIEVE IN BARLEY X RAVENPAW?????




      3
      • Echo Is Slipping On A Frozen Brook(Echopaw)
        December 6, 2017 at 2:30 am

        um yes




        1
    • November 30, 2017 at 3:08 am

      please omg

      I agree with Jayie on Fern being trans but we do need a trans cat and I think he’d make a good one, I just don’t want it to turn into “oh, Fern was trans all along! That’s why he took on a she-cat’s job! A tom being queen automatically means they’re trans! No other toms can be queen!”


      🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




      2
      • Echo Is Slipping On A Frozen Brook(Echopaw)
        December 6, 2017 at 2:30 am

        i agree!




        1
    • Sundance
      Sundance
      November 30, 2017 at 4:15 am

      Ivypool x Blossomfall . . . I will go down with that ship.




      2
      • Maple Leaf Drifting Onto Rudolph’s Nose (Mapledrift)
        November 30, 2017 at 7:34 am

        For me it is Ivypool x Hollyleaf, it will never die in my mind




        1
  2. Echo of falling autumn leaves(echopaw)
    November 28, 2017 at 2:53 am

    hang on, is twigpaw twigbranch now? i don’t remember that in the book?




    1
    • Snowflower
      November 28, 2017 at 3:35 am

      She hasn’t got her name yet. Kate just revealed what it was here on the Blog.




      2
    • Sky
      November 28, 2017 at 4:01 am

      Leak by Kate!!! A RARE APPEARANCE!!


      'Tis the season to be JOLLY!!!




      4
      • Anonymous
        November 29, 2017 at 12:31 am

        Unfortunately, this seems to be a tiny spoiler in comparison to the main plot of the arc.
        When did the previous accidental spoiler announcements occur?




        4
        • Brightstorm (Bright Candle On Thanksgiving Table)
          November 29, 2017 at 9:34 am

          I remember she revealed that ThornXBlossom was going to become canon back before Shattered Sky was posted.


          Can't rain all the time.




          6
  3. Snowflower
    November 28, 2017 at 3:43 am

    Kate, do you think Fintail would be way too cruel a name to give to Finpaw? It’s like when Berrynose was getting his warrior name. He was so worried that Firestar would name him Berrystumpytail (yes, I know that name is ridiculous). So what I’m asking is, if Finpaw becomes Fintail would he resent and hate his name since it would be a constant reminder of his tail?




    2
    • Kate Needs More Cadvent Pics
      November 28, 2017 at 10:30 am

      To be honest, I can’t imagine Finpaw resenting or hating anything. I think he would enjoy the name and be proud of what distinguishes him from other warriors. He’s a very upbeat cat 😀


      BlogTeam Administrator, Leader




      11
      • Jaysnow can't think of a good Christmas name that doesn't already sound like the one he has year round
        November 28, 2017 at 10:31 am

        I love him.




        7
      • Winterwhisper
        November 28, 2017 at 6:46 pm

        If only Berrynose could have been that way 😛




        4
      • Snowflower
        November 29, 2017 at 2:19 am

        That’s great to hear. c: Finpaw is a fantastic character.




        0
        • Falalalalalal! (Flowerstep)
          December 3, 2017 at 10:39 pm

          Kate, since you told us all Twigbranch’s warrior name, can you tell us Finpaw’s? If it really is Fintail, I’d drown in laughter, because that would just be a whole new level of irony. But please please please tell us THE SUSPENSE IS KILLING ME!




          1
          • Christmas Cake
            December 4, 2017 at 12:08 pm

            W.a.S 🙂


            BlogTeam Administrator, Leader




            1
          • December 7, 2017 at 4:29 am

            TBH I really hope it’s not Fintail, because a fin and a tail are almost the same thing, which brings us back to Twigbranch’s name.


            Lots of Purrs.




            2
      • November 30, 2017 at 3:11 am

        I don’t know. His tail seemed to be troubling him a lot. I think he’d take it well and over time he’d feel that way, but at first it would only feed his anxiety.


        🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




        3
      • Breeze Blowing Confetti Across Full Moon/Moonpaw/Moonbreeze (My Birthday is coming up...)
        December 2, 2017 at 11:20 pm

        Finstumpytail!


        Click my name!




        2
        • Christmas Cake
          December 3, 2017 at 12:09 pm

          😀


          BlogTeam Administrator, Leader




          0
          • Vixen the Fox-like Reindeer (Foxie)
            December 7, 2017 at 5:32 am

            Fintail sounds cute 🙂





            0
  4. Jaysnow can't think of a good Christmas name that doesn't already sound like the one he has year round
    November 28, 2017 at 10:02 am

    I hope we find out how Rowanclaw died…




    9
  5. Jaysnow the Snowman
    November 28, 2017 at 2:03 pm

    I wonder if those cats ever made it to StarClan. It’s a pretty scary thought, but what if some cats never got their “unfinished business” done and stayed wandering earth forever?




