My little problem with the 4 Clans by Frostmoon

Frostmoon shares their opinion on the clans before the Great Journey took place.

(some spoilers)

Okay. I know you might be thinking, “Frostmoon, everyone knows that with so many books published, there’s bound to be SOME mistakes!” Yeah, but I’m not here to point out cover art failures or grammatical errors or name errors. I’m here to point out an ongoing problem. BTW, I just finished reading Dawn, so… this is not into the Lake territory issues yet. I’ll do that later, because I can’t get the next book, because the bookstores are closed cause of corona virus.

I don’t have much to say about WindClan, but they’re the Clan that is apparently ALWAYS stealing prey.

My problem with RiverClan is that they’re the ones always getting into forbidden relationships…(Oakheart x Bluestar, Silverstream x Graystripe, Feathertail x Crowfeather, Stormfur x Brook, etc). They can also be depicted, at points, as the laziest cats in the forest that grow fat because they’re just so lucky they have a river that is conveniently always full of easy-to-catch fish.

ThunderClan and ShadowClan I have the most issues with. For ShadowClan, so, first of all, ShadowClan is treated like Slytherin is in Harry Potter. ShadowClan is always harboring the most vicious villains(Tigerstar, Brokenstar, Darkstripe, etc) and is so secretive and mysterious, and they don’t trust ANYONE, and they’re, as the Secrets of the Clans field guide itself says(not an exact quote, but I just read it a few minutes ago) -also, I think the field guides should be unbiased throughout the Clans – the field guide says something along the lines of “ShadowClan is aggressive, battle-hungry, greedy for territory, etc) under the Clan characteristic section. Does it list anything positive about the Clan? NO! *not that I can remember* just that ShadowClan is the MOST EVIL VICIOUS MONSTERS AND SHOULD BE TERMINATED!

wElCoMe to Gryffindor! ThunderClan is the best Clan ever! Yeah. So you know how I was saying under ShadowClan Clan characteristics in Secrets of the Clans, there’s almost nothing positive? Well, in best Clan ThunderClan, there’s almost nothing NEGATIVE. Why is ThunderClan always the best one? As far as I can tell, the only two bad things about ThunderClan were Mapleshade and Thistleclaw. That’s it. ThunderClan, like, NEVER dares steal prey from other territories, but the other 3 Clans seem to be doing it ALL THE TIME!

Yeah, that’s just some little issues with the Clans. I’m a ShadowClan cat, but my mom was WindClan, so yeah… I’m HalfClan!!! Anyways, the Clans themselves are fun, and I like the super editions because you get a look inside the other Clans that you don’t get in the main series because they’re always focused on ThunderClan.

Good luck fellow warriors,


Fan Articles


Recent Purrs