Rating Warrior Cats! by Silverstripe

Silverstripe rates characters from the series.

Art by TheMoonfall

Hi!!!!!!!! I am Silverpaw/stripe, and today I will rate some warriors from 1 to 10.
(also this is my first article:))

Starting with favorites!

First up: Mistystar gets a 10/10!
Mistystar is the best out of all contestants. Why? Because of her personality. Mistystar is a kind, generous leader. She is not a Mary Sue (ahem, making Mothwing a elder once), and she is not a terrible cat. Some may say she is soft. (Random tom: “She is soft!”.) But, she is a great leader, soft or not.

Next: Leafstar gets a 9/10!

Leafstar is second best. **ducks under acorn**. The only reason she isn’t higher is because she trusted Sol/Harry. (well, Sol manipulated everyone, so…..). Sorry Willowhawk/star(she did a WHOLE ARTICLE about Leafstar being underrated.) So, with all due respect, give Leafstar a round of applause! **random audience claps**

Next up: Spottedleaf gets an 8/10!
**Spottedleaf haters boo**. Ok, ok, I did take some points off for: 1. Loving blindly, 2. She is consdered a stalker in Firepaw/heart/star’s dreams, and 3. Just because.

Again, next: Ravenpaw gets 7/10!
**more booing**. Sorry, sorry, ok? Ravenpaw is not my favorite, but I do not hate him, soooooo he has to somewhere, right?

NEXT: Ivypool gets 6/10!
I love Ivypool, but **tinkers with calculator**, she gets 40% off for Training in the DF.

Next: Dovewing gets a 5/10!
Dovewing. Where to begin. A flawless Mary Sue. Do not hate. Do not love. Somewhere in between. Which is why 1/2, 2/4, 3/6, 4/8, and 5/10.

Whew. That was a lot. Now onto least favorite.

First up: Cloudtail gets a 4/10!
**dodges tomato**. Ok. Why is he on my list of least favorite cats? Well, first, he never moved from Brightpaw/heart’s side when she was hurt. While that is viewed as sheer kindness, imagine if you were Brightheart at that time. Like Frostkit said in “Why I dislike the BrightxCloud ship”, if someone you only knew as a friend sat by you, day after day, wouldn’t that feel creepy?

Next: Clawface gets a 3/10!
I. Do. Not. Like. Clawface. One. BIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Again, next: Darkstripe gets a 2/10!
He is a terrible supporting antagonist that is close to Tigerstar (1). He is annoyingly loyal to Tigerstar (1), and even Tigerstar (1) was annoyed by his eagerness to please him and slyness. So, he is worse than CLAWFACE! 2/10 for him, that is what he deserves!

Okay. So, before I reveal my least favorite cat IN THE WHOLE WARRIORS SAGA, I’d like to mention two cats who helped me come to this conclusion!

Willowhawk/star
Frostkit/Frost/Frapple

So……………………………………………..
My least favorite cat is………
HAWKFROST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So, Hawkfrost was shady from the start, with his suspicious cold, blue eyes staring evilly at cats. Then, he killed Firestar [1 life] (with the help of Ashfur). THEN he goes to the DF (thank you, Brambleclaw/star, for getting rid of him. Then, he tricks Ivypool, tries to kill her, AND kills Hollyleaf (silence for Hollyleaf now, please. **silence**). Okay so, now that I am done RANTING ABOUT THAT EVIL HAWKFROST, I’m wrapping up Rating Warrior Cats!

Silverpaw/stripe out.

Fan Articles

27 comments

  • 1
  • 2

  • Good article! Except I am currently reading TBC and must disagree on Mistystar. (If you haven’t read TBC up through Veil of Shadows, stop reading right now.) She exiles Mothwing because of who her parents are when she herself is half-clan and watched her brother get murdered because he was half-clan. She is either old and senile and forgetting things or a hypocrite who learned absolutely nothing from Tigerstar 1 if you ask me. She also exiles 2 loyal warriors for not obeying her orders even though her orders were wrong and they were right to disobey (Which she admits but exiles them anyway), punishing others for her own mistakes.
    But I do agree on many of your favorites. Leafstar is epic 😀

  • Let me get this straight, you hate a cat because he looks shady and killed a character you like? He brother died when he was very young and that can set a child down the wrong path. After that he probaby set his eyes on leader position so his brother did not die for nothing and then his father entered
    his dreams and y’all know the rest. But the point is you can’t judge a book by its cover like you can’t judge hawkfrost for killing a cat without knowing what lead him to it and judging him by his shady looks. He’s a good looking Siamese mix for sake.

    • You’re forgetting the fact that Hawkfrost set up a sign for his sister so that she would become a medicine cat. So that he could then blackmail her into keeping quiet. This is one of the only actions that isn’t influenced by Tigerstar, and is just Hawkfrost being a terrible person. Additionally, he knew what he was doing was wrong, and continued to do bad things anyways. Just because Tigerstar gave Hawkfrost an opportunity to show his colors doesn’t mean the former influenced every action taken by Hawkfrost.

      • Evil cats don’t just appear out of thin air, therris always a reason for there actions from the very start, from then on they due what the desire. Hawkfrost posses ambition from his father so its natural he wants to be leader, it’d in his blood. He uses his sister to help him achieve his ambition by sacrificing her future. He is putting both him and his sister at risk perhaps trying to prove his brothers death was not in vain. This is why you see him reach out to his half brother quite quickly. And wdym by true colors? You don’t know that since an evil father who you look up to could be very manipulating.

  • YES!!! MISTYSTAR IS THE BEST!!!!! 😀 HAVE ALL THE COOKIES!!! 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪 (sorry for all caps!)

  • I agree with most of these, cept Clawface. Clawface is too lame and evil to be in anyone’s list of characters, favorite or least favorite. (Ive only read TPB)

  • Nice article, Silverstripe! I love the originality of the concepts and design in your work, great job! Here are my opinions on the cats listed:

    1. Personally, I think that Mistystar is a very good leader! However, she treats Mothwing unfairly because of her parentage, judging her throughout the entire series – which was also her being hypocritical since she herself is half-Clan and her mother is from ThunderClan.
    2. Leafstar is wonderful! She’s my second-favorite character because of her warmth, compassion, and fairness. I understand how she trusted Sol and why she exiled him from her Clan, even though it lead to him being a threat to the Clans beside the lake.
    3. Spottedleaf, for me, is a good character based on how she acted, though her personality isn’t compelling enough and she’s a bit too much of a Mary Sue for me to love her.
    4. Ravenpaw’s awesome! I can’t really think of a reason to not mark him as one of my favorites.
    5. I’m neutral on Ivypool. Her character development is good, but she’s not exactly the most open-minded, kind character.
    6. I like Dovewing! She’s in my top ten favorite characters from Warriors. She’s not flawless and has her fair share of imperfections, from being a bit ignorant to being overtrusting some times and overly skeptical and defensive others.
    7. Cloudtail is okay, but I disagree about what you said about him and Brightheart. Brightheart enjoyed his company after her injury, and he helped her gain confidence. Besides, the two were already close friends and Brightheart felt encouraged by his presence, not bestranged.
    8. I agree.
    9. Darkstripe’s a good sidekick! It’s amusing to me how he’s always trying to impress Tigerstar… he’s a fairly good villain too. Obviously, I dislike him as a character.
    10. Hawkfrost’s a great villain, but I hate how he manipulated his sister.