Sparktooth questions Firestar’s true feelings.ย
Hey once again, bloggers! Sparktooth is here! I was rereading a few of the older Warriors books, and began to think something I never considered first reading it. I began to wonder if Firestar cared for Spottedleaf a little more than Sandstorm. FireXSand is one of my favorite ships. So I would find it pretty upsetting if that was the case. But Firestar is one of my favorite characters, so chances are that feeling would go pretty quickly XD.
โThe tortoiseshell she-cat padded toward the cave entrance and paused for a heartbeat, her pelt brushing his[Firestar]. Too soft for Sandstorm to hear, she murmured โSometimes, I’d give anything for things to be different.โโ -Firestarโs Quest, pg. 402.
This scene caused me to question Firestarโs feelings toward Sandstorm. Sandstorm was very hot-headed in this scene, and I donโt blame her. Firestar was acting very nice to Spottedleaf, a lot more than was necessary, I think. What I mean is it almost seemed like they were flirting or something. Sandstorm was his mate! Iโm not saying Firestar doesnโt love Sandstorm because he certainly does. But Firestar lost someone who he fell in love with before: Spottedleaf. Even though he loves Sandstorm, that doesnโt mean heโll stop loving Spottedleaf. Itโs exactly like with Graystripe with Silverstream and Millie. He still loves Millie, but wonโt stop loving Silverstream. But I still canโ get over how much Firestar mentions Spottedleaf. And I mean, he mentions her a LOT. Donโt believe me? Here:
โโI think theyโre wonderful names,โ Firestar replied. The dark ginger Squirrelkit for her fluffy tail, of course, and Leafkit in memory of Leafstar-and perhaps of Spottedleaf too.โ -Firestarโs Quest, pgs. 509-510.
โFirestar stared at his daughter as though he were seeing her for the first time. โI wish you couldโve known Spottedleaf,โ he murmured. โYou remind me of her.โโ -Dawn, pg. 141.
There is plenty more than just two if you pay attention to the books. But those are the two I decided to include in this article. Moving on, ever notice how when Firestar smells Spottedleaf when heโs dreaming, he describes it as โSpottedleafโs sweet scent.โ I donโt remember him describing Sandstormโs scent that way. And in The Darkest Hour, Firestar wanders by the river sometime before the battle with BloodClan. He sits there and begs for Spottedleaf to help him, or send him some kind of sign. Why didnโt he go find Sandstorm?
After reading this, youโre probably like, โFirestar hates Sandstorm! Why is he pretending to love her when he obviously loves Spottedleaf!?โ But…is that really true?
โโI love you, Sandstorm,โ Firestar put in. โYouโll never be second-best for me. My love for you belongs here and now, in the life that we share-and it will last for all the moons to come, I promise.โโ -Firestarโs Quest, pgs. 401-402.
So maybe itโs just me. Maybe Firestar loves both of them equally. But do you remember the first quote from Firestarโs Quest I used? That happened right after the last quote I used.
Well, thereโs my thoughts for you. Now that I read this over, I made Firestar sound a little more like the antagonist. Comment below if you think I should write a part two!
I’m actually pretty glad Spottedleaf got killed by Mapleshade because it would be really weird if Sandstorm went to Star clan and Firestar had to choose sandstorm or spottedleaf.
Idk your questionia
??
Dude
Listen to this story
Sandstorm: SPOTTEDLEAF SPOOTEDLEAF SPOOOOOTEDLEAFFF
Spottedleaf: Yes!
Sandstorm: Firestar likes me more than you
Spottedleaf: No he doesnโt
Sandstorm: He does -w-
Spottedleaf: I-I Is it true?
Sandstorm: Hell yea!
Sandstorm: FIRESTAR!!!
Spottedleaf: :<
Firestar: yes…yes!
Sandstorm: Is it true that were
Firestar: ?
Sandstorm: M-mates?
Spottedleaf: !?!!
Firestar: ermmmm
Sandstorm: ???!
Firestar: Heck
Firestar: Heckkkkk
Firestar: Heck nah!
Sandstorm: >:0
Spottedleaf: cmon Firestar!
Firestar: Okie dough!
Sandstorm: Iโll teach her >:)
Spottedleaf: Firestar!…Firestar!!!
