The prophesies begin- Top 10 SADDEST deaths by Frostbite

Frostbite makes a countdown for the saddest deaths. 

(Note- I have not read the darkest hour.)
1. Spottedleaf- Cause of death: killed by Clawface behind the nursery. Why it was sad- She was the sweetest cat I think was ever in the series. It was obvious Firestar loved her.

2. Yellowfang- Cause of death: Inhaled too much smoke during a fire. Why it was sad- Yellowfang might have been grumpy, but she had been though so much. She also died in Firestars paws.

3. Silverstream- Cause of death: Died during kitting of Greystripe’s kits. Why it was sad- Greystripe was right next to Silverstream when she left to be in Starclan, and even Tigerstar felt bad. Greystripe loved her so much.

4. Bluestar- Cause of death: Drowned saving Firestar from dogs. Why it was sad- She died for Firestar, and the fact that she drowned made it worse, Her kits watched their mother die,

5. Brindleface- Cause of death: Killed by Tigerstar/dogs. Why it was sad- Brindleface had been a mother to so many kits, and she was also Cloudtail’s foster mom. Cloudtail was one of the first to see her.

6. Lionheart- Cause of death: killed in battle against Shadowclan. Why it was sad- he was such a noble cat who was replaced but by Tigerstar. It just seems that no cats really mourned him.

7. Brokentail- Cause of death: killed by Yellowfang when she gives him death berriers. Why it was sad- sure, he was evil. But it was so depressing because his own mother fed him death berries after she clawed his eyes out.

8. Oakheart- Cause of death: killed by rockfall. Why it was sad- He was Bluestar’s mate, and the fact that he was smushed by a boulder just makes it 10x worse.

9. Redtail- Cause of death: killed by Tigerstar. Why it was sad- He hadn’t even been in the book when he died. He was killed because of Tigerstar’s fury and Ravenpaw watched it in horror.

10. Whitethroat- Cause of death: run over by a twoleg monster. Why it was sad- Whitethroat had been very sick and just wanted to be strong, his last sight was of Tigerstar as blood trickled from his mouth.


Fan Articles

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mapleleaf that loves her kits but still is Mapleleaf (Trust me)
Mapleleaf that loves her kits but still is Mapleleaf (Trust me)
February 12, 2017 6:36 pm

OK. Thank you. I was getting worried! 😀

Disco Kitten (aka so not Maplekit)
Disco Kitten (aka so not Maplekit)
February 12, 2017 7:08 pm

YAY HAVING NOT READ THE DARKEST HOUR TWINS! XD Tho I know what happens (kinda) 😛

Mistpaw X3
Mistpaw X3
February 15, 2017 10:27 pm

I SO agree with this list!!! I miss Yellowfang so much, she will always be one of my favorite characters… =( *sob sniff sob sob)

October 1, 2019 10:05 pm

i agree so much!! the prophecies begin deaths were on of my saddest deaths and about lionsheart death, i also felt angry when he was not mourned as much as he should have since he was noble and a good cat!! unlike you know who

Upcoming Events!

Recent Purrs


  • Rosefeather
  • The phone really isn't ringing
  • Wrenwing:kit
  • Agatha Long, a human version of Yellowfang by Mossnose
  • Rootspring-Shadowsight-and-Bristlefrost-The-Broken-Code-by Sparkpaw
  • tigerleaf
  • JayFeather
  • Warrior's At Sunset  by Jinx