The Better Mate by Sky

Who is the better mate? Sky ponders the long argued question.

Hello, BlogClan!

Today, I’ll be analyzing the pros and cons of mates who loved the same cat. Yes. I have unpopular opinions sometimes.

GRAYSTRIPE – MILLIE VS. SILVERSTREAM

SILVERSTREAM

Pros –

Saved Graystripe from drowning

Matched his personality

Was a kind and loving she-cat who protected and watched her kits from the stars

Cons

Different Clan, which means breaking the warrior code

Distracted Graystripe from everyday ThunderClan life

MILLIE

Pros –

Saved him from dogs

Helped him find a way back to ThunderClan

Been with him longer

Cons –

Bad mother

Graystripe didn’t pay much attention to her, which makes it seem like he didn’t love her as much

Made Blossomfall and Bumblestripe neglected, and was the cause of Blossomfall training in the DF

Don’t get mad at me…. but I think Silverstream wins! Sparktooth, you don’t have to write a Millie-support paragraph again 😉

BERRYNOSE – HONEYFERN VS POPPYFROST

HONEYFERN

Pros –

The cat who made Berrynose show his kind side

His first love(I’m including this here because everyone thought he was an obnoxious jerk, and, well, they still do, but they didn’t see his good side)

Cons –

None?

POPPYFROST

Pros –

Bore him kits

Healed his heart

Cons –

Honeyfern’s sister and Berrynose’s second love, which looks fishy for Berrynose

Looks like a substitute for Honeyfern, as Berrynose mated with her basically days after Honeyfern’s death

Honeyfern wins. Yes, this is an unpopular opinion, but I can’t say that I wasn’t upset when Berrynose got Honeyfern’s SISTER PREGNANT SO SOON AFTER HONEYFERN DIED SERIOUSLY I CANT STAND IT.

Anyways….

CLEAR SKY – BRIGHT STREAM VS STORM VS STAR FLOWER

BRIGHT STREAM

Pros –

Let him show is loving side

Made him seem happy

His heart broke so bad when she died, which was a pivoting point for him, which shows how much he loved her

Cons –

Died? IDK

STORM

Pros –

Gave him a new chance for a mate

Bore him a kit(that he didn’t care about wut)

Cons –

Didn’t really like him anymore afte what he did, something that he deserved

STAR FLOWER

Pros –

Gave him a chance for a real family and redemption

Healed him sort of

Cons –

Dated his DARN SON WTH

Very fishy cat

Overall, I’d say Bright Stream wins. OKAY DON’T KILL ME PLEASE!!!!! BUT I HATE STAR FLOWER AND THINK THAT STORM IS BETTER OFF WITHOUT HIM….

Moving on…

BLUESTAR – TRUSHPELT VS. OAKHEART

TRUSHPELT

Pros –

Cared for her even after he realized she didn’t love him back

Was a kind and good cat

Cons –

It was fishy how he was all, “Oh I’ll be their father in ThunderClan.”

Bluestar didn’t love him back

OAKHEART

Pros –

Bluestar’s true love

Hated the fact that they could only be together for one night

Raised his kits as loyal RiverClanners

Cons –

RiverClan cat