[Ashfur stares forward with narrowed eyes]

Why some of the unpopular/popular opinions were wrong by Wisteriapaw

Art by GrayPillow

Wisteriapaw critiques some popular theories/opinions

Hello, Blogclanners, I’m Wisteriapaw and this is my first article ever written on a blog!
I gathered some unpopular/popular opinions that I thought they might be wrong. Here it’s why.

1. Sunningrocks drama
I heard some rumors to call them, that some warriors fans think that Sunningrocks truly belongs to Riverclan. Well, that’s not necessarily true. Sunningrocks ONCE belonged to Riverclan but due to a natural disaster, Sunningrocks were on Thunderclan’s territory to say like that, making it difficult to protect the borders when the Riverclan hunting patrols are so close to their border. It must be confusing when you’re used to watch the hunting/border patrols on the other shore or in the water. And the second reason is that Riverclan cats eat FISH and IF they find it and catch it, some water-shrews, not mice, squirrels nor birds.

2. Ashfur is Dovewing’s and Ivypool’s father
That’s likely to be an unpopular opinion because it got denied every time. Let me deny it too! Firstly, Ashfur never cared about Dovewing’s and Ivypool’s mother, Whitewing. Birchfall was the only one who could be Whitewing’s daughters father. Long story short, this opinion was made due the fact Dovewing nor Ivypool had their parents’ pelt colour. Their kits can have their mother’s or father’s pelt colour but it can have their own fur too. After all, Dovewing has Whitewing’s green eyes or her grandfather’s, Cloudtail’s blue eyes (Starclan bless her green/blue eyes)

3. Ashfur WAS NOT an evil cat and he had the right to be in Starclan, the only reason is that he loved to much
Well, I’m not so sure. Can’t he just get over it, find another mate who can have with a wonderful, drama-free life? He even wanted to kill three innocent cats because of his obsession for Squirrelflight. How could he think he will win Squirrelflight’s heart when he made so many cats to suffer? Congratulations to Hollyleaf for killing him! I never really liked him from his first appearance.
Well, this is all. Comment down if you have something to say.! REMEMBER THIS IS MY FIRST ARTICLE!

Fan Articles


  • Great article and I totally agree! ….StarClan was too soft with Ashfur

  • great article! however a better title could be “why i disagree with some unpopular opinions). opinions can’t be right or wrong ๐Ÿ™‚

  • ashfur being in starclan was a good twist and a major plot point so i dont blame the writers for putting him in starclan
    but yellowfang cmon girl i thought u were better than that

  • ๐ŸŒŠStreampaw's Cafe, Bubble Tea and Cookies For Sale!๐ŸŒŠ (Streampaw/lark, she/her) says:

    Nice article! I agree about everything. Maybe you could title it “Why I Disagree With Some of the Unpopular/Popular Opinions” instead of why they’re wrong so that it doesn’t hurt people’s feelings if they disagree with what you said? Your points were great!๐Ÿ™‚

  • Yeah I agree with ashfur being evil. he almost killed leafpools kits because he was so desperate to erase every part of brambleclaw and squilfโ€™s relation ship. Though I donโ€™t really ship squilf with anyone anyways with bramblestar being a toxic mate, anyways yeah Ashfur went to the extreme in stealing his body.

    • That’s one of the reasons I hate Ashfur! You’re honestly very true! Ashfur ruined everything and everyone!

  • Ashfur also was in love with Squrrielflight at the time. I ship WhitexBirch so much! Also, does anyone find it funny that Ivypool and Birchfall both trained in the dark forest? I mean, itโ€™s a funny way to spend some father and daughter time.

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art