[Brambleclaw walks through a grassy field with wildflowers]

Why I love Bramblestar by Blacknight

Blacknight shares why they like Bramblestar.

Art by Aniritak

Hi everybody, Im not sure if I have done this article before already but anyways this is my fourth/fifth article and I will split this article into two parts, on defend part and one part why he is so amazing

Why I like him, part:
His is the son of The biggest villian the clans have ever seen, when Thunderclan drove out his father nobody trusted him, except of his mother and sister. His sister couldn`t bare that nobody trusted her, so she left the clan to join his evil father. Now Bramblepaw had only his mother left, he had no freinds. And when he had to choose between, if he wanted to be in the clan that didnt trust him, the clan where he had only his mother and the Clan where he would have been welcome, where he had the most of his family. He anyways chose Thinderclan, he technically didn`t even have a reason to go to Thunderclan. Then in the new propecy, he saved all the clans with some other cats. He chose to save his leader, over killing him, when his father and brother threatened him and when he so much wanted to be the leader he saved him and beat his brother in the fight and killed him. He was a good leader. +he saved squirrelflight and Ashfur from being killed by the fox

Defense part:
Some of the Bramb haters hate him becuase he went into the dark forest. But he didnt do it becuase he wanted to be like his father, but becuase he wanted to be a strong warrior, and right when he heard about uniting 4 clans into 2, he stopped. The most of the Bramb haters hate him becuase he broke up with Squirrelflight. Well, OF COURSE HE WILL, she lie to him about what he thought was his own kits, and told him at a gathering in front of all of the clans aware of the consiquences. The second reason why he may have broken up with her is becuase he had thought that she didnt trust him to keep the secret.

Fan Articles

19 comments

  • I can’t agree, I’m sorry. I do like your debate though! In my opinion, Bramblestar just lost his entire personality and character after he became leader. Once he finally won that argument about Lionblaze, Hollyleaf and Jayfeather, he was somewhat satisfied, if I’m correct. Even after Alderheart and Sparkpelt were born, he never treated Squirrelflight badly.

    • I am so sorry for the long wait, if you will ever see this, and this is not my opinion at the time.

  • Squirrelflight’s perspective, in my opinion, really made it seem like he was horrible but he actually wasn’t. Personally I don’t think he was abusive. Not wanting kits or being mad at her for lying about the Three isn’t being abusive, And I hate Squirrelflight’s Hope (no offense to the people who like it) because it was just lazy writing in my opinion. I already knew he was being mean to her and they didn’t need all the Sisters drama. Plus they were rogues, he is a lot less harsh then I would be! Let’s just say that if I were in charge there would be no more Sisters left. Plus he had every right to ask for StarClan’s permission after Sunrise got injured. And also I don’t like the book because it made me realize how horrible she is to Bramblestar. This is an extremely unpopular opinion, but, I feel like Squirrelflight was worse to Bramblestar than he was to her. Think about it: she disobeyed him every chance she got and lied to him about the Three and I just found her extremely annoying and her book boring. No offense to the people who have different opinion and I’ll respect yours if you respect mine.