Silverstream VS Millie and who will he pick for a mate in StarClan by Bluebellkit

Bluebellkit debates the pros and cons of Graystripe’s mates.

Artwork by DrakynWyrm

First I both like the two she-cats but I love Silverstream more than Millie though. Here is the article for who is the better mate for Graystripe lets begin.

First up Millie lets do the good things first and the bad things last.

Good things about Millie,
She helped Graystripe find true love again and have kits too
She helped support kittypets to join the clans than being treated like some pile of dirt
She made Graystripe not too sad about his former mate’s death
She is very respectful when she is not worrying about Briarlight

Bad things about Millie

She neglected her kits and was WAY to over protective for Briarlight
She snapped at other cats if she was angry and stressed about Briarlight ( some cats she snapped at Jayfeather and Blossomfall)
She said to Bramblestar if Briarlight was not saved in time enough and drown in the flood she said he never forgive him.


Good things about Sliverstream
Graystripe’s true first love
Help him not drown to death in the river
Always cared for him and always looked out for him even when she was a StarClan warrior
Gave Firestar and Mistystar a life

bad things about Silverstream
Did break the warrior code

Who will Graystripe when he will go to StarClan I think it is Silverstream because Kate did say he will maybe surely pick Silverstream and first love always wins

I do like Millie I understand why Millie cared for Briarlight more but did it a little too far I don’t hate her I think she is a good cat and that she does still love Bumblestripe and Blossomfall but is worry about Briarlight. And if she had a Clan name I think it would be Sliverstorm or Silverwing something like that so don’t hate Millie every warrior is unique in their own way so don’t but all your hate on her.

I like Sliverstream she did break the Warrior Code but out of true love. So don’t hate Silverstream because she was bossy or she was from a different Clan like that. So don’t put all her hate on Silverstream Graystripe loved her so just like her a tiny bit Sliverstream haters.

Hope you liked this article post a comment what you think.


Fan Articles


Leave a Reply to Embers of a Winter Dawn (Emberdawn) Cancel reply

  • Shes not millie is an ugly cat who thinks Graystripe likes her I mean come on Silverstream is WAY better. She would be a good role model for millie but millie will never be as great in a MILLION years(millie’s name doesn’t deserve to be capitialized)

      • If you’re a grammer freak, then you should say “all nameS”, instead of “all name.” All is plural, so names must be plural too. *Giggle* Anyway, I like Silver stream more.

        • “Grammar freak” can be used as an insult, so maybe try not to use it in that sense? I think you just meant to say “if you’re picky about grammar” (by the way, grammar is spelled with two a’s and no e’s 😉 ) 🙂 Besides, it could’ve just been a typo where they forgot to hit the s key 🙂

        • In my opinion, it’s the other way around: I think Millie sucks, and I love Silverstream.
          You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

    • He should choose Millie. It makes more sense as they’re mates in ThunderClan and have loved each other longer than he loved Silverstream.

      • In my opinion, he will choose Silverstream.
        Yes, he was with Millie longer, but he and Silverstream had a closer bond. Not only that, but Graystripe had a closer bond with Stormfur and Feathertail than Bumblestripe, Blossomfall, And Briarlight.
        Those are my reasons for believing he will pick Silverstream!
        You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

    • I hate Millie too!
      You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

  • I like Silverstream more. Millie never appealed to me as a character. She always felt like a unneeded random throw in character or someone’s OC. I also don’t like her personality, she is rude, disrespectful, and un-empathetic towards other cats. The Blossomfall/Briarlight drama just hit the nail on the coffin. I know its been argued that she still loves her other adult children. But, I can’t buy it, nothing in her actions shows that she still cares about them. She was apathetic when Blossomfall was sick and injured in Warriors:Omen of the stars: sign of the moon. The way she responded to Blossomfall was flat out mean. I’ll buy that she still loves them when she starts being kind to them. Actions speak louder than words. If she gets better later on the series and apologizes to Blossomfall, Bramblestar, and Jayfeather I might grow to like her. I think Graystripe will choose Silverstream, he was a better father to Stormfur and Feathertail than he was to Millie’s litter. He didn’t seem that close to her after Briarlight got hurt. We never see him spending time with Briarlight or comforting Millie.

