Fan ArticlesSkyecho shares their opinion of Hollyleaf.
Hi everyone! This is my first article and all I could think of is ‘Why I Hate Hollyleaf’. First of all, sorry to all those that like Hollyleaf. So, one of the reasons why I hate Hollyleaf was when she was like ‘the Warrior Code is so important! Millie doesn’t belong to ThunderClan because the Warrior Code says so!’ It’s not like the Warrior Code says ‘loners and kittypets that join the clan must be kicked out!’ As far as I can remember, in Code of the Clans, a cat suggested to let all cat that are not clan born be kicked out, even the ones that are already there and it was refused to be in the Warrior Code. Besides, that means Firestar would be kicked out, and probably Leafpool, Squrrelflight, Jayfeather (Jaypaw then), Lionblaze (Lionpaw then), and she, Hollyleaf (Hollypaw), herself would probably get kicked out, too! Is that what she wanted? Hollyleaf, in my opinion, is like Clear Sky (Skystar) when he kept ordering who and who doesn’t belong. Skystar was like, “You don’t belong! You are just a rogue!” when River Ripple (Riverstar) tried to answer the question Storm asked in The First Battle in Dawn of the Clans. I mean, I guess Millie was mean to Blossomfall when Blossomfall went into the tunnels with Ivypool and Millie thought Briarlight was the only one important, since she lost the use of her legs, but that’s in the future! Besides, Hollyleaf had to kill a cat, Ashfur, to hide a secret, but then spoiled the whole thing in a Gathering! And she also broke the so important ‘Warrior Code’ by doing so! What’s the use of killing a cat to hide a secret and then spoil it like a moon after? Isn’t that just weakening the clan? She was mad at Lionblaze for breaking the ‘Warrior Code’ by meeting up with Heathertail, and breaks the rule herself? Meeting up with a cat from another clan is way better than killing a cat from the SAME CLAN! She was mad at Lionblaze for not telling the truth about being with Heathertail, and doesn’t tell them about killing Ashfur! The only thing I feel sympathy for her is when she dies. How she dies is sad. I hate Hawkfrost more than Hollyleaf, as a matter of fact. Oops. I’m going off track.
Embers of an Autumn Dawn | Emberdawn
🤍🪷 Lilybreeze 🪷🤍
Birchfoot
Goldenfawn
✧˖°🍾⋆˙⟡ pineblossom (she/her) 🦢💫🩰 ain’t life just awfully strange? 🌨️🧸🕯️mentor to skyshimmer! 🌲⋆✴︎˚｡⋆
![[image description: Sparrowtail, Toadfoot, Mousewhisker, Sparkpelt, and Lightningtail are depicted with literal representations of their names]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/warriors_cats_names_taken_literally_8_by_iycewing_dcd37cz-fullview-385x300.jpg)
Good article! I agree
Also, having a person who’s barely a middle-schooler and doesn’t fit in with his personal life and is desperate to join your family is one thing; having a fully-grown, mature, intelligent adult woman coolly offering to join your family is another, and also, rather suspicious, I should say. Many cats, not just Hollyleaf, were reasonable to be suspicious, and to hate them for being so is… interesting. Also, their suspicion only lasted for, at most, a month or so, after seeing what I courageous, dedicated, and lively warrior Millie proved herself to be, despite her lack of a warrior name. To add to this, comparing Hollyleaf to Skystar is a massive stretch. Being suspicious in a guarded and honestly reasonable way is NOT the same as going up to a cat and demanding their exile in a cruel and coldhearted manner simply because that cat was injured. ~ Cloudy
She didn’t want Millie to join because it was against the warrior code, not because she was suspicious
Great Article!!
*gets sad*
i respect ur opinion tho
1. Maybe you can’t become the best cat if every decision you make is ‘is it in the warrior code’ but you can’t become evil if you do that either. Hollyleaf didn’t know leafpool was her mother, and when she found out she got a massive depression.
2. When she killed ashfur, she thought it was to DEFEND the warrior code, her mind was thinking ‘he has to die to protect the warrior code’ or something like that.
3. She told everyone at the gathering because was angry at leafpool and crowfeather and thought it was right to! She thought they destroyed the warrior code and deserved it at the time. Also, how is that against the warrior code?
4. She was angry at lionblaze before any of that happened, before everything went wrong. She thought she was defending the warrior code. Also, in the end lionblaze ended it anyways so it must be the right thing.
I love hollyleaf!