[a design of Firestar sitting and looking over his shoulder]

10 Warrior Cats I Think are Overrated by Flintpaw

Art by Aniritak

Flintpaw argues these characters are overrated

Hi! I’m Flintpaw, or Flinty, and I welcome you to my third article! Today, I will be listing 10 cats from Warriors that I think are overrated. Hope you like it!

10. Crowfeather
I mainly think he’s overrated because he was with both Feathertail AND Leafpool. This is why everybody likes him so much, when there is so much more about him. Also, he has his own super edition, which makes people like him even MORE.

9. Feathertail
Everyone likes Feathertail. She “saved” Crowfeather from Sharptooth, and all the cats mourned for her. Crowfeather asked Tallstar to NAME him after her when he probably could’ve saved himself. She is kind of a Mary Sue, as we say.

8. Yellowfang
People like her because they have sympathy for her. She got kicked out of ShadowClan. That really doesn’t sound too bad to me. Her son killed her mate, then he got kicked out of ShadowClan too! I wouldn’t even say she connected with Raggedstar. (not that I’ve read Yellowfang’s Secret) And she KILLED her son. Why would you have sypathy for a murderer?

7. Russetfur
She is loved because of her “boldness” and “seriousness”. SHE WATCHED BERRYNOSE GET CAUGHT IN A FOX TRAP. Then she said it wasn’t her problem. She didn’t even attempt to help him. Just watched him lose his tail.

6. Spottedleaf
Very Mary Sue. Firestar is in the ThunderClan camp for about five seconds and he’s like “oH wHaTs ThAt ReAlLy GoOd SmElL”. BOOM they’re in love. Of course, Spottedleaf is so good-smelling. That’s actually kinda creepy if you ask me. A cat that smells good every time you walk by. Hmm…

5. Silverstream
To be completely honest here, I think Silverstream wasn’t really a good character. She just saved Graystripe from drowning, they became mates, had kits and BOOM. She dead. Then she gave Firestar a life. How nice.

4. Brightheart
She gets so much love because she got her eye ripped out. She is Firestar’s son’s mate, too. It’s mostly the obscene amount of sympathy she gets that makes her overrated.
3. Hollyleaf
Oh, Hollyleaf. She killed Ashfur because he knew her secret, but he tried to kill her,too. Then she TOLD her clan that secret and Hawkfrost killed her in The Great Battle. How heroic.
2. Tawnypelt
Now she just straight up betrayed her clan over a COMMENT FROM AN ELDER. Like, seriously, you go to your killer father’s clan because an old guy told you that you did a bad job. Really.
1. Firestar
Mr. Perfect. Everyone loves him. He is SO Gary Sue that it’s not even funny. He is the most overrated cat in all of Warriors history. He was in love with the creepy-smelling Spottedleaf. Then, he had kits with Sandstorm, but Cinderpelt ALSO loved him. Seriously, Firestar?

I hope you enjoyed my article!

Fan Articles

63 comments

  • Nooooo!! Don’t say like that about Feathertail, Firestar, Spottedleaf, Hollyleaf, Brightheart and many more listed cats! But I agree with Russetfur!

    • 💥ᠻꪶꪖ᥅ꫀꫝꫀꪖ᥅ꪻ❤𝕗Lᗩя𝒆𝕡άW💥𝕱𝖑𝖆𝖗𝖊❤𝔽𝕝𝕒𝕣𝕖𝕪💥Belugasong💦 Who is eating Oreo icecream cake, YUM says:

      How do you agree with the most underrated cat on the list and don’t agree with the most overrated? i just find that amusing 🙂

  • I can sort of agree with YellowFang- though I personally dislike her for reasons that are of no fault of the character herself. The rest I have a difficult time grasping- and I definitely believe RussetFur is very, very, very underrated in the fandom. In the books she is praised- but I don’t know another person other than myself who marks her as a favorite character. In any case, nice article, whether I agree with the points or not.

  • If you are saying that Firestar and Spottedleaf are overrated in the fandom then you’d be wrong because the fandom HATES them. If you are saying that the other characters overrate them then you’d be right about Firestar, but Spottedleaf isn’t overrated because Firestar is the only cat who likes her. I do think that the authors making her a novella was sorta dumb, but it really doesn’t matter. Nice article!

  • I disagree with all of them except Firestar, he so Gary sue it’s not even funny. But it’s your opinion and I respect that. Great 📰article

  • Nice article!
    I disagree with pretty much everything, maybe except Brightheart (I hate Spottedleaf but I’ve only met 5 or so people who like her, so she’s well rated for me)? I actually think Firestar is underrated of all things, be gets called a Gary Stu, or annoying so much, and I really do love him 😀

  • I actually agree with you. Except Spottedleaf, Firestar, and Tawnypelt. But I do agree that Tawnypelt is too loyal to a fault. However, she is still a okay character.
    I so much agree with Feathertail! Thank you very much. She is really overrated (Although I disagree with Mary Sue part. But she was indeed a Mary Sue in New Prophecy but Shadow of Riverclan changed it.) She has terrible character development (because somehow she become loyal in SR and suddenly be all nice to strangers) and have undesirable traits (like recklessness, being naive, and etc). I am going to erase my copy and add some more about why I think Feathertail is a bad character.
    I also agree with Brightheart. I know you guys are going to try to kill me, but she is actually overrated. Silverstream too. Spottedleaf is overhated but she is a weird cat.

    I think you should add:
    Jayfeather
    Squirrelflight
    (Not Leafpool, cause 50% of the fandom hates her for not being a good mother and spoiled. I mean she is really overhated)
    Sorreltail (Everyone loves her because how she handles her grief)

  • Drizz is now an evil munchkin (declared by Moonblaze) and loves her gift from exchange! シ❣︎𝙳𝚛𝚒𝚣𝚣𝚕𝚎𝚙𝚊𝚠/𝚍𝚛𝚘𝚙, 𝚜𝚑𝚎/𝚑𝚎𝚛❣︎ says:

    I’m not gonna get into details, but I 100% disagree with Hollyleaf!

  • I am so so sorry that I have to say this, but I completely disagree with EVERYTHING in this article. Like, YELLOW FANG IS NOT A MURDERER! SHE KILLED HER SON TO SAVE THE CLANS LIKE THAT IS THE BRAVEST THING A MOTHER COULD’VE EVER DONE! BROKENSTAR IS BAD! ALSO FOR FEATHERTAIL, SHE IS LITERALLY THE NICEST CAT ALIVE AT THAT POINT!

    • 💥ᠻꪶꪖ᥅ꫀꫝꫀꪖ᥅ꪻ❤𝕗Lᗩя𝒆𝕡άW💥𝕱𝖑𝖆𝖗𝖊❤𝔽𝕝𝕒𝕣𝕖𝕪💥Belugasong💦 Who is eating Oreo icecream cake, YUM says:

      feathertail = ded

  • I love Brightheart!! I also LOVE Silverstream, Yellowfang, and Hollyleaf. Great article! I also kind of like Spottedleaf.

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art