Rainflower: Was she really that bad? by Aspenpaw

Aspenpaw gives us a new take on the character of Rainflower.

Artwork by FrostedKat

Hey there!
I am Aspenpaw and this is my first time writing an article. I have decided to focus on the character ‘Rainflower’ from ‘Crookedstar’s Promise’.
So what are you waiting for? Let’s begin!

Let me give you a brief overview of the character Rainflower:
Rainflower is a Riverclan Queen/Warrior who is the mother of Crookedstar (formerly known as Stormkit) and Oakheart. Her mate is Shellheart. On a stormy night when the Riverclan camp flooded, she gave birth to her two kits, naming them Stormkit and Oakkit. Later, Stormkit injured himself, causing Rainflower to stop loving him. She became a supposedly evil character and relentlessly hated upon poor Crookedkit. She died when a dog knocked her head against a rock next to a river she was drinking at.

Prior to Stormkit’s injury, Rainflower appeared to be a happy and sweet Queen. She loved her sons and her mate, Shellheart, dearly. But as soon as poor little Stormkit broke his jaw whilst trying to cross a river, hatred and pure anger began to surge through her. She began neglecting the poor kit and renamed him Crookedkit. She never was the same cat again.

So, can we really blame Rainflower for her violent and neglectful actions? Not necessarily. I mean, what she did was terrible and all, but she was too grief-stricken to realize what was actually happening. She was very upset about the fact that her ‘handsome young warrior’ had gone out and injured himself on his own accord. It was an accident, but Rainflower seemed to not take it that way. Sadness began to surge through her and that powerful sadness affected her actions for the rest of her life. She first neglected her poor injured kit, then broke up with her mate, re-named Stormkit Crookedkit, tried to distance herself as far away from her now disfigured son and blames everything on Crookedkit.

As you can see from what I stated above, most of the things that Rainflower did across the course of her later life, were affected by pure grief and sadness. From what we can tell, she seemed to be a lovely she-cat before the terrible accident.

All in all, I still think Rainflower was truly heartless for what she did to her son. Just because he disfigured himself doesn’t mean you should neglect him. Instead, she should have given him more attention. But, her personality drastically changed after that seemingly insignificant event. From what I have written, I believe that Rainflower really wasn’t that bad as some deem her to be. She simply took the event of an injury way too far. There have been other cases of cats completely changing because of one event. Take Mapleshade for example. When her kits drowned, she was blinded by her own grief and rage and wanted to take everything out on important cats in her life.

Rainflower is not as evil as she seems.

Thank you for reading my article!
I hope you enjoyed.
Fare the well!

Similar Posts:

  29 Replies to “Rainflower: Was she really that bad? by Aspenpaw”

  1. Sharptail
    July 3, 2017 at 6:05 pm

    There’s no excuse for an abuser. That stuff messes you up for life. If a loved one dies? You get sympathy. If you get attacked? You get sympathy. But if you’re abused, you feel alone and isolated and there is no excuse for making someone else feel like that. I don’t hate Rainflower, but I sure as [Icy edit: I replaced the following with a kinder word. 🙂 ] heck wouldn’t write an article excusing her for her abuse. I consider myself to be a relatively forgiving person and I don’t hold a grudge against her, but excusing her is just plain insensitive.

  2. ImaginarySolarfare
    May 10, 2018 at 2:32 am

    I honestly don’t think that Rainflower was that bad. Yes, I do blame her for her actions and grief she conflicted on Crookedstar as a kit, but really- from what the Erins have proved she’s not that bad.

    People think Rainflower his heartless in all ways and fashions, and that’s their opinion. Okay, yeah, it’s very rude and mean to neglect a kit by an accident, but that was THEN. The Erins have proved (Or at least I believe) That Rainflower and Crookedstar made up in StarClan. When people get angry at Rainflower for not giving Crookedstar a life, she couldn’t. StarClan didn’t think she deserved the opportunity to give her kit a life that she conflicted mental harm on as a kit. Rainflower always felt terrible for what she had said to Crookedstar, and how she changed her name, but she never knew how she could make it up to her mate, Shellheart, or Oakheart and Crookedstar. I understand that feeling where you don’t know what to do, and how to forgive yourself. Other Cats feel that way. She felt terrible for what she did, and that’s one reason she’s not entirely “heartless”. Has she ever murdered a cat? No. Yeah, she may be the worst mother in the Warrior’s series so far, but she never murdered her kits, or anyone else. So, at least we can clarify she’s not evil. Once Crookedstar went to StarClan, she apologized for everything she said and did, and Crookedstar /forgave/ her, which warms my heart completely. I think they did deserve to make up. Especially what Rainflower did in the past. Also, some people say she doesn’t deserve to be in StarClan, but genuinely, I think she does. I mean, yeah it’s my opinion, but she never murdered a cat; only mentally. Nor did Thistleclaw, but, that’s besides the point. I don’t know- all of this was completely my opinion. I don’t /entirely/ know that if what I said was all true, but I’m positive that the Erins have posted stuff about Rainflower’s past, and how she and Crookedstar made up in StarClan. I don’t know if I’m being arrogant or narrow-minded, but I’m just expressing my opinion openly, and maybe Rainflower deserves a /little/ more love then what she got. She suffered the consequences, loosing her mate and kits, but she deserves forgiving- at least to me. If anyone ever reads this, I hope you understand my opinion, and have a nice day.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll Up

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.