Meadowstripe discusses a few unhealthy relationships in the series.
Hiya, I’ll be talking about unhealthy relationships in this article/page, and it’ll be my first so sorry for any mistakes I might make.
So, the first relationship is Bramblestar and Squirrelflight’s relationship. Since you most likely read the title, you know what I’m here for. Bramblestar is manipulative! Or at least I think so. He makes Squilf deputy, saying she’ll stand up to him if he’s doing something mouse-brained (hare-brained for Windclan) but then when she tries to stand up to him for doing something mouse-brained (**POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT**) he threatens to take her position as deputy! He gave her the job to stop him from doing mouse-brained things, then threatened her for doing that! That’s not a good relationship with your cat-wife, Bramble!
Alright, okay, moving on to the second relationship, and keep in mind, these aren’t romantic. Blossomfall and Briarlight. Blossomfall, as you can see, if just living her normal life and then Briar gets paralyzed, Blossom is frustrated that she’s getting all Mille’s love… you know the story by now. I’d like to see if MAYBE just MAYBE I can find some sort of sympathy for Blossomfall. I don’t personally hate nor love her, so this isn’t super biased. So, let’s see, maybe I can think of something…? Mhmm… that COULD work… Okay, hear me out on this that I’ve been able to conjure in my brain-mind. Blossom’s view: She’s trying to escape from the tree, and her sister runs back TO the murderous tree, Blossom is freaking out, wondering what she just saw. And she keeps herself together despite the fact that she’s thinking of the worst possible outcome: Her sister is dead. She finds out her sister is just badly injured and will never properly walk. Maybe Blossom is actually freaking out? I don’t know. I was kinda hoping I could find some reasoning, but no, she’s just immature and flat out terrible to Briar.
The last one here is going to have to be Bumblestripe and Dovewing. Bumblestripe gets his clanmates on his side about the whole thing, and he tries more than he should, to cat-marry Dove, when she says no, he and his clanmates pester her more and call her a terrible cat for rejecting him like that. You might say Ashfur loved too much, but he killed Firestar, BUMBLESTRIPE loved too much! I’m not going for him, but you can see, in Bristlefrost’s point of view of not getting loved back, his problem was that he took it too far. He got her friends and family to annoy her about it, he manipulated her.
But what do I know? I’m just a silly apprentice!
Great Article
Great article! I agree with all of these, and am glad you put SquilfxBramble on here 😀 Moonkitti made a great video on that called Bramblestar is Worse, if you haven’t seen it already.
Yeah, I saw it.
Nice article. I agree with all of them accept Bramblestar.
Bramblestar is definitely abusive, and Bumblestripe is awful. The one thing I disagree with is Blossomfall: she never hated her sister, she only hated her injuries, and being neglected by her mother.
Squirrelflight lover
Yeah. She was just jealous.
I still think of her as a bit of a brat and genuinely rude to her sister.
I agree, no one wants to be the source of an argument, and be treated like an object. She did the same thing to Dovewing too.
i thought blossomfall was gonna be NICE.
was literally when out of nowhere shes in the DF.
(SAME WITH BIRCHFALL + MOUSEWHISKER!)
Great article! I agree with all of these and I think briar light and blossom fall is bad but it’s Millies fault for neglecting blossom fall. 🤷♂️
As someone who is like Blossomfall— being sometimes ignored my my brother for personal reasons; I don’t feel Millie’s in the wrong. She might be the good cat in this situation. She is not neglectful, she is just over-protective! Millie Was once kittypet, and while she was more confident to go into the clans than others— say Daisy, she was still worried about somethings. Briarlight’s injury was one of them. She thought she crippled daughter was going too die, definitely a bad feeling. So no, it’s not Millie’s fault!
I’m with you 100% with what you said about Bumblestripe & Dovewing, and it is true that Bramblestar can be pretty oblivious and annoying, especially torward Squirrelflight.
Lots of mixed feelings on BramblexSquilf, blaming Millie for Blossomfall and Briarlight’s relationship, but mostly agreeing on Bumble being in the wrong so far. I’m not saying your opinions are invalid or not considered, I’m just summing up your thoughts for my own sake, I supposed. Thanks, Birchy and Embix for getting my article posted, and thanks to everyone else for your thoughts on it 😌
I made sure to write it in a way I wouldn’t find cringy by the time it was out, then promptly undid that work with my last line. 😀 I should stop annoying myself
I like this article except the BrambleStar and SquirrelFlight one I like their relationship
Their relationship was fine….until Bramble began to manipulate and abuse Squilf. Bramblestar is Worse – YouTube Here’s a video explaining the various times Bramblestar treated Squilf unfairly and/or manipulated her.
Also a silly apprentice here!
That makes two of us 😛
I totally agree with you!
I feel like I’m the only one in the fandom who supports Dovewing x Bumblestripe. And is Bramblestar x Leafpool a valid ship or is it just completely fanmade with no evidence?
I personally like Dovewing single and I think the idea around LeafxBramble is cute.
Extremely late here but bramble x lead would be abusive/toxic as well and it’s not canon, and I’m kinda concerned on why you like dovestripe because bumble is ashfur but a lot worse.
Nice article. I agree on all of them!