    • Did you read the mangas with Millie? They make her feel less of a ‘throw-in.’ I actually read those prior to reading the books where Graystripe returns to the Clans with Millie, so she never really felt like a ‘throw-in character’ to me. She actually seemed well enough elaborated on, and I became a fan of her bond with Graystripe; while a bit unnecessary overall, it was sweet. I’m not really a fan of the direction the Erins chose to take her character in, though. She felt different in the Lost Warrior mangas. More likable.

      • Yeah, manga Millie is definitely better than book Millie.
        You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

    • Silver was a brat, and she was only in the books for 2 books! It- no. It’s not a good ship, and Silver should go die in a hole. HOWEVER, I don’t like Millie either, and the points you made about her are valid. I feel bad for Briar.

      • Silverstream should NOT go die in a hole! >:C
        You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

    • YES. Just… YES.
      You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

  • I definitely love Millie WAY more, but I won’t rant. But I think that the thing with Briarlight and Blossomfall has gone TOO FAR. I mean, if your daughter had broken her spine, you’d probably look after her more than the one with nothing wrong with her? I’m not hating on Blossomfall though!!! She’s amazing! 😉
    Everyone says she was just a lazy kittypet who was thrown in, but was she really? She did WAY more than Daisy (i’m Kinda meh on her tho) and loads of other warriors! I think she would seem more active if she had a warrior name? But I get that she wanted to keep her name! It would be like if you went to another country and they wanted you to change your name?
    I don’t know . . .

    • Daisy wasn’t a kitty pet. She was a barn cat. Also, she DID THINGS! Helping to take care of kits is an important job, and shouldn’t be underrated!
      You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

  • I like Silverstream better than Millie because she and Graystripe really loved each other and she never let him down. In the end of Crookedstar’s Promise (Spoiler ahead!) He sees Silverstream (his daughter) with Graystripe and HE STILL LETS HER MEET HIM! Crookedstar obviously though that Graystripe was good for her, or else he would have told her not to meet him again (I mean, he did, but wasn’t very thorough about making sure she didn’t) . his mate, Willowbreze, died in labor like Silverstream, so, off topic, I kinda feel sorry for him for having the cats he loved the most both died very young. back on topic, Millie and Graystripe are hardly ever seen together in Omen Of The Stars, and Millie is super mean. Millie is part of the reason that Blossomfall went to train in the Dark Forest, and BLOSSOMFALL KNOW THAT THE DARK FOREST IS WHERE EVIL CATS GO!!! Millie is a flea-ridden mange butt, in my opinion.
    Long Sory short, I hate Millie, and love Silverstream.
    Team Gray x Silver for me!

    • I’m Team Gray X Silver too!
      Also, you had a good point about the Crookedstar thing 😀
      You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

    • She is!
      You sit and weave your lies, like a fox trots through the night.

  • Oh my gosh, I HATE Silverstream. She was bratty, and the only reason she saved Grey was because she didn’t want the river to be dirty! IT’S NOT A GOOD SHIP! She was only in there for like what, 2 books?

  • I love Mille WAY more then Silverstream. Graystripe could not have made his way back to the forest when he got captured by the twolegs because of Millie. He even mentioned it in Graystripe’s adventure. She taught him how to speak dog, helped Graystripe in battles, and had the idea to ride on a monster to the sun-drown-place. If it weren’t for Millie, we would not see Graystripe for a LONG time after he got captured by the twolegs, or maybe even never seen again. It was even one of the best ship’s I’ve ever had in warrior cat history near the end of Graystripe’s adventure.
    But Grayxsilver for me? Nope. silverstream broke the warrior code AND made her father break his promise AND lose her. (In Crookedstar’s promise.) It also put a lot of stress on FireHeart. When Fethertail was made a warrior, it put a lot of stress on her for being half-clan, (and even though it’s half Graystripe’s fault, and it’s the whole point of the story.) And Silverstream was only in like, two books. that’s why I love MillieXGray much, much, more.

  • Uh so you said at the beginning that you liked Silver’stream better and i mean it turned out you thought she was the better mate……..this is why these articles of this certain type are hard. I would’ve personally dug up some more things about Silver’stream that are bad. But like, Millie is protective of her d i s a b l e d kit. I also think Silver’stream is a great warrior. To admit it really quick, Graystripe was kinda obsessed with Silver’stream. “Beauty and Bravery” as she usually thought in his adventures.

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art