How Warriors Ruined Bramblestar (as told by a Bramblestar fan) by Brambleheart

Brambleheart shares their thoughts on how Bramblestar changed throughout the series.

Art by MissyDakota

Hey everyone. So Bramblestar is my favourite character in Warriors. I named my cat after him! But, he is also a controversial warrior cat. A lot of people hate him because he is a “bad” leader, or an “abusive” mate. While I can see why a lot of people dislike him, and think that some things that he did were mean, I feel that a lot of people fail to understand that Bramblestar wasn’t always that way. (I’m not saying anything mean about Bramblestar haters, you are all valid). In fact, in older books, it seems that Bramblestar was a different cat, sending different messages.

I feel that Bramblestar was a good cat before his Super Edition, but after, he fell apart quick by losing his crucial development with both himself as a leader and his relationship with Squirrelflight–and here is why.

To truly understand Bramblestar, we need to see him from the beginning. In the Prophecies Begin arc, Bramblekit/paw was created to further help Firestar’s development and teach him to not judge a book by its cover. And we get that adorable scene of baby Bramblepaw playing in the snow and it’s the most wholesome scene in the entire series.

In New Prophecy, although Brambleclaw himself wasn’t as interesting as Leafpool and Squirrelflight development-wise, he was still the most important cat when it comes to the overall themes of the series. Brambleclaw’s development coincided with Squirrelflight’s, in the sense that Squirrelflight was important to develop Brambleclaw, and Brambleclaw was important to develop Squirrelflight. Brambleclaw’s impression of Squirrelflight as an “annoying idiot” was the reader’s first impression of her as well. But as we see Squirrelflight prove herself again and again as a competent warrior, Brambleclaw sees it too. It’s an extension of the “don’t judge a book by it’s cover” message we saw in his original appearences.

The latter half of The New Prophecy does this beautifully as well with the ups and downs of Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight’s relationship. It gives the reader a good message of how relationships are supposed to work. A lot of relationships in Warriors, especially before this one, aren’t realistic in the sense that there are fights. A lot of good relationships in Warriors are glorified because the cats don’t have arguments, when in real life, it’s the opposite. In fact, a relationship without any fights is an unhealthy relationship. Why?

In a relationship, there are two people (or cats) trying to work together, and it’s a two-way street. Fights are usually made when one person is struggling to meet in the middle, and a lot of the time, the fights resolve themselves and both people in the relationship grow and learn from their mistakes. If all relationships ended after one fight, we wouldn’t have any at all. This makes the relationship between Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight one of the most realistic in the series that sends a message of how they are supposed to be. This remains as a constant in later arcs, which I will get to later.

Brambleclaw also was key to broadening horizons in Warriors when it came to having new protagonists. He was the perfect blend of familiarity that we saw with Firestar, and someone new. I believe that Brambleclaw was intended to parallel Firestar at the beginning of The New Prophecy for this reason, in the sense that Firestar fans would read the new books despite not having their favourite character as a protagonist, while becoming familiar with the other unique protagonists the arc had to offer, which was essential for what was a big risk for Warriors at the time New Prophecy was being written.

In Power of Three, Brambleclaw was a loving and good father and role model for Jayfeather, Lionblaze and Hollyleaf as they grew up. And the fact that he temporarily broke up with Squirrelflight was very valid. His mate lied to him, because she didn’t trust him. Yes, Squirrelflight’s reasoning was understandable, but it didn’t stop Brambleclaw from feeling betrayed, which a lot of people would if this situation happened in real life. But the fact that they reconciled in The Last Hope continued and stayed faithful to the message of how fights are important for those in a relationship to grow and understand each other.

But Bramblestar’s Super Edition made things wary. This is where I believe the downfall of Bramblestar’s character development began. While Bramblestar developed as a great leader, e didn’t get to see a whole lot of development with him and Squirrelflight besides the manga, which in itself was more from Squirrelflight’s perspective. Despite this, Bramblestar was still developed as a competent and strong leader who was beloved by his Clan. He and Squirrelflight got a happier happy ending in kits as well, which was very nice for the two of them.

I can’t say the same about Bramblestar going on to A Vision of Shadows or beyond, as this is both when his development got ignored and when he started to get a lot of hate. I like to call this the Onestar effect: it’s when a character becomes a leader and is thrown off the spotlight, and loses all their development and become a jerk as a result. A Vision of Shadows, The Broken Code and Squirrelflight’s Hope are really guilty of this with Bramblestar, Mistystar, Harestar, and Tigerheartstar getting this treatment.

