Mistypool wonders if Hal is Jake’s father.

Hello everybody! Today, I have a new theory, is Hal, Jake’s father?
I am the first to think of this, I just, thought about it, and I thought it could make some since. I know that Hal is brown, but, he could have had another mate, who is red, I like to call her Pepper. So I would also assume that Pepper would have had green eyes, because how else would he get them? Also, I know warrior cats don’t really follow genetics, but whatever. And I know what your all saying, “But Hal’s mate is Featherstorm!” You would all be right, but, how do we know that Featherstorm was his ONLY mate? He could have gotten with Pepper like, a year or two before he got together with Featherstorm. He could have left Pepper, for some reason, and he would have rejected Jake.
Just a quick note, I just thought about this, even though its very bad, and that is why Hal is a VERY bad father, is that he found out his son was gay, (Tallstar’s Revege) and hes like; “Heck no!” and then left.
So, anyways, I feel like that Hal could be Jake’s father, and that would make… Raggedstar… Firestar’s Half uncle, as Jake and Raggedstar would be half brothers, and that means that Brokenstar and Firestar, are related, like, cousins twice removed. Then, after being rejected, Jake met Talltail, all the stuff with Tallstar’s Revenge, and the ‘Revenge’ part happens, and then they sadly left eachother. Then Jake decided to change… you know what… and then got together with Quince. Then didn’t want to see his children get sold, so he left, had kits with Nutmeg, then, I guess died of being old, or hes still alive somewhere. Because; “Jake is everyone’s father, Jake is my father, Jake is your father.” There is the quote from Moonkitti, not exactly.
You can believe this if you like, but if you don’t, that is fine, I won’t feel offended, I just thought I should share this.
Justanother fast note, it also says one of his kits is Russetfur, but that could of been Jake’s sister, and it also has an unnamed she’cat as one of his mates, so that could be Pepper.
Bye, bye, everybody! See you guys another time!
Actually, cat genetics don’t work the same way as human genetics do. If a cat has a grandparent with a certain coloring, even if their parents don’t have that coloring, the cat can still inherit it and look like its grandparent. It’s a little more complicated than that, but that’s kind of the basics. Also, that is a very interesting idea! I suppose it’s possible. I can’t even follow where this is going though. :’) (First Comment?)
Nice article, but I disagree. First of all, Crystal was actually Jake’s mother, and she is a ginger-and-white she-cat with glossy fur and blue eyes. So Hal being Crystal’s mate would make no sense according to the very basics of genetics. Hal also lives halfway across the forest, and wasn’t Hal a rogue or something?
Crystal also appeared in Pinestar’s Choice when Pinestar was an apprentice, while Hal was the father of Raggedstar, who was a kit when Pinestar was well into leadership. So the numbers don’t really match up either.
Pepper could work for the mother of Russetfur, however.
But Jake would still be red, since toms get the red gene from their mothers. And for the white part, he could have the gene for white without it being expressed since the scale of spotting isn’t genetically influenced. But, I’m not sure how the eyes would work, since no one seems to know anything about eye genetics in cats.
oh idk anything about genetics but I’m pretty sure both parents have to have green eyes for the kid to have green eyes. But in general, Hal being Jake’s father just wouldn’t work.
I get what you’re saying, but, let’s be honest, when has genetics ever been realistic in warriors? :,)
no- and thats why i put the theory here!
Yeah I wrote this before I found that out- but I basicly just called them Pepper- I nevers said they could not be named that!
also there could be proof that like- Jake was never crystals and he was given to her by Pepper
Wow. I never thought about that, but it makes sense…………… great article!
(First comment?)
THANKS!!!
I hadn’t thought of that, Mistypool. That’s a deep theory and definitely an interesting one! Fantastic job!
ty!
great theory! but i think this is a bit closer to fanfiction? 🙂
Little bit, but not as overt as some other articles are 🙂
Great Article!!
Great article!!
great article! (first comment?)
Great article!
Interesting!
But Jake does have a mother, Crystal. Vicky also posted on Facebook that Jakes dad is a brown cat with green eyes named Mocha. But this doesn’t completely debunk your theory, because one, I heard her Facebook isn’t accurate(but I’m not sure), and two, you could switch Pepper with Crystal and the theory stays the same.
Nice article by the way!! 🙂
Well until canon says it I’m not going ‘ALWAYS LISTEN TO AUTHORS MODE’
Hey if Russet Fur is red (like her mother)and she is Hals daughter who says she can’t be Jake’s sister and Fire Stars aunt!🐈👍
Yeah that was a theory I had too! Crystal/Pepper was also Russetfur’s mother!
I’ve never thought of that :)!
I love Russetfur, we should get soem backstory for her!!
Interesting Theory MistyPool, I agree that it could be possible i wonder if we will ever find out!
ikr