Spottedpaw shares their gripes with the series.
This article is a reworking of an article I submitted that was lost. Sad, but hopefully I remember all the points I made in that one. In this article I will be talking about stuff in warriors I dislike. Hopefully this article is long enough. I will also complain about fandom stuff.
1: Frecklewish doesn’t deserve the dark forest. Here is why: It. Was. Pouring. Down. Rain. And a river that was big enough to have BOATS on it was FLOODED now compare that to a cat. Frecklewish saw mapleshade stumble and could barely make out a riverclan patrol coming to save them. She didn’t know the kits where drowning. HOW ON EARTH COULD SHE HAVE HAD SEEN 2 MONTH OLD KITTENS IN THE MIDDLE OF A 30 FEET WIDE RIVER THAT IS FLOODED (so it is more than 30) WHILE ITS POURING DOWN RAIN AND SHE IS A FOOT AND A HALF TALL CAT!!!!!?!??!!?!!!!!She could not have helped at all, and even if she got thunderclan cats it would be way to late. Also, if Rainflower and Russetfur and Blackstar can make it into starclan, so can Frecklewish.
2: I absolutely HATE the “Who will Graystripe choose in starclan.” Like, with Crowfeather, it’s in character that he will choose rather feathertail or leafpool. (I definitely won’t open that wound). But with Graystripe, he can just…. Choose both!? Like, he loves Silverstream and Millie equally. It makes sense he would just be in a polyamory relationship with them. Silverstream would probably be effy about it, but ALITM was full of character inconsistencies, so that one jealous silverstream scene I am not counting because it just goes against everything she said in Graystripes Adventure. Graystripe loves them both, and will “choose” both.
3: Everything about Thistleclaw and Spottedleafs Heart.
4: Pinestar….is the same age as Leopardfoot’s grandma. And don’t you dare say “buuuut the are just cats lol” a ~50-60 year old had a crush on a 15 year old. Pinestar is DISGUSTING AND HORRIBLE.
5: Bluestar and Oakheart are an underdeveloped one night stand with no chemistry. Bluestar had better chemistry with Crookedstar in that one gathering scene that Bluestar and Oakhearts whole “relationship”. (I don’t ship crookedxblue, crookedxbreeze is amazing.)
6: When someone says “I hate Millie”, most people think that person is talking about how she treated blossomfall. But, she treated Briarlight WAY worse that she treated her not-disabled-ivypaw-bully-adult-complain-machine of a daughter. Hear is a quote from
It got cut off 😞
Great article!! But I think it got cut off…
You have an interesting perspective. 👍🏻
Oh no it got cut off 😭
It was great though!
Great article! but I think it got cut off 🙁
can you finish it in comments for us?😊 #Ilikegivingemotionalsupport😊
I AGREE WITH THIS SO MUCH!
1: Frecklewish DID NOT deserve this.
2: Graystripe will PROBABLY choose Silverstream. Let’s be honest, will Millie even GO to StarClan?
3: Thistleclaw just needs to die already
4: What is it with grandpa-aged toms getting together with young she-cats??
5: I HATE HATE HATE Bluestar and Oakheart’s relationship. Should’ve been Thrushpelt.
6: Millie was a bad mother all together
1. i think frecklewish deserved the dark forest, but only because i like mapleshade. Still, she was quite harsh when she said that mapleshae didn’t deserve to be a warrior and the kits were half clan creatures.
2 You’re right. Mille was bad and silverstream loved graystripe more than mille ever will.
3. he has and it’s AWESOME. Period.
4. this has happened ONE too many times and I’m TIRED of it.
5. I mean, they loved each other, and i agree that it was underdeveloped, but maybe there was something we didn’t see? I do agree it probably should have been thrushpelt.
6. I hate Millie so much! She was the worst mother ever and bumblestripe, briarlight, and blossomfall don’t deserve such a bad mother.
Aww it got cut off 🙁 these are some great points tho! (I am also a huge Crookedbreeze shipper)
I am SO glad that someone adressed the Pine/Leopard problem. I was reading Pinestars Choice or whatever book and I for real look at the alligences, then at the part I was and I was like, “Leopardfoot was a KIT!!! SHE SHOULD NOT BE MATES WITH PINESTAR!!!” Also I’m pretty sure she had her kits only a little while after she became a warrior.
Nooooooo it got cut off!!! But it was amazing!!! I prefer to stay neutral on Frecklewish, and as for the Graystripe thing: I never really thought abt it… But if he can choose both, can’t Crowfeather as well? And Firestar?(If Spottedleaf was still alive) I hate Spotted x Thistle, its just….. Awful, Pinestar is a creep, BlueXOak is so underdeveloped. They barely knew each other and pretended like they’d been in love forever. I don’t like Millie because of the way she treated all of her kits. She seemed to hate Blossomfall, was overprotective of Briarlight, and just ignored Bumblestripe. Past his apprenticeship, we barely ever see a scene where Millie talks to her son like he’s her son. It’s awful.
Great article!!
AGREED SO MUCH
Great article, I wish it didn’t get cut off. I hope it can get fixed 🙁
It got cut off. But it was a great article. And I agree with all of your points. If Rainflower can fully neglect her kit and get to StarClan, why can’t a cat who couldn’t have done anything even if she tried?
And though I LOVE Crookedstar X Willowbreeze, Bluestar and Crookedstar make WAAAYYY more sense.