Sharptail analyzes the morality of Mapleshade’s actions.
Ah, Mapleshade. Plenty hate her, plenty love her. I can’t wait to read the flame war of comments on this article. Before we properly get to the titular question, let’s establish three things first:
– What she did was wrong. Murder is wrong in all instances other than self-defense, as is stated by most western legal systems (not a lawyer nor have academically studied Law, so correct me if I’m wrong). I’m not saying that she’s a bad cat, but that one of her actions was objectively evil.
– The motivation behind her killing Ravenwing, Frecklewish, and Appledusk was her grief and anger over her dead kits.
– Previous to her exile, she had been a loyal ThunderClan cat.
Now, let’s ask the question. Was/is she redeemable? By redeemable, I mean two things:
– Could she have become a good cat in the right circumstances post-death?
– Could she be viewed as a good cat overall?
What we know is that, when she’s sent to the Dark Forest (as is canon), she becomes bitter and driven insane. She becomes murderous and seeks revenge upon the Clans.
So what if StarClan had said, on the day she died, “Hey, she was a grieving mother and she had been exiled from her Clan. What could she have done?” What if she went to StarClan? What if she had been reunited with her dead kits who assured her that they were fine?
If we look at Ashfur, a very morally objectionable cat, he went to StarClan and he seemed to suddenly turn good. Obviously morality doesn’t work like that, but you get what I’m trying to say. He didn’t fight for the Dark Forest in TLH, that’s for sure. So what if he did go to the Place of No Stars? From his character pre-mortem, I’d say that he’d definitely be headed down Mapleshade’s path. See this excellent video by spinosaurus rex for a great insight into Ashfur’s psychology.
So why are we talking about Ashfur, I hear you ask? Isn’t this article about Mapleshade? Well, if we think about it, Ashfur’s post-mortem happenings just so happen to mirror Mapleshade’s. He’s the anti-Mapleshade, in a way. Of course, they’re two fundamentally different characters, but there are parallels, particularly in their vengeful psyches.
So I’d imagine that, given the chance to go to StarClan, Mapleshade would likely turn out a lot like our Ashfur.
Hmm. Well, that was a little anti-climactic. Eh.
I mean to leave this open-ended for you guys! What’s your opinion? Should Mapleshade have gone to StarClan in order to see redemption? And I never answered the second question because I wanted for everyone to come to their own conclusions as this is probably the most subjective topic in the fandom: could she be viewed as a good cat overall? Because remember, morality is defined by what you want, not what you do. What I mean is say that a homeless mother steals some bread from a store to feed her starving children. This is a lot more morally grey than a rich millionaire stealing bread just because they feel like it, even though they both did the same thing: steal bread. The former is trying to feed her children, and the latter is trying to get a cheap thrill out of stealing. Just keep that in mind when answering that!
Anyway, this has been Sharptail, over and out.
- Should Ashfur be in StarClan? *Spoiler on Moth Flight’s Vision* by Shadekit
- The Judging of Mapleshade by Acorva
- My Opinion On Mapleshade by Silverpaw
- Analyzing Starclan and the Dark forest- Is sending cats to the dark forest helping or hurting? by Prowlclaw
- Which Warrior? Mapleshade or Ashfur? Skit #1 by Iceclaw