Sandstorm: He died he went in clawfaceโs den last time I saw him!
Spottedleaf: T-thanks sandstorm!
Sandstorm: >:)
Spottedleaf: Heh heh hello claw face?
Claw face: Who dare wake me up from my slumber?!
Spottedleaf: :<
*spottedleaf dies *
Sandstorm: Firestar!
Firestar: Iโm on this tree
Firestar: I saved a kit from falling :3
Sandatorm: F-firestar! * face palms*
Firestar: Oh hey Graystripe!
Firestar: Greystripe? Are you doing your tree breakin rule?
Firestar: Wait….
Sandstorm: 0-0 no never gonna get a m8 -~-
Wait one more..
The claw face and Mapleshade kill spottedleaf show :p
Claw face: Hello Mapleshade!
Mapleshade: Hello claw-face!!:
Spottedleaf: |~|
Spottedleaf: Hehe Iโm danger
Sandstorm: Meh fav show :3
Sandstorm: right firestar!? * head gets on his shoulder *
Firestar: Noi hate seeing my wife die :p
Sandstorm: Mwa :3
Firestar: stop….
Greystripe: hi :3
Greystripe: Did I have to come ๐
Firestar: No -~-
Mapleshade: Letโs kill spottedleaf claw-face ๐
Claw-face: Ok Mapleshade ๐
But just to respect sandstorm sandstorm x firestar is good too I guess :>
I think firestar is confirmed with sandstorm. But it doesnโt mean that firestar hates spottedleaf he loves both but just still mostly sandstorm. Spottedleaf is ok with sandxfire because she was the one who made it happen. Unfortunately spottedleaf is jealous cause sandstorm got kits. She still loves there ship and clearly thinks itโs fine. She clearly gave firestar a mate not him finding a mate. Spottedleaf got more building blocks to firestars family tree!!!
So, I think in the battle with BloodClan he begged for Spottedleafs help, because sheโs in StarClan, their sopposed to be all knowing, right? And he probably just likes the sent of herbs or something, spottedleafโs a MEDICINE cat. I vote Firestar and Sandstorm. Hands down. No reason to break the warrior code, again, for her, when you have a mate you love already.
I think Firestar should have made a choice, and been a loyal mate. Its like he was cheating on Sandstorm!
In the books spottedleaf tries to make firestar get a mate. Sandstorm was his mate. He loved sandstorm. But spottedleaf the girl who gave firestar sandstorm didnโt get love back for example at least a thank you or a lick!!! Sandstorm got kits. Iโm ok with spottedleaf not having kits…Iโm not overreacting but sandstorm shouldโve got someone who was not firestar. I donโt know if firestar fits well with a unkind warrior…This is just my opinion. If this is wrong idc…
Sandstorm and firestar are mates. They made kits and stayed with each other for every book…But spottedleaf really was ok and fine about not having kits or having mates…Oh and also I relazied everyone in thunderclan loves spottedleaf and wants to be mates with her but sadly sheโs a medicine cat…FirestarxSandstorm is one of my favorite ships but Iโm curious…Why is spottedleaf a medicine cat?? Oh and also spottedxfire shouldโve been confirmed. Because spottedleaf is ofc left alone in some abyss of no mates and no kits!! Like she canโt grow her family!!! ERIN ARE YOU CRAZY!?!?!? Iโm not overreacting and overwhelmed but I sorta hate sandxfire sortaa!!! Cause Erin is โ so smart โ sheโs making medicine cats not grow there FAMILY!! Iโm not disrespecting her! Iโm just saying…I love Erin Hunter sheโs the best but still. Pls Erin change this big mistake :>
They can’t change big events like that in past books. Maybe in StarClan, she was able to help take care of the kits who died young and maybe, just maybe, she found someone to care for there as well ๐
That sounds like a wonderful idea of what she could do! ๐
I headcanon that Honeyfern takes care of kits in StarClan, and it seems like something Spottedleaf would do as well.
Oh, wow, Embix is alive! Hi, Embix!
…I’ve been alive this whole time ๐
can confirm that embix hasnt been killed and resurrected within the last calendar year :3
By the way, Erin Hunter is actually multiple authors writing under a pen name, one of them runs this blog !!