My top 10 least fav and fav cats and why by Riverkit

Riverkit lists their favourite and least favourite characters from the series.

Art by Lithestep

Hi! I already did an article on this, but I changed my opinion on a lot of them.
Here are my favorite cats:

5. Squirrelflight. Squirrelflight is not a character mentioned much. I love her because she has endless energy (in The New Prophecy.)

4. Ivypool. Ivypool is one of my favorite characters for multiple reasons. First reason: She was overpowered by Dovewing. In my opinion (and many peoples’ opinions I think) she should’ve been the fourth cat. Second reason: She risked everything to go to the Dark Forest.

3. Crookedstar/Half Moon (I can’t decide.) Crookedstar: Crookedstar’s background is so sad! Rainflower gave him the name Crookedkit after he broke his jaw, and all of the cats that he loved died! I don’t know anyone who does not love Crookedstar’s Promise. Half Moon: I’m a big fan of the Jayfeather and Half Moon ship. I don’t know why I like her, I just do.

2: Jayfeather. I think pretty much everyone likes Jayfeather. He is just so grumpy and…and… what is another good word for him? Defiant, and brave, and defiant. (Again a big fan of the Jayfeather Half Moon ship.) I love ya Jay!

1. Yellowfang. Ohmygosh, Yellowfang is my favorite. She’s also just so grumpy, and like, ‘do this, do that’ and I just love her! I don’t care if she broke the warrior code, and is kinda, maybe, a little bit bossy. She is so awesome!

Honorable mentions:
Cinderpelt
Tawnypelt
Sorreltail
Crowfeather
Hollyleaf

Least favorite cats:

5. Millie. Millie is just “Oh no, my kits!” and scolds them when they can take care of themselves. For example, when Blossomfall and Ivypool come back from the tunnels, Millie was all like, “Where did you go! You could’ve been killed!” and “You are so irresponsible!” and also when Briarlight broke her back, Millie was giving her all the attention, and when Blossomfall came back from hunting, Millie just scolded her and said “Your sister would give up everything to hunt for the rest of the Clan!”

4. Mapleshade. Poor Crookedstar! (Note that I have not read Mapleshade’s Vengeance, but I have read Crookedstar’s Promise.)

3. Rainflower. Also poor Crookedstar! He doesn’t deserve to be treated that way! And named Crookedkit after he broke his jaw! Any cat can break their jaw, but I doubt that any good mother would rename their kit “Crookedkit.”

2. I have no idea.

1. Dovewing. Dovewing is just all goody goody, smarty smartypants. I hate her! In my opinion, Dovewing should never have existed.

Thanks for reading!
May StarClan light your path.

https://images.app.goo.gl/KXLoQF98SG4azzz67

Fan Articles

42 comments

    • Her sad life was caused by her own terrible choices! But I agree, they should read Mapleshade’s Vengeance so they can form their own opinion on it.

  • Well, I love Dovewing, and I defend Millie a lot, but I mostly agree with you! Rainflower was pretty horrible.

  • Politely agree, politely disagree!
    Great article!

    Squirrelflight – I love her!
    Ivypool – I like Dovewing better. But still, they’re both annoying, both hate-able(?), both obnoxious, both weird, and both lovable. She was jealous, sure, but that is not a reason, ehem, not a reason to go train with a bunch of maniacs who are clearly murderers… still. Besides, she was a horrible spy and a horrible sister.
    Crookedstar/Half Moon – Crookedstar’s good. Overrated, sure. Half Moon… well, I daresay I skipped all the Ancients part.
    Jayfeather – Yes, I hate him.
    Yellowfang – She’s loving.

    Millie – Well, in her view, of course Blossomfall was irresponsible. She was a grown warrior, and a grown woman. She didn’t need any help from her mother. Briarlight, however, had a broken spine and could die.
    Mapleshade – Her sob story is ridiculous.
    Rainflower – 🙁
    Dovewing – She’s no smarty-pants. Oh, and if she’s a goody-two-shoes(paws?), why do you hate her? She should’ve existed. She’s not whiny, not a Mary Sue…

    Well, nice article!

    • I don’t get all the hate on Dovewing! Everyone calls me a boring, annoying goody two shoes but that doesn’t mean I shouldn’t exist, Dovewing did nothing bad! Yes for Millie too, I mean, she had kin, she had friends, Blossomfall didn’t need her mother, and she was a mean bully because she didn’t get enough attention as her hurt sister! Of course Millie was going to be worried more about her injured sister! Like, Firestar had no kin and he was very young, did he bully anyone? She should have been grateful instead of a mean bully.

  • My thoughts on these cats:

    Squirrelflight- I love her. She deserves better.
    Ivypool- she’s awesome!
    Crookedstar- he’s cool.
    Half Moon- she’s a pretty good cat.
    Jayfeather- I love this guy.
    Yellowfang- she rocks.
    Millie- reaaaaalllly bad mom.
    Mapleshade- she is the Warrior cat I defend the most.
    Rainflower- worst. mom. ever.
    Dovewing- I lovewing Dovewing.
    WolfStar 4 Life

  • First, i dont really like jay! second, onec you read mapleshade’s vengeance your prespective of her will change. Third, your opinion has changed a lot! i remember when you actually liked dovewing! Fourth, i havent read crookedstars promise TvT. And fifth, this was a really cool article