My top 10 least fav and fav cats and why by Riverkit

Riverkit lists their favourite and least favourite characters from the series.

Art by Lithestep

Hi! I already did an article on this, but I changed my opinion on a lot of them.
Here are my favorite cats:

5. Squirrelflight. Squirrelflight is not a character mentioned much. I love her because she has endless energy (in The New Prophecy.)

4. Ivypool. Ivypool is one of my favorite characters for multiple reasons. First reason: She was overpowered by Dovewing. In my opinion (and many peoples’ opinions I think) she should’ve been the fourth cat. Second reason: She risked everything to go to the Dark Forest.

3. Crookedstar/Half Moon (I can’t decide.) Crookedstar: Crookedstar’s background is so sad! Rainflower gave him the name Crookedkit after he broke his jaw, and all of the cats that he loved died! I don’t know anyone who does not love Crookedstar’s Promise. Half Moon: I’m a big fan of the Jayfeather and Half Moon ship. I don’t know why I like her, I just do.

2: Jayfeather. I think pretty much everyone likes Jayfeather. He is just so grumpy and…and… what is another good word for him? Defiant, and brave, and defiant. (Again a big fan of the Jayfeather Half Moon ship.) I love ya Jay!

1. Yellowfang. Ohmygosh, Yellowfang is my favorite. She’s also just so grumpy, and like, ‘do this, do that’ and I just love her! I don’t care if she broke the warrior code, and is kinda, maybe, a little bit bossy. She is so awesome!

Honorable mentions:
Cinderpelt
Tawnypelt
Sorreltail
Crowfeather
Hollyleaf

Least favorite cats:

5. Millie. Millie is just “Oh no, my kits!” and scolds them when they can take care of themselves. For example, when Blossomfall and Ivypool come back from the tunnels, Millie was all like, “Where did you go! You could’ve been killed!” and “You are so irresponsible!” and also when Briarlight broke her back, Millie was giving her all the attention, and when Blossomfall came back from hunting, Millie just scolded her and said “Your sister would give up everything to hunt for the rest of the Clan!”

4. Mapleshade. Poor Crookedstar! (Note that I have not read Mapleshade’s Vengeance, but I have read Crookedstar’s Promise.)

3. Rainflower. Also poor Crookedstar! He doesn’t deserve to be treated that way! And named Crookedkit after he broke his jaw! Any cat can break their jaw, but I doubt that any good mother would rename their kit “Crookedkit.”

2. I have no idea.

1. Dovewing. Dovewing is just all goody goody, smarty smartypants. I hate her! In my opinion, Dovewing should never have existed.

Thanks for reading!
May StarClan light your path.

https://images.app.goo.gl/KXLoQF98SG4azzz67

Fan Articles

43 comments

  • I like alive Yellowfang but not dead Yellowfang. Yellowfang was by far one of my favorite characters throughout Yellowfang’s Secret and The Prophecies Begin. But then in StarClan she was completely different, and I started to dislike her. It’s too bad she changed so much when she died.

  • I agree with Squirrelflight, Ivypool, and Jayfeather. They are all great! I also agree with Mapleshade, and rainflower. I like Half Moon and crookedstar is ok! I disagree with Dovewing, Millie, and Yellowfang. I hate yellowfang. She literally told squirrelflight that she would never have kits just so squirrelflight would take Leafpool’s. Then she acted like she did nothing wrong in squirrelflight’s hope and completely got away with it. Not to mention, she’s always sticking her nose in everyone’s business. I liked her when she was alive but I can’t STAND her in death. Milie isn’t that bad- she didn’t neglect her children she was just really worried about briarlight. Also blossomfall was just a brat and she couldn’t accept not getting attention from her mom. Bumblestripe didn’t mind millie’s attention towards briarlight. I don’t care much about millie, I like her but I don’t give much thought to her though. I feel bad for Dovewing. Idk why she gets so much hate. She’s really not that bad. She’s not my favourite but I think she’s cool. I’m one of those people who loves Ivypool but doesn’t Dovewing. I respect your opinions though! Good article!

  • Squirrelflight- I love her and she’s tied with my other favourite character
    Ivypool- I also love her!
    Crookedstar- meh he’s fine
    Half moon- she’s ok, I like her
    Jayfeather- I kind of like him? He’s overrated, and he’s just a meh character
    Yellowfang- I hate her and I hate how she’s can’t stop bugging the clans and I hate how she manipulated Squirrelflight into taking Leafpool’s kits.

    Millie- I don’t like her
    Mapleshade- I hate her
    Rainflower- I hate her
    Dovewing- I love her so much! I don’t get why she gets so much hate.

    • dovewing keeps getting attention and doesnt care about her sister’s feelings. also she abandoned thunderclan for Tigerheart.
      Squirrelflight- she’s pretty good
      Ivypool- my favorite
      Crookedstar- He’s good i guess
      Half Moon- Ok
      Jayfeather- He’s good
      Yellowfang- Ok, and really annoying
      Millie- I hate her
      Mapleshade- I also hate her
      Rainflower- I don’t like her
      Dovewing- I hate her so much

  • dovewing keeps getting attention and doesnt care about her sister’s feelings. also she abandoned thunderclan for Tigerheart.
    Squirrelflight- she’s pretty good
    Ivypool- my favorite
    Crookedstar- He’s good i guess
    Half Moon- Ok
    Jayfeather- He’s good
    Yellowfang- Ok, and really annoying
    Millie- I hate her
    Mapleshade- I also hate her
    Rainflower- I don’t like her
    Dovewing- I hate her so much

  • Favorite
    Spottedleaf- she is sooooooooo kind

    Dovewing- She may be a smarty pants but now look she is struggling

    Half Moon- I don’t know why

    Jayfeather- he is such a good med cat

    Sorreltail- She was such a good cat and without her Thunderclan would have never known about Darkstripe
    Non favorites

    Mapleshade- I know she has been in tremendous pain but why after getting your revenge you try to kill someone that never did anything to you

    Rainflower- I wish she went to the dark forest she is so rude to Crookedkit like she changed his name, she didn’t allow him to sleep with her yada yada yada

    In betweens

    Ivypool – I don’t like how she trained in the dark forest but she is a fine cat that deserves to be in Starclan

    Hollyleaf- I don’t like how she killed Ashfur to protect the sercret and then she told the secret but she was a good cat that didn’t deserve to die so early

  • Nice Article… It’s really amazing

    Squirrelflight- I love her (She’s in my top 10)
    Ivypool- My Fav Character!!!!💙
    Crookedstar- OK
    Half moon- I like her
    Jayfeather- OK
    Yellowfang- I really liked alive Yellowfang but not dead Yellowfang

    Millie- She’s OK
    Mapleshade- I can’t decide since I’ve read her novella
    Rainflower- I hate her too! She’s such a bad mother!
    Dovewing- She’s my second favorite cat!