[Briarlight lies in the medicine cat den with Jayfeather by her side, the latter with his tail curling over her back]

My top 10 faveorite noncannon ships and why they didnt happen by Shinepaw

Shinepaw shares their favourite non-canon ships. Which of these do you like?

Art by Hoverpelt

hello! this is my very first post on blogclan! anyways hope you enjoy the list! this is comletely my opinion so im sorry if you favorite ship is not on here!

10. mothpool (mothwing x leafpool) –
i think this ship is a amazing idea but there is a ton of things that would keep it from being a good ship not just the fact that they arent medicene cats
9. dasytail (dasiy x cloudtail)
this ship way a one way ship dasiy loved cloudtail so much but cloudtail was alrady taken by brightheat so this ship never happened
8. halffeather (jayfeather x halfmoon )
this ship is so cute!! i think it would have become real if jay feather was a acinent cat and wasnt just there for a littel while

7. heatherlion (heatherpaw x lionnpaw)
this ship would defintly happened if it wasnt for tigerstar and hawkfrost forseing lionpaw to stop meeting heatherpaw in the tunnels and trin with them

6. fallenleaf (fallen leaves x hollyleaf)
this ship is adorable even more so in the novella hollyleafs journy and fallen leves reaction when she died in the last hope is heart breaking.

5, velvetheart (velvet x alderheart)
very cute but i think alderheart never would stop being a medicene cat and velvet would never stop being a kittypet

4. sorrelpool (sorreltail x leafpool) –
this ship is very very close to being number 3 but i think that when they became friends sorreltail was already starting to have intrest in brackenfur so this ship never really reached its full potintal

3. briarjay (briarlight x jayfeather)-
i love this ship but i did some reasherch in the books and i relized why this ship never happened . briarlight always felt that she was getting in the way of jayfeather in the medicene den and i belive this is why this ship never happed

2. bluetail (bluefur(star) x rosetail)
this ship is a great ship rosetail was always the one bluefur(Star) turned to for comfurt when her family died, sadly rosetail always wanted her to get together with thrushpelt this is why i belive this ship never happened

1. cinderleaf (cinderheart x hollyleaf)-
i know this ship is not as common but i absolutly love this ship!!! these cats are the best of friends intill hollyleaf killed ashfur and ran away into the tunnels. when she comes back cinderheart is already with lionblaze i belive if she hadent run away this ship would happened

anyways i hope you enjoyed my very first post and have a great day!
-shine

Fan Articles

53 comments

  • I agree with some of these.
    10. “Mothpool.” I don’t know! Personally, I’m trying to figure out who I should ship: Moth x Leaf, or Crow x Leaf. I mean they’re both good ships! So PLEASE help me.
    9. “Daisytail.” I’m sorry but no. NO NO NO NO NO! Cloudtail was in love with Brightheart! Not Daisy! And I just feel like Cloudtail is better off with Brightheart anyway! So, no. (Sorry if you found this rude in any sort of way.)
    8. “Halffeather.” I don’t hate this one. But I don’t love it either. I mean, Half Moon loved Jay’s Wing, not Jayfeather. And yes Jayfeather IS Jay’s Wing, but she never got too see who Jay’s Wing truly was. And that’s what’s important in a relationship. They have to know each other. And Half Moon didn’t really know who Jay’s Wing actually was. By the way, I’m sorry to any Jay x Half fans. I just don’t really ship them.
    7. “Heatherlion.” Omg, there’s so many problems here. No offence, but Lionblaze loved Cinderheart. Not Heathertail. Honestly, this is just a crush. And, if I’m telling the truth, I’m VERY glad that it didn’t happen. Because if it did it would cause SO MUCH drama for the clans. So… yeah.
    6. “Fallenleaf.” YES! yes, yes, yes, yes, yes! They are perfect for each other! I LOVE Fallen Leaves x Hollyleaf! They are so CUTE together! Again, this is perfect.
    5. “Velvetheart.” I feel like I can’t say anything about this one, because I haven’t read about it yet. So.. I don’t know.
    4. “Sorrelpool.” I think they’re just friends. I’m sorry but it just doesn’t seem likely to me.
    3. “Briarjay.” YES! They are THE CUTEST COUPLE EVER! BRIAR X JAY FOREVER!
    2. “Bluetail.” I LOVE this one! I’m now gonna start shipping them.
    1. “Cinderleaf.” I don’t know? I mean, I feel like I need to do more research on this one, but from your description, it seems sweet.

  • Some of my favorite non-cannon ships are, TallxJake, IvyxBlossom, MaplexReed, FallenxHolly, BriarxJay, SquirrelxLeaf (as in, LeafSTAR), ShadowxSpire, and…some others.

    P.S. I would also mention Raven x Barley, but I recently found out that they are cannon.😀

  • I love this article!
    Personally, I think FrostXYellow (Frostfur and Yellowfang) is my favorite noncannon Ship!

  • Although I don’t ship Daisytail, Sorrelpool, Briarfeather, or Cinderleaf, this is a amazing article!