    9
    • Mobile Echopaw
      November 28, 2017 at 4:33 pm

      That…would be creepy




      4
      • Jaysnow the Snowman
        November 28, 2017 at 7:09 pm

        Indeed




        0
        • Snowstrike
          November 28, 2017 at 7:32 pm

          It does seem realistic, as what about all of the cats in Goosefeather’s curse?




          0
          • Jaysnow the Snowman
            November 28, 2017 at 8:11 pm

            Vicky said those cats were just visiting their old hunting grounds. That’s different.




            5
            • Snowstrike
              November 28, 2017 at 8:29 pm

              Thanks, Jaysnow. I do have a question, and here it is:
              Who do you think will deserve a novella/super edition next? And who is your favorite character?




              0
              • Jaysnow the Snowman
                November 28, 2017 at 8:50 pm

                I want Riverstar to get a super edition.
                My favorite of all time is Jayfeather. 🙂




                5
                • Wildstar
                  November 29, 2017 at 10:24 pm

                  SAME Jayfeather is me if I was a cat.




                  0
                • November 30, 2017 at 5:55 am

                  Riverstar super edition yessssss!


                  🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




                  2
                • Breeze Blowing Confetti Across Full Moon/Moonpaw/Moonbreeze (My Birthday is coming up...)
                  December 2, 2017 at 11:21 pm

                  Yesss Riverstar is sooooo kind of mysterious. Or at least we don’t know anything about him really, so that would be very cool.


                  Click my name!




                  0
    • Snowflower
      November 29, 2017 at 2:20 am

      That is scary. We already know that Dawnpelt makes it, but I hope the others do as well.




      2
    • Beech leaves frosted with snow (Beechpaw/Beechflight)
      November 30, 2017 at 4:39 am

      Which cats? *I’m a sucker for spoilers*


      Lots of Purrs.




      1
      • CoAl2O4 that Dyes Snow Blue (Cobaltheart)
        December 2, 2017 at 2:17 am

        Needletail, Beenose, Lioneye, Mistcloud, and Dawnpelt.


        Reading: Dawn




        0
        • Breeze Blowing Confetti Across Full Moon/Moonpaw/Moonbreeze (My Birthday is coming up...)
          December 2, 2017 at 11:21 pm

          Birchbark as well.


          Click my name!




          0
          • Falalalalalal! (Flowerstep)
            December 3, 2017 at 10:43 pm

            Jaysnow, I have some questions. Birchbark, Looney, Needletail and the others are refs dead right? also was there some chemistry going on between Violetshine and Tree? Do you know? If so, pleez answer!




            0
  6. Duststorm (Winter Storm of the Season)
    November 28, 2017 at 6:48 pm

    Kate, are we going to see FinxTwig’s kits by the end of the arc like BirchxWhite’s kits in PoT?


    Waiting for RoF...




    2
  7. Silverleaf (Silverpaw)
    November 29, 2017 at 2:57 am

    I have a question: The cats on the cover are Hawkwing and Tigerheart, right? Or am I wrong?




    0
    • Falalalalalal! (Flowerstep)
      December 6, 2017 at 1:25 am

      I dunno. I though it was Rowanstar or Bramblestar…The gray cat is defs Hawkwing though.




      0
      • Vixen the Fox-like Reindeer (Foxie)
        December 6, 2017 at 1:51 am

        Yeah I think it’s Hawkwing and Tigerheart 🙂 (Rowanstar would look more ginger)





        0
  8. Snowflower
    November 29, 2017 at 5:41 am

    Kate, do you know who ShadowClan’s new deputy is?

    And if you do and can’t (or won’t) tell us, can you at least tell us if it’s a younger or older cat so we can narrow it down?




    0
    • Kate Needs More Cadvent Pics
      November 29, 2017 at 2:45 pm

      W.A.S!


      BlogTeam Administrator, Leader




      5
      • Jaysnow the Snowman
        November 30, 2017 at 6:29 am

        Still hoping for Tawnypelt.




        2
        • December 2, 2017 at 1:01 am

          Same here.


          🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




          0
          • Winterwhisper
            December 2, 2017 at 1:42 am

            I want Snowbird! Or Grassheart. Just please not Dovewing!




