Fawnberry lists reasons as to why Millie was a good cat.
whY HELLO THERE! I’m Fawnberry. Or fawnpaw at the moment. And today, I’m gonna tell you why I LIKE MILLIE! Yes, yes, I like Millie. Shun me. And I’m going to show you why ALL YOUR ARGUMENTS ARE INVALID! Also, this is just my opinion.
SPOILER WARNING: THE SIGHT AND ONWARDS, PLUS ALL GRAYSTRIPE MANGAS
‘She doesn’t really love Graystripe. And Graystripe doesn’t love her.’
Um… That is quite invalid. If you’ve read the final Graystripe manga, you can see that she does in fact love Graystripe. Also, why would Graystripe ask her to be his mate if he didn’t love her? After Graystripe’s request to be her mate, she says something along the lines of “Graystripe, to be with you… That’s what I wanted from the moment I met you.” So, he does in fact love her, and she loves him.
‘She’s a horrible mom!!’
No. Correction: ‘She’s a overprotective mom.’ She loves all her kits equally. When Briarlight got injured, she was so worried about her, she shut her other kits out without knowing. She wanted Briarlight to live, to thrive as much as she could after her fatal injury. You may argue by pointing out the fight with Blossomfall, but no. Millie had accidentally shut out her other kits, and the way I see it, she felt bad about the fight as soon as she realized.
Millie is going to make an amazing grandma, since she really DOES care for all her kits.
‘Graystripe only chose her because she looked like Silverstream!’
Well, I’d like to point out that in the MANGAS, Millie is a cream tabby she-cat. So if that wasn’t a mistake, although I’m pretty sure it was, Millie looks nothing like Silverstream. And even if Millie does, Graystripe definitely did not choose her for that reason alone. Sure, that might’ve been ONE of the reasons, but he most likely chose her for her attitude, her kindness to him, and many other things. Millie and Graystripe have been mates since The Sight, which is actually quite a long time. They still show affection to EACHOTHER in the elders den, and neither of them have died yet. I am sure Millie will try as hard as she can to have her grandchildren know her, since we really do need another grandparent-grand kit relationship. Yellowfang and Silverflame was adorable.
Well, anyways, I’m done now! Next up: