Mintrose shares their opinion on some disliked characters from the series.

Hello fellow warriors! Today I will be giving you my opinion on the most hated Warriors characters in history!
1) Rainflower
I like hate her. Who does that? What she did was inexcusable. You can’t brag because one of your kits is so handsome and cute and adorable, then when he breaks his jaw, you don’t care about his health and decide to rename him from Stormkit to Crookedkit, then totally ignore him his whole life and favor his brother Oakkit instead!!! Way to go Shellheart, good thing you left that mange-pelt. In Crookedstar’s Promise, she calls Stormkit an ugly mess and keeps Crookedkit a kit while his brother is an apprentice, apprenticed to his father, that’s because Rainflower asked for that. Dark Forest.
2) Palebird
She wasn’t that bad. I mean she did ignore Tallstar when he was an apprentice and a warrior and she didn’t let him drink milk when he was a kit. But imagine you are pregnant and you have your kits. One of them dies, your mate (in her case, Sandgorse) doesn’t seem to care about you and you get depression. Becoming mates with Woolytail that soon after Sandgorse’s death wasn’t a great choice, but it’s obvious Sandgorse didn’t love her or care about her while Woolytail did. StarClan.
3) Breezepelt
Breezepelt sure seems like a fox-hearted evil cat in the main arc. But if you read Crowfeather’s Trial he’s not that bad. I don’t really know. He did take on Heathertail as a mate and had kits, proved his loyalty and most importantly apologized to Lionblaze for trying to murder him during the Great Battle. StarClan? Comment what you think down below 🙂
4) Spottedleaf
People say she was a stalker, creepy, a Mary-Sue and waaaaay too old for Firestar. Well, correct she was. But she also helped Leafpool, Firestar and lots of other cats as well as dying a second time to save Sandstorm. I think her character needed some more development or more flaws.
5) Firestar
People hate Firestar because later in the books he is portrayed like a Mary-Sue. Firestar was great in the first arc but after that he lost development. he was the role model leader and looked perfect. In other words, his flaws disappeared when we lost his POV.
And that was it! Uh, bye bye and thanks for reading this! 😀
I agree with Breezepelt part tbh O_O
I agree with Breezepelt part tbh O_O it makes sense.
Nice article! The Rainflower thing, I used to hate her, but I finished Crookedstar’s Promise and at the end, she isn’t so bad. I still hate her though, XD 😀
I just learned that people hate Spottedleaf.
I didn’t (and don’t) have any complaints about her. She was the go-to prophecy giver and she filled that role the best. I have read the series and I think she might have liked Firestar some too much but that is what makes her interesting. It’s what sets her apart from all of the other StarClan prophecy givers that were close to Firestar (cough Yellowfang cough Cinderpelt cough).
I agree. I don’t have any complaints about Spottedleaf, either. I like her and think she was a good character. 🙂
I know, when my friend told me that she hated Spottedleaf my world changed. I am now on the dark side, I am anti-Spottedleaf. Goodbye, guys.
we will miss you 😔
I can’t believe I wrote this 😛
I’ve not read Crowfeather’s Trial, and I love Breezepelt, and he should have been one of the Three. StarClan indefinitely! I hate Rainflower. I don’t get why everyone hates Palebird, because I think she was a good character. Nice article 👍
Hi! Nice article. Here are my opinion on all these cats…
Rainflower: I HATE HER! WHY DID SHE CHANGE STORMKIT’S NAME,WHY? THAT WAS JUST CRUEL!
Palebird- I don’t HATE her, but I don’t really LIKE her either.
Breezepelt: I HATE him! He tired to kill Poppyfrost, a PREGNANT QUEEN, and Jayfeather, a BLIND MEDICINE CAT! And he was always so MEAN and just- UGH.
Spottedleaf: Spottedleaf is awesome! Even though she had feelings for Firestar, she stayed loyal to her duties as a medicine cat. She kept guiding Firestar and his kin after her death, and was just amazing!
(Also, I don’t think she was too old for Firestar, but that’s a topic for another time. 😉 )
Firestar- Firestar is my favorite Clan leader. He is cool! He’s a great leader, awesome mate, and wonderful father. Seriously, why do people hate him? He’s awesome!
Spotty is a bean.
no kidding!
Stormstar
yes!
it sounds so regal
( i am ignoring the fact that if he didn’t break his jaw he probably wouldn’t be a leader)
i think Breezepelt is cool. he was like “sorry for trying to murder you and stuff”
i think people hate Firestar just to hate him
I really like Breezepelt
I don’t know much about Rainflower
Palebird- Ok
Breezepelt- I HATE YOU BREEZEPELT
Spottedleaf- Ok
Firestar- I HATE FIRESTAR HE IS THE WORST LEADER(well, Leopardstar and Raggedstar are the worst) HE WAS WAY TOO BIASED AND NEVER FOLLOWED THE WARRIOR CODE HE MADE LEAFPOOL A MEDICINE CAT AGAIN JUST BECAUSE SHE WAS HIS DAUGHTER AND REFUSED TO APPOINT ANOTHER DEPUTY WHEN GRAYSTRIPE WAS CAPTURED AND GRAYSTRIPE WAS ALREADY TOO OLD TO STAY AS DEPUTY ANYWAYS AND HE MADE INFLUENCED AND BIASED DECISIONS AND WAS A TERRIBLE LEADER.
whew
I see what you mean when you say he was biased about Leafpool becoming a medicine cat.
But, if we look at Mothwing and how Mistystar unmade her a medicine cat, then made her a medicine cat over what is, arguably, a more important issue in a medicine cat’s life, we see that Mothwing was remade a medicine cat without that bias. This means that I think that (what a mouthful) Leafpool would have been remade a medicine cat regardless if she was Firestar’s daughter.
I am trying to think of a noticeably better leader than Firestar and I am having a hard time. Sunstar comes to mind but his character wasn’t explored like Firestar’s. Sure we see him as a deputy and then a leader, but we never see things from his perspective. I think that all of the leaders who could potentially be better leaders than Firestar were all not explored as much as Firestar.
Palebird should not receive so much hate. I mean, she had depression.
I agree with these!
my opinions::
rainflower:same!!!!
Palebird:i don’t hate her but i don’t like her..
Breezepelt:i absoulutely HATE him..
Spottedleaf:i like her but i hate Fire x Spotted ship ;3
Firestar:luvvvvvvvvv
I think Spottedleaf is such a maiden in distress and a huge Mary-sue. Keep in mind this is my opinion. I wish she had more time to kick butt than be an overrated character.
I completely agree!
Though the reason I think she is seen as a Mary-Sue (she does end up getting murdered at a young age and dying again, so she doesn’t exactly have the happiest life) is that she didn’t get very much development. I do like her character and the role she was filling. It’s unfortunate she went to StarClan so early because by the time most cats get to StarClan their personalities have been solidified and won’t be changed.
*SPOILERS* I don’t think Firestar deserves the hate. Don’t get me wrong some people love him (that’s me) but some people don’t like him. He was awesome in the first arc because he saved the clans from Tigerstar and defeated Scourge. In the second arc he was a little annoying for keeping Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight apart but he thought it was for the good of the clans. In the Last Hope, he saves the clans for like the millionth time and that takes his last life. I do not see why he is bad.