Ashwillow shares a theory about the former ThunderClan cat, Ravenpaw.
Alright, before you blow up the comments, I’m not proposing this theory simply because they have similar physical appearances and share the same prefix, though that is a contributing factor to this theory and will be mentioned. The main part of this theory is actually that Ravenwing was given a second chance as Ravenpaw to keep a secret.
Okay, to start off simple, we are going to be comparing their physical appearances according to the Warriors Wiki.
Ravenpaw: Small, sleek, skinny, jet-black with a tiny white dash on his chest, green eyes, and a long, thin white-tipped tail.
Ravenwing: Small, thick-furred black tom with dark, sky-blue eyes.
Since we have seen Ravenpaw more than Ravenwing in the series, it only makes sense that more details regarding his appearance is made known to the readers. Anyways, as you can tell, both cats are small and black, and share the “Raven” prefix. However, Ravenwing lacks the white markings Ravenpaw has, as well as having a different eye color. This could be one reason why the theory might not work. While they don’t look exactly the same, they are similar, and Cinderpelt and Cinderheart do not look exactly alike either according to the Warriors Wiki, and as we all know Cinerpelt was resurrected as Cinderheart. ( I am aware the Wiki counts every little detail mentioned, even if it doesn’t stay consistent in the rest of the series but still )
Now let’s go over their personalities, which are not similar at all. Could there be a reason behind this?
Ravenpaw: At first, Ravenpaw was jumpy, scared, and unsure of himself. (Though as he grows older we can see he grows out of this)
Ravenwing: This cat is confident as well as calm. He didn’t hesitate to ask Mapleshade questions and to tell on her. (However, we had no idea what he was like when he was a kit/apprentice)
Pretty different, right? Here’s the reasoning why Ravenpaw’s personality was so different even if he was Ravenwing in his past life: When Ravenwing was killed, his death could have shattered his trust and his calm personality, that’s why he was so jittery when he was brought back as Ravenpaw.
Okay, now we’re going to go over similar instances in their lives:
-Ravenpaw and Ravenwing both witnessed something they were not supposed to see, know, or reveal.
-Ravenwing figured out that Mapleshade had kits with a cat from another Clan. He was killed because he told her he knew her secret to her face, and also told his leader.
-Ravenpaw also witnessed something he wasn’t meant to, and didn’t tell anyone until later.
Ravenpaw was so nervous around Tigerclaw, because he was in the same predicament as his past life: knowing something he shouldn’t have known. This time, Ravenpaw kept the secret until the right time.
Conclusion: Ravenpaw is Ravenwing and was given a second chance by StarClan to keep a secret until the right time.
What do you guys think of this theory?