My fav and least fav characters by Mangonose

Mangonose lists their favourite and least favourite cats from the series.

Art by fairyleaf

Hi there guys! My name is Mangonose, and this is my first ever post here! so i figured to get to know me, i would say my fav and least fav characters and warriors. ill start of with my favorite, and then my least fav bc why not.

honorable mentions:
Half Moon

8. Needletail.
i always loved how rebellious she was, and i think she made the first three books of AVoS more fun to read

7. Littlecloud
I dont rlly have a good reason to love Littlecloud so much, i just do. hes always had a place in my heart, and ill love him 4ever.

6. Oakheart
Ever since i read bluestar’s prophecy i felt something to Oakheart that i couldnt describe. like he was my type of guy, y’know wut im saying? i love how hes so lovey dovey over Bluefur and Bluefur’s like “nuh uh Oakie im not breaking the code” and then they instantly have kits XD

5. Mosskit
what can i say? im obsessed with the blueoak fam. i think Mosskit is very cute, and im so happy to know shes with Bluestar now, and im grateful to Snowfur for raising her.

ok, so i need to ask a question. who doesnt like Purdy? Purdy is the best elder to ever exist, dont try to argue with me. i love him SO much. his sense of humor, he isnt that grumpy, his enthusiasm, everything!

2 AND 3 (i cant decide between these two their both so amazing). Yellowfang and Jayfeather.
i L O V E them SOSOSOSOOS much. they are the b e s t. there so grumpy, and in leafpools wish i rlly loved how yellowfang was so kind to leafpool about this, and i re read rising storm a few days ago bc i was bored, and i couldnt believe how amazing yellowfang was. ok so onto jayfeather. he just…….how do i explain it? i think his power was AMAZING, and i love how even from his apprenticeship he was a grumpy old furball. i also love how there are particular cats that bring the soft side in him (im looking at Half Moon) i dont rlly have much to say about Jayfeather other then hes perfect

1. is……………..HOLLYLEAF!!!!!!!
i rlly dont get why Hollyleaf gets so much hate. she did n o t over react AT ALL, and i think that everything she does is perfect. she never let go of thunderclan, and she forgave leafpool in the end, so theres not rlly anything to be angry about with her. she was always honorable, and tbh, how cares if she killed ashfur? she did it for her and her brothers sake, and then realized that no secret can be kept forever. also, literally every time shes MENTIONED, i love her more.

ok so ive done that, not time for my least fav’s

Honorable mentions:
frecklewish (of thunderclan, the skyclan one is awesome)

7. heathertail
ok so this is and interesting choice, but i rlly do hate her. i dont have a good reason why tho. sorta like my love to littlecloud. i dont like how when lionpaw broke up with her she didnt recognize that being a warrior was more important then playing. yes, ultimately she loved him, but she was an APPRENTICE for StarClan’s sake! she was young, and even tho i hate breezepelt, ill honestly respect her love for him just bc she was older and understood wut love is.

6. breezepelt
i dont like him. i rlly dont. he just had so much potential, and wasted all of it on the DF, and the DF had to train him anyways. i think he could’ve been a great villain, and if not a villain, then VERY rebellious. yes, he already is/was, but i think that he could’ve questioned clan life like needletail did, and manage to do stuff like darktail (yes ik im getting very unrealistic but i think that that was within his reach, considering he tried to kill JAYFEATHER)

5. darkstar
he was so unfair to mapleshade!
1. appledusk obviously didnt care about the kits
2. letting appledusk go and punishing mapleshade even tho appledusk had more than mapleshade, saying that her losing kits is enough and then letting her go homeless, is not something he should’ve done. yes, oakstar exiled mapleshade, but darkstar could’ve at least let her TAKE HER KITS AND E A T. i think riverclan deserved a better leader.

4. brokentail
i just never liked him. i might change my opinion on him once i read yellowfangs secret (lol i havent), but for now, i think that he shouldnt have done anything like wut he did.

3. darkstripe
he was always weak and awful. taunting fireheart that hes a kittypet and then literally doing nothing to help the clan is disgusting. he also never had any good ideas, tigerstar always came up with them, and he always failed anyways.

1 and 2 are tied. they are………. APPLEDUSK AND SMOKY!!!!!

ill talk about smoky first.
ok so onewhisker obviously wants nothing to do with her, and she just trys to guilt trip him. i love darktail, and smoky is the REASON for all of this. making ur son evil is N O T something to be proud of, and she just lets him destroy the cat she loved and everything he loved.

now onto appledusk.
im pretty sure u guys can tell my thought on mapleshades vengeance already. i have pity for her, and i LOVE her kits SO much! their so sweet!
but appledusk………oh appledusk buddy, u just……..oh boy. u need some work.
he doesnt care about mapleshade, even after telling her he loved her, and didnt care about the kits. sometimes i wonder if appledusk would’ve been a good father.
anyways, i rlly hate both of them.

so yea, thats it. it might not have been a great start, but those are my opinions. and i know wut it feels like to get mad about opinions, so ill respect if u think my opinions suck lol. but i love and hate these characters a lot, and ill see u in the next article!


