My Top 10 Worst Warriors Characters by Ebonypaw

Ebonypaw shares their opinion on the worst cats of the series.

Artwork by OneXWarrior

Here’s my list for the top 10 worst warriors characters. I’m going to list some uncommon opinions so please be nice.

10. Moonflower

In my opinion, Moonflower wasn’t that great. She was a good mother, but that’s about it. She hung out with Stormtail way too much, whines about Goosefeather being an apprentice too much, doesn’t care that her crush almost left her brother to die, and picks fights with apprentices even though she was almost a warrior.

9. Spottedleaf

Sure she was cool in Spottedleaf’s Heart, but that’s about it. She has no character and is placeholder for everything. Placeholder medicine cat, placeholder Starclan cat, placeholder Firestar crush, etc

8. Thistleclaw

He’s the most to blame for Tigerstar being evil. He trains in the Dark Forest and expects everyone to love him. He caused the death of 30+ cats.

7. Raggedstar

Raggedstar is also an overrated cat. Everyone adores him, but he’s annoying. He doesn’t care about Yellowfang at all, and thinks Brokenstar should be leader just because he’s his son.

6. Oakstar

He thinks it’s right to banish a queen and three helpless kits during a strong storm. Sure he may have had a reason to banish Mapleshade, but her kits? Not only that, but during a STORM!

5. Lionblaze (PO3)

He has no character until OOTS.

4. Skystar

Many people like him after The First Battle, but I just find him annoying.

3. Silverstream

I don’t get why Silverstream gets all the love. She’s bratty and selfish. She thinks she can change the warrior code and everything goes her way just because she’s Crookedstar’s daughter.

2. Blossomfall

Almost #1. It’s her own fault she’s in the Dark Forest. Millie just scolds her and she takes it as hate and trains in the Dark Forest. She’s a spoiled brat and expects Ivypool to be her friend even though Blossomfall is a huge jerk to her and Dovewing.

1. Breezepelt.

I have absolute no idea how anyone could relate to him. He has a good mother and expects his father to always pay attention to him. He attacks a disabled medicine cat and a pregnant queen at the Moonpool just because he doesn’t get attention from one cat. If your father didn’t pay attention to you, would you murder? Look at Bluestar and Snowfur, they weren’t evil. Same with Crookedstar.

So that’s my opinion. If you disagree, please say so nicely. Thanks for reading!


Fan Articles


  • 1
  • 2

  • I DEFINITELY Agree (Mostly..) With Silver`Stream, Shes Not Really That Bratty And All (Opinion) But Shes DEFINITIETLYY Over-Rated 😛

  • Yes! Finally someone thinks Moonflower is bad. I honestly don’t like her because of her way of treating Goosefeather, complaining about Goosefeather getting a medicine cat name before she’s a warrior (I think but I kind of forgot if this happened), and thinks Goosefeather is weird.

  • Great article! It was interesting to read and you provided excellent reasons.

    But I don’t completely agree with all of this, sorry Rainy. I do agree on Thistleclaw, Breezepelt, and Oakstar. Oakstar and Thistleclaw are my least favorites, as well as Reedshine (Mapleshade’s Vengeance) and Appledusk. I like Moonflower because of her name 😛 and that she’s Bluestar’s mom. And that she loved her kits. But otherwise she was neutral for me. The others are all just kind of meh, don t love them, don t hate them. Except for Blossomfall. I feel bad for her, even though she’s kind of a brat. But still. She’d probably be in my top 10 list as like 8 or so, but I respect your opinion.

    It’s cool to read about other people’s thoughts though!

  • Im sooooo with you on Oakstar. How could he be so heartless, and the clan let him kick them out.
    Yeah, I know that Appledust was partly responsible for Birchface and Flowerpaw’s death but still.
    The kits were so young, not only that, THEY WERE KITS.
    That storm was worse than the storm in Bluestars SE when Thunderclan attacked Windclan.

  • I really love your article! Though I don’t agree with some of the points.
    Moonflower: I haven’t read much about her other than Bluestar’s prophecy so I really have nor right to judge 😅
    Spottedleaf: She’s not my favorite, but I did like her in OOTS because she was really kind, but that’s about it (I haven’t read Spottedleaf’s heart)
    Raggedstar: I have not read Yellowfang’s secret 🙁 this is sad….
    Oakstar: HE SUCKS, Never should have been leader
    Lionblaze: I like Lionblaze, maybe I don’t have good taste but I really liked his character, and I think he has character in POT and in OOTS.

    And the rest I agree with!

  • I agree completely on 10, 9, 8, 6, 5, 3, and 2!
    I liked Raggedstar. I think he just spoiled Brokenstar because he felt bad. I mean both of them grew up with only one parent figure. Brokenstar grew up like Breezepelt.
    I like Breezepelt because of his awesome redemption arc, I mean Crowfeather’s Trial! Awesome!!!
    Oakstar made me super annoyed because his banishment of Mapleshade wasn’t completely Warrior Code based! It was just because his son died on accident!
    I would love to see what Birchface thought in StarClan!
    Really good points though! I just have a soft spot for cats with sad childhoods.

  • Here are mine (not that anyone cares). This is MY opinion, Not yours.
    10. Bramblestar
    9. Stormtail
    8. Feathertail
    7. Spottedleaf
    6. Briarlight
    5.Rainflower & Lizardstripe
    4. Appledusk & Reedshine
    3. Breezepwlt
    2. Millie
    1. Dovewing

  • I agree with all of these except for Moonflower because I haven’t read much about her outside of Bluestar’s Prophecy

  • I agree with a lot of these

    1 – Spottedleaf (Before I read the last hope I was like “Just die already!”)
    2 – Silverstream (EXTREMELY overrated)
    3 – Leafpool (She’s not horrible, but the forbidden love thing is kind of getting a bit old…)
    4 – Bramblestar (Do I really have to talk about him?)
    5 – Squirrelflight (Same reason as Silverstream)