My Unusual Opinions on Cats in the Books by Heatherflight


Heatherflight discusses some “different” opinions about some cats

Hey! It’s Heatherflight, a relatively new member! I have opinions, like everyone else, except mine tend to differ from everyone else’s. So, as a VERY opinionated person, here are cats I like/hate, and my arguments.

1. Jayfeather

I find Jayfeather annoying, honestly. He complains about not having attention, then snarls at anyone who GIVES him the attention he wanted. He’s overly grumpy. He’s a jerk to everyone except his siblings, and I find him to be like Nico di Angelo, except I like Nico. (Plus, he wanted Longtail and Brightheart to get crushed by a tree.)

2. Millie

*deep breath* I like Millie. She was loyal to Graystripe, fought like a LION to protect ThunderClan, and listen for a moment. Just think. Two of your kits were nearly full-grown, didn’t need (or really ask for,) your attention. The other one was crippled, and even something small, like not moving around enough, could kill her. Which would you pay more attention to? Blossomfall went to the Dark Forest because she wanted to learn new battle moves for her Clan, and make some more friends! Yes, she could be really grumpy at times, but the fandom loves full-time grumpy characters like Jayfeather or Yellowfang, so why not Millie?

3. Hollyleaf

Now, I don’t like using the word ‘hate’, but here we go. I actually, full-blown HATE Hollyleaf. She’s whiny, irritating, boring, and actually a bit of a Mary-Sue. Plus, she always flips from talent to talent. Best hunter out of the apprentices, to best fighter, back to best hunter, BLAHDY BLAH. You killed Ashfur, then couldn’t live with the guilt. Realistic emotions, but seriously. You are described as the thinker. Lionblaze gave Ashfur some space to let him make a choice on his own, and/or to find a CIVIL way to stop him. Jayfeather went to him CIVILLY. YOU went to murder-mode without thinking it through. One of the only things you did that I approve of was saving Ivypool.

4. Scourge

I REALLY don’t feel like repeating myself, as on another Blog site, I already wrote down a small rant on Scourge. So, I’ll put it here.

He’s the most STEREOTYPICAL villain in the history of ever.

Being bullied by your siblings is no reason to go crazy. Plus, WAAAAAY too over-powered and kind of whiny.

Or maybe it’s just all the SCOURGE’S DAUGHTER 111!!1111!1!!!!!!!11 oc’s.

The killer of Scourge, a powerful villain, leader of the almighty BloodClan, so much potential, we were on the edges of our seats when we started, and you give us……….

This Gary-Stu, stereotypical, brat?

Am I reading the wrong book?

But seriously, all in all, he’s just, irritating.

That’s all! This is just my opinion, if you respect mine, I’ll respect yours! Thanks for reading! 🙂

Fan Articles


  • 1
  • 2

  • Wow! Interesting articles and opinions! I can’t say I agree with them all, but I like how you’ve formed your opinions and really made it clear what you think.

  • THANK YOU FOR SETTING THINGS STRAIGHT WITH SCOURGE. Why does the fandom feel so much sympathy for him? I bet everyone has gotten into fights with siblings, and yes, some are as mean as Scourge’s. That doesn’t make it ok to turn evil!

    • I feel bad for him as a kit, because I do think the way his littermates treated him was more awful than just sibling bickering, but they don’t excuse his actions and I don’t think it makes him any less than the murderer and tyrant he is.

  • Looks around then whispers ‘I hate Hollyleaf too, except for that part where she saved Ivy’ ducks out before chairs are thrown

  • I have to disagree with Hollyleaf, however I agree with Jayfeather! (dont kill me jayfeather fans)

  • Jayfeather: Good points, but I’m still neutral about him.

    Millie: Totally agree with you all the way! 😀

    Hollyleaf: I once found her irritating, but I moved to neutral on her and I’m still neutral.

    Scourge: Eh. I felt sorry for Scourge at the beginning. I don’t really like him a lot, though. A lot of people are too obsessed with Scourge, I think.

  • Nice article, but I disagree with all of these except Scourge. I LOVE Jayfeather and Hollyleaf, and dislike Millie. But I respect your opinion.

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art