Best Super Edition Ever? by Emberheart

Emberheart shares their list of the best super editions in the series

Official artwork by Wayne McLoughlin


Being someone’s who’s read almost every super edition, I think I have a pretty experienced opinion on this. Bluestar’s Prophecy: I think Kate and Vicky agree that this is the best warriors super edition. I have a ranking, please note that I haven’t read Mapleshade’s vengeance so if it’s not up here, just tell me where you think it deserves to be.

Bluestar’s Prophecy [This is an absolutely amazing book because Bluestar is a wonderful and easily relatable character, and I have a soft spot for books that make me cry five times in public!]

Crookedstar’s Promise [I LOVE Mapleshade’s backstory and I also really relate to and fall in love with books where the main character isn’t good with relationships and I also LOVE deception… I hate Rainflower, she is evil. :P]

Tallstar’s Revenge [Okay, I really like having an inside look at WindClan because they’re so different from the other clans with tunneling and moor running, and their weird way of hunting… Again, I have a problem with how much I like characters with family issues and really sad parts.Tallstar X Jake is great.]

Yellowfang’s Secret [Yellowfang has always been one of my favorite characters, and seeing her young and naive was very interesting to me. It really gives you a new perspective on the grumpy old medicine cat.]

Firestar’s Quest [Sandstorm and Firestar arguing always gets me! Sandstorm is just so sassy and I was on Power of Three when I read this one, so I missed Firestar’s perspective]

SkyClan’s Destiny [I really thought this one was good because SkyClan is still figuring thighs out on how to be a clan and don’t have a lot of cats. I also like the relationship between Leafstar and Billystorm because Leafstar is such a complicated character.]

Hollyleaf’s Story [Oh come on! Hollyleaf X Fallen Leaves. SO CUTE!]

Bramblestar’s Storm [I love Jesse and I feel like everything would be better if Squirrelflight chose Ashfur while Bramblestar went with Jesse. Sorry!]

Crowfeather’s Trial [I love Crowfeather and it’s nice to see other sides of Breezepelt for a change.] Squirrelflight’s Hope [Idk… it’s not as good as the other ones but if it wasn’t up here people would be MAD.]

Leafpool’s Wish [It was good to know how Leafpool felt through this but it was so short of a book.]

Anyway, Jayfeather should have a super edition! MORE JAYFEATHER CONTENT I LOVE HIM! JayXStick JayXBriar JayXHalf Oh gosh Jayfeather’s a floosie…

Fan Articles


  • I fully agree with this BP is the best!
    As for Mapleshade’s Vengeance, that one has a deep rabbit hole of opinions there…

  • Great article! I’ve read SkyClan’s Destiny but not Firestar’s Quest, so I should probably read that one soon. I’ve been wanting to.

  • I disagree with your opinion that JessyxBramble and SquirrelxAsh should’ve happened. I hate Jessy and Ashfur, maybe if Ashfur were still alive they should’ve ended together.

  • I disagree that Jessy x Bramble
    Jessy just downright moved her nest next to Bramblestar when he had a living mate,and Bramblestar was too weak in mind. Bramblestar never loved Jessy.

  • Great article! In my opinion Squirrelflight’s Hope is AMAZING… this was probably written before Graystripe’s vow came out but I love that one too

  • I disagree with your opinion on Bramblestar’s Storm because I think that bramblestar and Squirrelflight are a cute couple even though bramble could have rewarded her a bit better in squirrelflight’s hope. I don’t like Jessy because she was pretty annoying, saying things like “oh, I thought it would be okay if I took over the apprentices’ training” I just think bramblexsquirrel is cute overall.

  • Why is Bluestar’s Prophecy at the top?
    The book had way too little info for it to be over 300 pages
    Wasn’t Moonflower a terrible sister to GooseFeather ? I all felt was justice at her death , and Snowfur was annyoing and mean and was also a terrible sister and did the same thing her mother did.

    Wanna know what book that made me cry?
    Crowfeathers trial
    I cried when Breezepelt was being tormented by Berrynose and Spiderleg at the same time!
    They basically spoke out in a gathering (which is wrong) and Breezepelt was surroned by hostile stares from the other Clans. Give him a break! His mother just died and his clanmates wish he were dead and for his entire life he had no father by his side. Also Antpelt was like a brother to him until Ivypool killed him for good.

    That is far more sad then the deaths of terrible sisters