oakheart VS thrushpelt: who was better for bluestar? by Hollyfrost and Willowpaw

Hollyfrost and Willowpaw debate who would’ve been a better mate for Bluestar.

( me/hollyfrost) : hello! it’s me hollyfrost back with another article! and today me and willowpaw/fur will be doing “oakheart VS thrushpelt :who was a better choice for bluestar?” now enough chitchat and let’s see what willowpaw has to say! take it away!

(willowpaw/fur): hi! so hollyfrost and i are debating, and i’m debating on the side that bluestar should’ve chosen thrushpelt! hollyfrost is going to debate that bluestar should’ve chosen oakheart, like she did! okay, so now we’re going start debating.

so, i think bluestar should’ve chosen thrushpelt because he was in her clan, and it would just be so much easier for both of them. thrushpelt truly loved bluestar, and bluestar said once that, “i would’ve been happy with you [thrushpelt].” plus, oakheart and bluestar didn’t really have much development.

(me/hollyfrost): good points! i honestly think oakheart was right for her because it just feels like they we’re made for each other. as for they we’re in different clans, a lot of warriors relationships are like that and it doesn’t make THAT much of a difference. if bluestar and oakheart weren’t mates, than stonefur and mistyfoot (star) wouldn’t be alive. i understand they didn’t have that much development, but they did have a lot of fun and love with/for another.

(willowpaw/fur): i understand Mistystar and Stonefur wouldn’t be alive, but bluestar could’ve had other kits or no kits at all. plus, someone else could’ve sacrificed themself for feathertail and stormfur. i’m pretty graystripe would do that or some other riverclan cat. also leopardstar would have appointed another cat deputy that was not hawkfrost, because leopardstar became leader before hawkfrost joined.

i think bluestar did love thrushpelt- but just as a friend. also thrushpelt loved bluestar. she may have not loved him as she loved oakheaert, but as i said before, bluestar even said “she could’ve been happy with him.”

anyway, great arguments!

(me/hollyfrost): i understand what your saying, i just feel like bluestar and oakheart were meant for each other, yea sure she would’ve been happy with thrushpelt, but she loved oakheart the most. and it was really sweet how mistystar and stonefur forgave her while she was dying. also if mistystar and stonefur weren’t alive, than she would’ve died in a instant, she had firestar,mistystar AND stonefurs help. i know she would’ve died anyways, but not as slow as she did. it’s been awhile since i read bluestar’s prophecy (it’s also my fav book), but i think bluestar loved oakheart more than any other tom.