            3
            • Jay Frost Nipping at Your Nose
              Jay Frost Nipping at Your Nose
              December 2, 2017 at 1:45 am

              I don’t think she could be chosen, since I don’t think she’s trained an apprentice yet.


              BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




              1
            • Jaysnow the Snowman
              December 2, 2017 at 1:48 am

              If it’s Dovewing I will actually riot.

              I doubt it though, she’s a queen and also hasn’t had an apprentice.




              1
            • December 2, 2017 at 2:01 am

              Dovewing?! Please no!


              🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




              1
              • Jaysnow the Snowman
                December 2, 2017 at 2:38 am

                I think he will choose one of his newphews: Juniperclaw or Strikestone. I want Tawnypelt, though. He can’t just ignore his momma like that.




                0
                • Breeze Blowing Confetti Across Full Moon/Moonpaw/Moonbreeze (My Birthday is coming up...)
                  December 2, 2017 at 11:23 pm

                  It might be weird because she is his mom and all… but she is the most logical choice. I’m thinking Rippletail or Juniperclaw. Not Dovewing. Please StarClan.


                  Click my name!




                  2
                • December 3, 2017 at 2:46 pm

                  Tawnypelt is really old, though. If you put Tawnypelt in as deputy , it might work, but she’s only got a few more moons on her until she retires. Same with Brackenfur and Thornclaw.


                  Lots of Purrs.




                  0
                • Jay Frost Nipping at Your Nose
                  Jay Frost Nipping at Your Nose
                  December 3, 2017 at 7:09 pm

                  But her brother who is the same age is currently ThunderClan’s leader with no signs of retiring soon.


                  BlogTeam Administrator, Deputy




                  1
                • December 3, 2017 at 8:30 pm

                  So, Jayfrost made me think of this. Here’s a list of all the cats currently alive in AVoS that were alive in the first series (not including the ones that died in TAQ, TAS, etc.)
                  ThunderClan:
                  -Bramblestar
                  -Greystripe
                  -Brackenfur
                  -Cloudtail
                  -Thornclaw
                  ShadowClan:
                  -Tawnypelt
                  -Oakfur
                  WindClan:
                  -Whitetail
                  RiverClan:
                  -Mistystar
                  -Mosspelt
                  ( I didn’t include SkyClan in this because we didn’t know who was alive when)


                  Lots of Purrs.




                  3
  9. November 30, 2017 at 4:04 am

    aaaah so I finally got and read the book so I can be here and do my usual rambling review with theories sprinkled in and boy do I have some thoughts 😀

    First of all, I thought it was amazing. Well done, Kate! It was extremely well-written and had tons of plot, tension, drama, character and relationship building, and foreshadowing. It was really hard to put down! (haha bad I have homework tonight that I was supposed to start two hours ago and haven’t 😛 ) I honestly wasn’t super excited for this one (I was excited though) because Shattered Sky felt like the end of an arc and I wasn’t sure how you could pick up from that aside from tying up loose ends. But it was done really well! Now Shattered Sky doesn’t feel like as much of a conclusion, which is great since there are still two books to go 😀

    all right, where do I begin?

    Ivy and Fern. Okay, how I feel about this ship still stands. I don’t like it. I like Ivy single and kitless, as an independent she-cat. I don’t like that every she-cat in ThunderClan is getting a mate and/or love interest. Fern for Ivy is better than some, but still wouldn’t be my choice. I’d just have her stay a Single Pringle 😛 However, I adored Fernsong in this book. He was very devoted to Ivypool and was following her around on most patrols, especially the one looking for her sister. It wasn’t shown, but I think it’s cute that he was probably comforting her offscreen. Also, I loved how he’s gonna go into the nursery for her. Not only does it break gender stereotyped boundaries, which I am always in favor of, it shows a lot of his character. He’s really mature and devoted and I love that. I also like how they’re acknowledging that Ivypool isn’t the type to settle down in the nursery, but Fernsong is, and that’s okay. They can still work things out. Out of all the scenes this ship was shown in, that was my favorite. I really hope that this paves the way for more toms to become queens. Ivypool and Fernsong’s situation will definitely come up in future mates, and some toms are just more suited for the nursery. I hope there comes a time that when a she-cat and a tom decide to have kits, they choose which one of them wants to stay in the nursery, and that there can be permanent queens like Ferncloud and Daisy who are toms. The mother really doesn’t have to be there for the nursing period anyway, she can just come to them when they need to nurse. It’s amazing. I love it.