We at first see this with Bramblestar as a father. With Leafpool’s kits, Bramblestar was hands on, loving, and supportive of them throughout their lives (until the truth estranged them), but with his own kits we see him be a proper father for one book. A SINGULAR BOOK, AKA the last book that remembers Bramblestar’s development. And Bramblestar isn’t even there for the majority of it! As A Vision of Shadows progresses, we see Bramblestar be an incompetent leader for the sake of the conflict in the books dragging on; not the compassionate, loyal, and supportive Bramblestar we’ve seen before that.

While this was a mild inconvenience for me at the time, Squirrelflight’s Hope made a lot of people hate Bramblestar–including me. For the sake of summary, Bramblestar was being toxic and abusive to Squirrelflight, and a very bad leader too. He did so many bad things in that book that were completely out of nowhere and super out of character. The only development that Bramblestar got from this was from other books that ignored his other development.

Myself along with some of the other Bramblestar fans accept that Bramblestar is just a different cat now, and I personally hate this other Bramblestar. I want the old one back! I hope I gave you some light on Bramblestar, and I hope you’ve enjoyed this article! Please, please leave a comment on your thoughts on the two Bramblestars. I am excited to see your opinions!

Avatar

Fan Articles

guest
40 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
lilacpelt
lilacpelt
December 15, 2020 5:32 pm

bramblestar was better as a warrior but the way he treated squirrelflight i don’t really like him after he found out he wasn’t the father of hollyleaf,jayfeather and lionblaze i haven’t read the books for the 6th and 7th arc but still i agree with you tbh nice article

Flowerfern
Flowerfern
December 15, 2020 5:52 pm

Squirrelflight trusted him, she just wanted him to treat Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf as his own kits.

✧・゚: *✧・゚:* Eagle that soars through the sky ✯ Aquila *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:* Eagle that soars through the sky ✯ Aquila *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
December 15, 2020 5:53 pm

I love Brambleclaw!!!
He was always the most relatable character to me and I could see myself in him. I completely agree with you, I want Bramblestar as Bramblepaw or Brambleclaw back!! 🙁😛

Icepaw/Icefur
Icepaw/Icefur
January 6, 2021 4:56 am

I completely agree, as a Bramblepaw/Brambleclaw fan, I wish that Bramblestar was still like he used to be when he was Bramblepaw/claw!!! 🙁😔

Lilly that Wilts in Winter (Lillypaw/Lil)
Lilly that Wilts in Winter (Lillypaw/Lil)
December 15, 2020 10:35 pm

I was so angry and confused when it came to Bramblestar in Squirrelflight’s Hope and this sums up my emotions. Great article!

Cinders Drifting by Moonlit Pool - Cindie (Cinderpaw/pool)
Cinders Drifting by Moonlit Pool - Cindie (Cinderpaw/pool)
December 16, 2020 2:47 am

“The Onestar effect”
Exactly 😛 ! Great job, Brambleheart! You’re a great mentor!

Nightpool
Nightpool
December 16, 2020 7:08 pm

Great article! I used to love Bramblestar but now I hate him because of Bramblestar’s Storm and the books after it.

shadowtail
shadowtail
December 17, 2020 5:43 pm

i think he is still pretty ok

Rockpelt
Rockpelt
December 17, 2020 8:24 pm

I think maybe cats becoming jerks after they are leaders is intentional. It may be more of a Clear Sky effect than a Onestar effect. They have to think about all of their cats instead of just their closest pals. This thought is the one thing that has stopped me from hating Bramblestar. Oh… And also The Broken Code seems to be bringing back some more of the old Bramblestar. Great article by the way.

Coldheart
Christmas Coldheart
December 18, 2020 1:29 am

YAY BRAMBLECLAW! I’m a hard-core shipper of SquirrelxBramble. I love Brambleclaw. But thank you for this article.

Riverpond
Riverpond
December 18, 2020 2:04 am

Beautifully written article

Icepaw/Icefur
Icepaw/Icefur
January 6, 2021 4:57 am
Reply to  Riverpond

indeed

raven will eat your bread (raventhornpaw)
raven will eat your bread (raventhornpaw)
December 19, 2020 2:23 am

What if Ashfur actually possessed Bramble in AVoS instead of TBC, and only at TBC cats start to catch on because Ash got lazy while possessing Bramble?

Bronzestrike
Bronzestrike
January 1, 2021 10:32 pm

How would he do that? Bramblestar never lost a life in AVoS. Also, we see that Bramblestar WAS in his body throughout Lost Stars.

hollypool
hollypool
January 12, 2021 8:01 pm

in squellflights hope bramblestar treats squellflight like a pice of trash. :(((

Upcoming Events!

Recent Purrs

Flickr

  • Rosefeather
  • The phone really isn't ringing
  • Wrenwing:kit
  • Agatha Long, a human version of Yellowfang by Mossnose
  • Rootspring-Shadowsight-and-Bristlefrost-The-Broken-Code-by Sparkpaw
  • tigerleaf
  • JayFeather
  • Warrior's At Sunset  by Jinx