Fan Articles

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
November 28, 2020 10:28 pm

Okay, so I agree with a lot of these, but not about the ThunderClan Mapleshade’s vengeance characters (Except for Ravenwing). Actually, I want to write an article about it, but to make it better I want to collab with a Mapleshade defendant. Reply if you’re interested.

.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
December 8, 2020 4:19 pm
Reply to  Willowsilver


.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
December 8, 2020 4:19 pm
Reply to  Willowsilver

Maple is my fave cat! Totally interested!

December 21, 2020 1:51 am
Reply to  Willowsilver

Aaaa sorry im so late-
i wasnt logged in lol
anyways i understand that you probably dont want to do it now but im up

November 29, 2020 12:43 am

Smoky? Do you mean Smoke?

November 29, 2020 6:20 pm
Reply to  Flowerfern

Yeah I kinda thought she meant the farm cat by the lake for a second and got confused.

Stormpaw (Stormi)
Stormpaw (Stormi)
November 29, 2020 7:21 pm
Reply to  Flowerfern

Smoky’s also not very cool. He moved on from Floss so quickly when she was killed, and before Floss it was Daisy

November 29, 2020 2:22 am

Thank you for giving Needletail and Hollyleaf the love they deserve!!!

`~*|🌯 Burnt Cinder-burrito-Cinderpaw/whisker-Cinda🌯|*~`
`~*|🌯 Burnt Cinder-burrito-Cinderpaw/whisker-Cinda🌯|*~`
November 29, 2020 7:53 am

great article

Stormpaw (Stormi)
Stormpaw (Stormi)
November 29, 2020 7:18 pm

I loved HeatherxLion, but then I hated her when she became Breezepelt’s mate. Lol, I went from liking her to hating her

November 30, 2020 2:00 pm

I pretty much agree, but WHYYYYY DO YOU HAVE TO LIKE JAYFEATHER?! im not salty, im just confused. Jayfeather is like;


and then-




also, he wanted to prophecy to himself, so…maybe I should write an article…
(oof im gonna get so much hate)

December 1, 2020 12:28 am

Great article! I loveee Purdy, Bluestar and Mosskit like crazy. But I defend Frecklewish. Great article anyway!

Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
December 1, 2020 2:55 pm
Reply to  Coldheart

Frecklewish wasnt too bad, i mean when maple attacked her she was like, no, bruh i still like you. And i love mapleshade but why not attack someone else instead?

December 1, 2020 12:29 am

You mean Hollyleaf? Me?

Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
December 1, 2020 2:56 pm
Reply to  Hollyleaf

n-no, hollyleaf from power of three? who doesant have social media? or maybe she does…… lol 😀

December 1, 2020 3:59 am

I agree with you on a lot of these. In my opinion, Needletail is the best and Breezepelt is evil no matter what happens in Crowfeather’s trial says. Crowfeather’s Trial was good but it caused people to LIKE Breezepelt when I was reading the book I needed to constantly remind myself that he tried to murder JAYFEATHER so he deserves as bad a punishment as Ashfur who also tried to hurt Jayfeather (I love Jayfeather).

Sorry if anyone felt insulted by this comment I go into rants about things like this.

Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
Water'wish | water that fills the britta jug
December 1, 2020 2:52 pm

i agree on all of these (especially purdy and apple) but its not my list,
1 (favs) okay, its Goosefeather for life.
2 Feathertail,
3 Scourge
4 tallstar
5 mapleshade
6 yellowfang
7 stonefur
8 sorreltail
9 cinderpelt
10 thrushpelt

2 appledusk
3 dirt stripe (darkstripe)
4 crag
5 tigerstar
6 Poolcloud. period.
7 Stormtail
8 brokenstar
9 hal (he deserves worst father prize)
10 leopardstar (idk, just didnt rly like her, although she redeemed herself at the end of the frist series)

.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
.:Jaypaw (Claw):.
December 8, 2020 4:21 pm

I totally agree with Hal. Like, disowning Raggedstar? Really?

The yellow thorn
The yellow thorn
December 1, 2020 5:47 pm

Yellowfang is my f a v

December 21, 2020 1:52 am

Ayyyyyyyy Yellowfang gang!!

December 1, 2020 8:58 pm

yes hollyleaf ftw!!!

Upcoming Events!

Recent Purrs


  • Rosefeather
  • The phone really isn't ringing
  • Wrenwing:kit
  • Agatha Long, a human version of Yellowfang by Mossnose
  • Rootspring-Shadowsight-and-Bristlefrost-The-Broken-Code-by Sparkpaw
  • tigerleaf
  • JayFeather
  • Warrior's At Sunset  by Jinx