Why I think Firestar is a complete Gary Sue by Rose’Paw

Rose’Paw shares their opinion on Firestar.

Art by NatameSecrea

Hi, I’m Rose’Paw! Thank you for looking into my article and I really hope you like it. It’s my first article so i’m sorry if it’s completely terrible. I tried my hardest.
Enough chit-chat, let’s start already!
First of all, let’s get to the topic. Firestar. I think he’s a total gary sue. Sure, he has some kittypet roots, but we’ll talk about that later.
He was the cat of the “Fire will save the clan” prophecy. Some people may not think that, but it’s okay to disagree with this point, but he was a kittypet. At the time Spottedleaf retrieved this, he was still a plump kittypet tom with no idea of the clans or the outside world. Doesn’t that make him seem a little too special? I personally thought it should have been some other loyal, senior warrior to have this prophecy.
In the begging, I loved him because he brought us into the world of warriors. He learned quickly the ways of the clans. But was it a little too fast? He learned how to hunt basically in a couple days and he adjusted to life as a wild cat far too quickly. I believe that the Erins just wanted to make him seem special. It was like he was never a kittypet ever, and I think that makes him a little too perfect for my liking. Anyways, let’s get to the next point.
The prophecies.
Don’t you just think it takes away from the Power of three prophecy? I mean, he already got his own prophecy dedicated to him. Why ruin Jayfeather, Lionblaze’s and Dovewing’s? I think the Erins just wanted to make him more special and perfect than he already is. The last moment he came in and was like, “Hey guys, im even more of a gary sue because i just crashed your prophecy!” Like, why would you include him? He did nothing. In my opinion he didn’t need to be in there, it just ruined it all.
So, in conclusion, the Erins tried too hard to make him perfect and I don’t know why anyone likes him at this point. Also, I think he is kind of dumb. He has a loyal mate but is still padding after some dead she cat. I would go on, but that will (Hopefully) be in a different article. Anyways, thank you for reading my first article, I hope you liked it and sorry if you don’t agree with me, this is all just my opinion and it’s not my job to change your mind. Bye guys! Rose’Paw out!

Fan Articles


  • 1
  • 2