My Top 3 Most Underrated and Overrated Ships by Hazelfeather

Art by DarkBroken

Hazelfeather lists some ships in the fandom.

Hey! I’m Hazelfeather, and this is my first article on BlogClan!

So, today I am going to be analysing the most underrated (and hated) ships and the most overrated ships, whether it be because another ship overshadows it, or for different reasons! This is my opinion, feel free to post yours in the comments. Without further ado, let us begin!

Underrated Ships

1. Leafpool x Crowfeather (LeafxCrow)

Honestly, this is really hated and underrated because of Mothpool (Mothwing x Leafpool). A lot of Mothpool shipper keep on saying stuff like “Oh, Leaf x Crow sucks, Crowfeather abused Leafpool!” This is not true! Crowfeather loved Leafpool, and sure, the ship could have had more development, but really, Crowfeather and Leafpool loved each other deeply and it broke their hearts to leave each other in Twilight.

2. Jayfeather x Half Moon (Jay’s Moon)

This is so underrated because of Jay x Stick. Jayfeather finally falls in love, only to have the fandom ship him with an inanimate object! Come on people, the stick is NOT alive! Really, I wonder who invented Jay x Stick. Yes, originally Jayfeather didn’t love Half Moon. But he admitted that he loved her and when leaving the mountains, he also had to leave Half Moon. This is probably my favorite canon ship, and they are so sweet together. This is also really sad, two lovers separated by time…

3. Lionblaze x Cinderheart (LionxCinder)

There are several people who ship this, but I’m focusing on the hate it is given by the majority of Lion x Heather shippers. Cinderheart and Lionblaze loved each other, but Cinderheart thought that she couldn’t be with Lionblaze because of the prophecy and her being Cinderpelt. In the end, Lionblaze’s love for Cinderheart convinced her to be his mate. That’s true love, that is. Just because Lionblaze and Heathertail roleplayed or whatever in the tunnels, doesn’t mean they could be mates anyway, due to them being in different Clans.

Overrated Ships

1. Jayfeather x Stick

Yeah, I think you saw this coming. I am a die-hard JayxHalf shipper, and there are way too many fanfics, fanart and other stuff about it, and I wish that I could find more JayxHalf fanfics. The stick is an inanimate object for StarClan’s sake! How can you love an item?! Please, don’t rage at me for not shipping this. Also, this is my own opinion, you can have your own.

2. Mothwing x Leafpool (Mothpool)

Yeah, there are so many shippers of this. I don’t get it. Just because Leafpool thinks about how she’s beautiful and such, doesn’t mean they’re instantly in love. You can consider a friend to look beautiful (platonic love) because they look nice.

3. Ravenpaw x Barley

I ship this. But it is pretty overrated…

Honorable Mentions (overrated)
Alderheart x Needletail
Alderheart x Velvet
Jayfeather x Briarlight
Tigerheart x Dovewing

Well, that wraps up my top 3 most underrated and overrated ships!

Hazelfeather out!


Fan Articles

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
December 21, 2018 7:40 pm

Jaymoon forever!!! I agreed with everything you said though I do love Tiger z Dove & Needle x Alder. But great article, I really enjoyed it!

July 27, 2019 8:32 pm

I agree with you. Even though I ship CrowxNight (I’m the only one).

αмвιxιε sнαℓт үεεт нεя ωαү тняσυgн cσяσηα ~sριяιткιт/sкү ~
αмвιxιε sнαℓт үεεт нεя ωαү тняσυgн cσяσηα ~sριяιткιт/sкү ~
January 12, 2020 9:55 am

Love your article!
gaspie i ship JayXBrair!

June 27, 2020 7:47 pm

I ship JayxBriar too 😀
I like this article

♥️Dancing in the Rain/Raindance (Rainyyy)♥️
July 1, 2020 5:42 pm

I know no one ships this, but I ship Cinderpaw/heart and Jaypaw/feather…

Jå¥'§ Wïñg åñÐ Hål£ Mððñ
Jå¥'§ Wïñg åñÐ Hål£ Mððñ
July 8, 2020 3:52 pm

Jay’s Moon FOREVER!!!

August 31, 2020 5:11 am

I love it! Mwah! CoughcoughIshipBriarfeathercoughcough

September 15, 2020 9:49 pm

Some other ship names for Half Moon and Jayfeather-Half Jay,Moonfeather

September 21, 2020 11:32 pm

CrowxLeaf isn’t hated because of Mothpool shippers it’s hated because it makes no sense at all but Mothpool doesn’t make sense either and they’re related so that’s weird

September 21, 2020 11:33 pm

AlderxNeedle isn’t necessarily overrated in my opinion and AlderxVelvet is definitely not overrated no one talks about them and by them I mean him and Velvet.

Shimmer in the snowy sky(Shimmerpaw/sky)
Shimmer in the snowy sky(Shimmerpaw/sky)
October 14, 2020 6:30 pm

I totally agree on the over rated ships. WHO CAN LOVE A STICK. Also, he was NOT in love with it, it was one of his only connections to Half Moon.

swoop of snow owl (snowswoop)
swoop of snow owl (snowswoop)
December 29, 2020 3:24 am

millie x silverstream. shipping wars? make it gay.

Upcoming Events!

Recent Purrs


  • Rosefeather
  • The phone really isn't ringing
  • Wrenwing:kit
  • Agatha Long, a human version of Yellowfang by Mossnose
  • Rootspring-Shadowsight-and-Bristlefrost-The-Broken-Code-by Sparkpaw
  • tigerleaf
  • JayFeather
  • Warrior's At Sunset  by Jinx