    Twig and Fin. One of my favorite pairings. Tbh in AVOS there haven’t really been many pairs that I’ve intensely shipped, but I’m intensely shipping this one. They’re adorable! At first I was a bit annoyed by it because there seem to be a lot of random new ships in this book and it felt stereotypical and cliche, but as it developed it grew on me. I love how Dewpaw slyly got them to hang out when Finpaw was in the medicine den. Finpaw’s decision to come to ThunderClan with Twigpaw was rash and will have consequences, but it was adorable and I loved his devotion. I was also really happy that they’re not making it into another stereotypical forbidden relationship. And how Finpaw’s in ThunderClan, so he can learn about Halftail! I really hope someone tells him about him or Halftail visits him sometime. He’d be so happy. Finpaw is also just a great character in general and he’s already become one of my favorites.

    I loved Violetshine in this book. She’s so mature, but she’s still very bouncy and thoughtful. It was heartbreaking when Twigpaw left for ThunderClan because her separation anxiety is going to start coming up again. But I know she’s meant to be in SkyClan with Hawkwing. She’s flourished, and she flourished on the journey too. She’s grown into such a great character. I honestly won’t be surprised if she becomes leader of SkyClan someday. She has the makings for a great leader, thoughtful and mature, but full of energy and kindness, firece, and willing to defy others to do the right thing. Her chasing after Needletail was really sad, and every time I really wanted Needletail to turn around and talk to her. I was really happy when she finally found Tree and was able to talk to her.

    Tree! I’m so happy! I really liked him in the short I saw with him at the end of SS. I’m so happy he’s a main character. He’s such a great character. He’ll make a great Clan cat. His gift is really interesting and I have a lot of questions and theories on it. (I posted those in my predictions post on the River of Fire spoiler page, but if you want me to post them here I will ^^)

    I have to talk about Molewhisker. He was adorable in the journey. It obviously made him so happy. I hope he gets to go on another journey soon. I don’t think he’ll become a member of SkyClan, as I don’t think that it was hanging out with the SkyClan cats that made him happy (although that could be the case, although that’s kind of disappointing). I think it was going out and doing something important, exploring, etc. He had a role to play, and he was out exploring and doing great things for SkyClan. He was being a hero in his own way. I really liked him. I hope we get to see that side of him again. I wonder if there’s pressure on him in ThunderClan that we don’t really get to see. After all, his apprentice pretty much failed warrior training and then became a medicine cat. That must be a bit saddening.

    JASPER!!! Aggressive ginger cat who is a fighter and has prejudiced views of our protagonist group? Jasper from Steven Universe much? (the gender is wrong though, but Jasper is one of the more masculine of gems tbh). I was SO HAPPY. I know it’s probably not a SU reference because I don’t think the Erins know SU, but I could be wrong. I’m choosing to believe that maybe it was a reference. 😀 (alert alert alert! Jasper has copied Amethyst and shapeshifted into a cat! Warriors/SU crossover! 😛 )

    I really didn’t like Sparkpelt and Larksong. It was extremely rushed, just shoved in our face, out of nowhere, and mostly offscreen. If I’m going to ship them (which is entirely possible because I have no idea what dynamic they have together. But I think it’s cute because their names rhyme! Also, I was a bit confused when Alderheart and Sparkpelt talked about him not being happy with her because she was spending all her time with him. I thought he was unhappy with her because she wanted SkyClan to leave? Also, I thought it was really sweet how she followed him and saved him. I, too, miss their close relationship and I hope not only will they regain it, but we’ll see a lot of it!

    I’m really sad about what happened to RiverClan. RiverClan is my favorite Clan along with SkyClan (and Wavepaw’s in it 😛 ) so I love seeing them and seeing them flourish. They’ve been the background Clan this series and I don’t like it one bit. The whole closing borders thing was very out of character for Mistystar. I wonder if there’s something we don’t know that’s happening inside the borders. If only Dovewing still had her powers and hadn’t left so she could check! I honestly think Mistystar is losing her spark and is going to die soon, as in this series. I’m really sad to see her go, but I’m excited for a chance to see more of Reedwhisker, to see him as leader, and to see more of RiverClan in general. I really hope that her dying isn’t the cause for the borders to reopen. I want to see Mistystar deal with it, go on with her life, and then die. (Or she could just retire I’m cool with that I love Mistystar)

