Darklily lists their facourite and least favourite characters from the series.
There will be some major spoilers in this article. Hello, Darklily here! In this article I will list my top 5 favourite cats, and then my 5 least favourite. This is my first article, so it is probably a bit rusty. Apologies in advance for the errors. They are in no particular order.
My top 5 favourite characters:
1. Crowfeather
I like Crowfeather because I really relate to him. Weirdly. I felt so sorry for him when Feathertail died in Moonrise. He got incredibly unlucky in love, if he was a human he would be brilliant at cards. I honestly hope he lives long enough to become Crowstar.
2. Ashfur
I know what youโre thinking. โWho likes such an evil character!!!โ I really do not know why I like him as a character. I tend to like evil characters more than the heroes. Anyway, on with the list.
3. Mapleshade
As I said in the Ashfur section, I really like evil characters. I am in no way defending Mapleshade for her actions. But her poor kits… Mapleshade was not treated well, but was a truly cruel cat. If I was basing it on moral level, she would be on the other list.
4. Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf was a cat who tried her best to be loyal to her clan and the warrior code. Not many cats in the series take it as seriously as her. It was such a shame that she went partly insane towards the end of the PoT arc. At least she had a dignified death in the OotS arc.
5. Bluestar
I wish Bluestar could have at least lived until the second arc. In the first few books she is such a great, calm leader. I recently got Bluestarโs prophecy, and I am glad to read more of the old Bluestar.
My top 5 least favourite characters:
1. Firestar
I personally feel that Firestar left too much of an impact. How can a kittypet with no warrior training beat a warrior in a fight? Not possible, and yet Firestar does it. And two prophecies? I just do not like him.
2. Lionblaze
I think his power is too much. Dovewing and Jayfeather have much more reasonable powers. This power just stops him from being relatable. Also, I doubt I would be able to relate without the power either.
3. Hawkfrost
This could fill an article by itself, but I will sum it up the best I can. Of course he had to be evil, of course. The Mothwing was interesting for a while, but got dropped. Then he got totally ripped off at the end. I think I donโt like him because of plot, rather than his character.
4. Berrynose
Oh gosh, he annoyed me nearly to death. It is not possible to be more full of yourself than he was. Also, he wants kits with Honeyfern, Honeyfern dies, letโs have kits with her sister instead! So logical. Honestly, I hate his character.
5. Spottedleaf
We see her alive for like, hardly any amount of time and Firepawโs in looove! She is so boringly nice! I was glad when Mapleshade murdered StarClan Spottedleaf. How does that work again?
Now, Darklily out!
Crowfeather – Like him ๐
Ashfur – ewww
Mapleshade – Noh
Hollyleaf – Screechno
Bluestar – I like her!
Firestar – Longtail was probably underestimating Rusty, since he was just a tiny kittypet, and he was taken by surprise. Longtail might not have been very skilled at that.
Lionblaze – He has no power anymore. It’s his power. It exists for two arcs. I thought you’d say he’s boring, tbh.
Hawkfrost – Bland and boring though I liked his tongue.
Berrynose – Annoying but he grew on me. rip
I admit BerryPoppy’s sort of weird but they had whole six moons before, and six moons for a cat is longer than our six months.
Spottedleaf – ew
Great Article! I really like Crowfeather, so I agree with you on the first one. I also really like Firestar, though
Great article! I completely agree, and I also love evil characters! However, I kind of disagree on Firestar and Spottedleaf. Firestar’s development in the first arc was really cool, and Spottedleaf’s development in Spottedleaf’s Heart I think makes up for her “mary sue-ness” in TPB. Even though I really dislike Spottedleaf’s Heart ๐
THE Mothwing?! WHAT IS THAT?!
Medicine cat who doesn’t believe in StarClan alert
-sounds alarm-
the moth’s wing incident where hawkfrost placed a moth’s wing outside
I hate crowfeather, and I think firestar is prime in TPB
I hate crowfeather, and I think firestar is prime in TPB. I like mapleshade as a villain
Crowfeather- I donโt like him too much..
Ashfur- you like the Alabama creep who tried to hook up with his half niece. Alright.. I hate him
Mapleshade- I hate her
Hollyleaf- I love her so much
Bluestar- I like her/neutral
Firestar- I like him/neutral
Lionblaze- uh I was ok with him until the place of no stars was released-
Hawkfrost- I hate him
Berrynose- I HATE HIM SO MUCH. Heโs the biggest jerk who bullies cats for the joy of it. JUST READ VEIL OF SHADOWS. Iโm so glad he died
Spottedleaf- I donโt like her
Crowfeather -Heโs amazing ๐
Ashfur – He was very mean to squirrelflight later on, but I see why you like him!
Mapleshade -Such an annoying cat, it was her fault her kits died, she literally saw bridge but she decided to cross the river instead? But she is the greatest villain of all time *wink wink* Hollyleaf- Yes! Bluestar: Definitely! Firestar -agree with Briarpaw and I think heโs cool Lionblaze- Kinda Hawkfrost -Nah but great villain Berrynose- He =Obnoxious twit. Spottedleaf – She was to perfect but I donโt hate her. Great Article.
Rusty never won. Longtail was about to kill him via choking, but Rusty’s collar broke. I would call that a Longtail victory.
Amazing article!!! ๐ ๐ ๐
I agree with you!
The article is written very well! ๐
(And I love your name! <3)
Crowfeather: Ehhhโฆreading Crowfeatherโs Trial, attempting to figure him out (I still might write a defense article for him!)
Ashfur: grrrrrrrrโฆโฆ
Mapleshade: hmmmโฆ..
Hollyleaf: sure?
Bluestar: Liked her better in Bluestarโs prophecy
Firestar: heโs overrated
Lionblaze: hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmโฆโฆโฆโฆ..
Hawkfrost: I hate him, he tried to kill Ivypool. Heโs also a jerk and heโs dead
Berrynose: no thank you
Spottedleaf: I AGREE WITH YOU COMPLETLY!
Great article, Darklily!
I don’t hate Mapleshade, but I don’t get people who dislike Appledusk or are sympethetic about her situation. I just don’t understand it and I never will.
Crowfeather: meh he is okay I liked him as crowpaw
Ashfur: ewwww I hate him
Maple shade: no! So mean to crookedstar
Hollyleaf:Yuck all she cares about is the warrior code
Bluestar: meh
Firestar: I like him
Lionblaze: meh
Hawkfrost: yeahโฆ no
Berry nose: annoying
Spottedleaf: I like her
Sorry I used the same thing as you briarpaw