Violetpaw lists some cats who they think need a novella. Do you agree with this list?
Hi im violetpaw and imma make another article…….
Who i think should get a novella and why
The first 2 i think ppl are gonna scream at me but i hv a reason why i want them and its not cuz i luke them
SOL
Sol needs a lot more development and i think he could become more likable if the erins just try. He just came out of nowhere, made an eclipse and ran away.
How does he know about the clans and eclipse?
Who was he born too?
Why does he hate the clans?
THISTLECLAW
He also could be developed, we never get anything frkm him apart from he is bad. I want to see how he feels about it and why he chose to get rid of his kind side we see in spottedleaf’s heart
PEBBLESHINE
She is twigbranch and violetshine’s mum but we dont know anything about her
Why did she leave skyclan?
Why was she living in the middle of the road?
HALF MOON
I want to know her perspective on loving jay’s wing a cat she doesnt know is from the future, how she copes with being the first stoneteller
NEEDLETAIL
we dont know a whole lot about her apart from that she doesnt like the rules and that she joins darktail.
MIDNIGHT
Who is this badger?
How does she speak cat?
How does she connect with starclan?
Is it true that she might have been a cursed spirit, much like rock?
These questions about her need to be answered. I dont care that she isnt a cat she needs a novella.
ROCK
Why was he cursed?
Who acctually was he when he was alive?
I would rather hv something about him being alive and a bit about him dead and why he has that horrible curse of knowing everything yet having to keep it a secret.
BUMBLE OR TOM
DotC was my fav arc yet there is no one that intresting to know about apart from these too. I would rather have them in a book together and each chapter is for 1 of them
ONE EYE
The first villan in the history of the clans
Who was his mate?
Why does he look like that?
Why is he evil in genral?
SLEEKWHISKER
She fought with the DF and then joined darktail. Why? What did she do when darktail died or when the DF failed to win?
DARKTAIL
when he was young. We dont have anything about why he is evil apart from that the clans gave him away. A theory i saw somewhere is that sol is his brother. This would be intresting
FEATHERTAIL (dead)
This would be a chance to find how starclan works. Also it would be intresting since she served the tribe of endless hunting too.
BRIGHTPAW OR SWIFTPAW
Iether one of these. Speceificly the dog attack part. If swiftpaw i wanna see how he prepared for this. If brightpaw, i wanna see how she coped with losing her friend and how she becomes friends with cloudtail and how she deals with her halfblindness and the name lostface. Now that i think of it it should be a brightheart only one starting with the dog fight and ending with her getting the name brightheart and her thinking about swiftpaws name. Like the tom and bumble one, i think each chapter should have one of them. The first chapter is swiftpaw the last chapter is brightpaw, maybe her name ceremony where she is thinking what name swiftpaw would have got.
FINALY THE ONE AND ONLY
PURDY!!!!!!
what did he do before joining the clans?
We need more awesomeness. I just imagine it will be so sad when purdy goes home from exploring one day and finds his upwalker dead 🙁
There are so many characters who could be way more developed and intrestingbut now the erins just make them for boring characters. Listen to ur fans.
I think thats it for my list. Thanks.
Violetpaw out.
Note: i was gonna call this cats who deserve a novella but i remembered there was midnight and she is a badger….
☆ Okay bye ☆
Nice article! I agree with that Midnight should have a novella. :3
I think they did Pebbleshine in A warriors Spirit.
this was published before that 🙂
Awesome article!! Although I do believe that Pebbleshine already has a novella called Pebbleshine’s Kits, but otherwise great article 🙂
This was probably written, not published, before it.
cool
but i don’t think thistleclaw
Yes most of these yet though doesn’t sol have the manga skyclan and the stranger?
Also yeah the erins really need the further development of some characters
Gasp! I’ll write some!
nice article :3 I totally agree, swiftpaw should get a novella! 😀
I think Pebbleshine has a novella and Sol has SkyClan and the Stranger. But the others? I would be nice to see Brightheart! But I’d love the villains to remain hatable… although that’s not a word. Midnight and Rock can remain mysterious friends, Thistleclaw, Darktail, and One-eye to be evil villains. I want to hate Sleekwhisker, since I don’t want any excuses for her, you know?
But if Brightheart has a novella… it’ll be interesting to see her side of the Dog Lostface Incident!
Good article!
They Erins made a pretty solid caracter on him in skyclan and the stranger. [spoiler title=”Sol’s caracter “] He knows about the Eclipse because he ran into Midnight and she told him. He was born to a she cat named Cinders and he hates the clans because he was a kittypet and then Leafstar was captured and brought to his house and he helped her escape then he joined the clan he thought that he was ready to become a warrior even though he wasn’t then he stole Leafstars kits so when he “finds” them he’ll be a warrior and when she found out he was exiled. [/spoiler]
Why did Midnight tell him?
Sol hates the Clans for a really petty reason. Basically he first met SkyClan back when SkyClan had just re-started, and Sol wanted to impress Leafstar, the SkyClan leader, so he stole her kits and hid them. Then when the Clan went into a panic to find the kits, Sol planned to wait a few days and then get the kits from their hiding place, but he was discovered and banished. Then Sol got extremely salty and began hating the Clans. Very petty, very entitled.
anyways yea 😀 good article and i agree with all of these (even tho Pebbleshine already has hers)
great article! The only thing I would say is that Thistleclaw kinda showed his worst side in Spottedleaf’s Heart 😛 Sleekwhisker and One Eye totally need one!
im weird and want a foxhearts love novella! like i already commented my ideas!
YAZSSSS PURDY!
I thought of a theory in which Purdy was Skywacthers long lost brother, Twig, and that’s why he had such a strong connection to sol, since sol used to be a part of SkyClan, just like His brother loved the clans!
Needletail SO NEEDS ONE!
Put that thing back where it came from, or so help me!
I totally agree with everything especially Midnight! (But Pebbleshine already has hers) But anyways great article!