Flamefire lists their favourite characters.

Hello! This article, my favorite cats, will be going in order from 10 (least favorite) to 1 (top favorite). Friendly reminder these are just opinions, and also, spoiler for main arcs ahead!
10. Lionblaze – Lionblaze is a fun character. While he’s not the best, being kind of arrogant, he has good qualities to balance the bad. Like his love and loyalty towards Cinderheart. You can’t deny, it was a tiny bit sweet (though irrational and a bad idea) when he decided to pick a fight and let himself get hurt to show he could choose his own path. Though it was a waste of herbs and not a very well thought-out plan, he was trying to show affection. Doesn’t that count for something?
9. Half Moon – Half Moon was so nice and considerate, and there may be bad qualities in her, but honestly when I think of her none come to mind for me. She really, genuinely cared for Jayfeather and while I dislike Jayfeather I thought the ship was really adorable, and I wanted to see more of Half Moon, like her having her own Super Edition or Novella or Manga, perhaps.
8. Featherwhisker – This tom is inquiring and curious, and though he often butts into other cats’ business, he is a very gentle and caring cat, and I like both him and his brother. It makes me especially said thinking he barely gets any time in the spotlight. Go, Featherwhisker!
7. Yellowfang – Ah, yes, the grumpy cat. Now. Yellowfang went through so much, and honestly, I can’t say that justifies her need to be endlessly grumpy, but it’s not like it started out that way for her. It’s not like she was grumpy and rude from the beginning, unlike a certain tom, who was grumpy since apprenticeship. If you think about it, Yellowfang, though no blind, went through many struggles, most of them with Raggedpelt (ugh), and her son, Brokenstar. Yes, Brokenstar’s existence is partly her fault, but the emphasis on partly. Raggedpelt was basically pressuring Yellowfang into a relationship some of the time, and then ignoring her. Yellowfang wasn’t treated very fairly, and though I believe they had a small amount of chemistry, it is mostly Raggedpelt’s fault for not giving Brokenpaw a suitable mentor, and discipline. Also, Yellowfang made up for it (a bit) by killing Brokenstar, and being a good mentor to Cinderpelt.
6. Firestar – Ah yes, the overrated cat! Let’s give him the spotlight, shall we? Before I go on about Firestar’s good deeds, let me just say that he has made mistakes. And some good things he’s done hasn’t made up for that, but honestly I feel like he gets hate from the fact that since he’s got a lot of time for him to shine that everyone gets to point out his meager flaws and exploit them,
aw it got cut off! great article though, I love Lionblaze! (first comment?)
Aww, it got cut off! I was really looking forward to reading it. But, from what I’ve read, great article! I agree with Firestar, Yellowfang, Featherwhisker and Half Moon. But, I don’t really like Lionblaze. I mean, I LOVE his sister, Holly, and Jay is awesome as well. But, Lionblaze just never really caught my eye. Like, he killed (or tried to kill) A LOT of cats, and he never uses his very cool superpower. He just isn’t a cat that I enjoy. Anyways, here are my top ten favorite cats:
10. Hollyleaf
9. Ivypool
8. Mapleshade
7. Moth Flight
6. Leafpool
5. Spottedleaf
4. Feathertail
3. Silverstream
2. Squirrelflight
1. FIRESTAR!!!!!!!!!!!! <333333333333 He is just SO AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!<333333333
Ok, sorry about that. Anyways, I liked your article! It was very interesting! Bye! <3
Yay a fellow Silverstream and Mapleshade lover!
Nice article! Sorry it got cut off 🙁
Great Article!!
Yessssss another Featherwhisker lover! He’s way too underrated. Anyway great article! Sorry it got cut off.
I agree! Featherwhisker and Goosefeather are definitely my favourite pair of medicine cats. Also Sunstar is awesome – Moonflower should’ve been his mate, not Stormtail’s
Yeah! Stormtail’s a jerk!
Great article! I like all of these characters, though I do think Lionblaze is a bit annoying and arrogant in my opinion. Sorry that your article got cut off! Maybe you could just list the rest of your favourites in the comments?
Great article! I like all of these characters, though I do think Lionblaze is a bit annoying and arrogant in my opinion. Sorry that your article got cut off! Maybe you could just list the rest of your favourites in the comments?
Amazing Article! Shame it got cut off, maybe you could post the rest of it in the comments.
Cool article! Sad it got cut off, tho
My top ten favorite cats
10. Cinderpelt she was a pain as an apprentice I only liked her when she became a med cat but she was a great confident cat that could have never done better
9. Clear Sky his story was interesting I never seen any cat become evil because of fear but then somehow healed
8. Needletail she was first a follower of Darktail but then realized her mistake and sacrificed herself to save Violetshine when she could have ran away and it was a nice thing for her to do
7. Ivypool ( Dovewing is here too but ivy has a better reasoning) she went to the dark forest but realized her mistake and convinced the other trainees to fight for the clans and that made dark forest cats that deserved starclan go to starclan
6. Ashfur he suffered a LOT okay. First his mother died then the cat he liked rejected him and then hollyleaf killed him and she is related to squirrelflight so I defo like him
5. Blossomfall and briarlight both of them suffered somthing but made changes in the book Briar helped jay and blossom trained in the dk so then when ivy convinced her she was ready
4. Jayfeather he is a rude cat but just like me I get mad easily and also he is blind what can you expect and if you turn into a friend with him you will have a friend for life
3. Sorreltail she was a great cat she told the clans about Darkstripe, protected the nursery, was a good mate, hid her wounds just to see her kits she deserves 3
2. Spottedleaf she was a kind cat. She was one of the few cats that welcomed rusty, she broke off with thistleclaw but not rudely and she is one of the kindest cats ever but people keep posting mean things about her. PLZ tell me if you are a lover of spotted
1. Scourge his story was SOO interesting and how he started as a tiny weak cat to a powerful cat was amazing. Even if he took one of firestar’s life he took all of tigerstar’s so well tigerstar could have taken all of firestar’s lives before going into the dark forest
I agree with most of these, and I love Spottedleaf #Spotted4Eva ~ Cloudy
Nice! Sorry it got cut off!
Aw, got cut off. But I really agree with your opinion on Half Moon. It would be nice to see more of her. Great article!
Interesting article! I agree with the men st of them cuz I haven’t read any Super editions yet