    Just some unrelated thoughts that aren’t long enough for their own paragraph: I really liked seeing Loki and Zelda again, even if it wasn’t for long. I hope we see more of them in the future books, and that Zelda can be with Violetpaw again. I wish we’d seen Minty and Jessy, I really want to see them again soon. I found it funny that a great storm happened near the beginning and end of Rowanclaw’s leadership. I wonder if it’s a bit of a metaphor for more than just the great storm that’s coming, which I think it is. Every cat seems to think Tree will save them, but in TS didn’t it say to beware him? That might be personal for Tigerheart and Dovewing as there’s probably going to be a lot of drama when they get back, but maybe he’s going to cause some tragedy. I hope it’s by accident. I don’t want Tree to be a bad guy. As I said above, I really like him and want him to be a protagonist. I loved the names of Tinycloud’s kits. They’re names that have been used only in minor characters a long time ago and I think they’re great names! I hope they get really good warrior names too. I also liked the names of the lost SkyClan apprentices. When they were first spotted I groaned because I thought there actually might be a sixth Clan, which is cliche, a plot device, and just completely out of the blue. I’m glad they’re not. When Frecklewish escaped and the Twoleg was trying to get her back, I actually identified more with the Twoleg than with Frecklewish. I have a cat who’s kept indoors because indoor cats live longer and are healthier than outdoor cats, and I felt a pang in my heart because I knew I would be heartbroken if Melodie ran away. I was sad that Cypresspaw and Wavepaw weren’t shown, but there was basically no RiverClan anyway. I also think that not enough attention to RiverClan was paid given the situation they were in, but a lot was happening so I get it. I thought there was gonna be more drama involving SkyClan having no medicine cat, so I was a bit disappointed but I thought it was handled well, and I’m glad to have Frecklewish and Fidgetpaw back, especially now that Twigpaw’s not gonna be SkyClan’s medicine cat (she was my personal pick). The Hawk/Twig/Violet family belonging moments were adorable and one of my favorite parts of the book, but now whenever I reread it they’re gonna be bittersweet because of Twigpaw leaving for ThunderClan 😛 I wish that we’d seen more of Bumblestripe and how he’s dealing with Dovewing being gone and then Tigerheart leaving too. Also, Scorchfur’s behavior strikes me as off. He was always the one stirring up trouble and tried to blind Tawnypelt! His own Clanmate! It reminds me of the Dark Forest training days. I really hope it’s not that, because we already had two series focused on that, but I do think there’s something here we don’t know about. Also there was no Wavepaw I’m sad 🙁 oh well. I’m so happy that Cherrytail and Cloudmist came back! I was hoping they would but I was a bit worried they wouldn’t or that something would’ve happened to them. Cherrytail is pretty old (but not old enough to die don’t you dare Kate 😛 ). Also I’m so happy Barley is still alive and well and we saw him! He handled Molewhisker really well and made him happy. I wish Ravenpaw could’ve been there to talk with Molewhisker about ThunderClan and just see him again.


    🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




    4
    • Sky
      December 1, 2017 at 12:18 am

      *reads Ivy and Fern part* *screams* YESSSSSSSSS SINGLE IVY!!!

      Scorchfur was a pretty big antagonist in this book!


      'Tis the season to be JOLLY!!!




      0
      • December 1, 2017 at 12:43 am

        single ivyyyyyyyy


        🌊 Queen of Canon Correcting🌊




        0
        • Duskpaw
          December 2, 2017 at 1:37 am

          SINGLE IVYYYYY!!!!!!




          0
        • Sky
          December 2, 2017 at 1:47 am

          I agree with almost every word you said


          'Tis the season to be JOLLY!!!




          0
      • Winterwhisper
        December 2, 2017 at 1:40 am

        Yes he was. I was actually impressed and pleased that a more minor character had such a strong personality and strong beliefs. He’ll make a good villain, even if he doesn’t have to be a major violent one! Or, ooh, if he has a character arc and becomes good, that’d be nice too…




        0
      • Falalalalalal! (Flowerstep)
        December 3, 2017 at 10:49 pm

        Oh my gosh yes! But I didn’t really like Scorchfur at all (I never really have). I know he has reasons, but it’s no excuse to be a massive traitor! I think he’s a real jerk. Does anyone agree with me, cause I don’t want to seem like a hater.




        0
    • Winterwhisper
      December 2, 2017 at 1:39 am

      Great review 🙂




      0
    • Breeze Blowing Confetti Across Full Moon/Moonpaw/Moonbreeze (My Birthday is coming up...)
      December 2, 2017 at 11:25 pm

      I agree with basically everything you just said. Especially the SparkXLark part. And the RiverClan part. I was really sad as well. I would like Ivypool to be a single mother however, I want her to have kits! Only if her kits are like her though…


      Click my name!




      2
  10. swanshine
    December 1, 2017 at 2:09 am

    i wanted violetheart




    3
    • Jaysnow the Snowman
      December 2, 2017 at 2:07 am

      Interesting name choice. I would have liked that, too.




      2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll Up

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close