Sunshinepaw lists Firestar’s main flaws and how they can be changed.
Hi, it’s Sunshinepaw here with her first article in BlogClan. I am trying my hardest to type 350 or more words for my article to be published. So, today I’m going to be talking about all the flaws of Firestar. Before we dive in, I know Firestar has already gone to StarClan and the authors really can’t change much about Firestar’s character or behavior, so I am going to act like Firestar has not died yet. Also, this is a copy and paste version of something I have written in real life. Now let’s let the past me who wrote this article dive into today’s topic: The 2 Main Flaws Of Firestar And How To Change Them.
Hi, welcome to today’s topic: The 2 Main Flaws of Firestar and How to Change Them. Let’s dive in.
1) He always gets away with light punishments
Now, this is the first one I thought of when I was thinking about what to write. He always gets light punishments when he is in trouble. For example, taking care of a cat for a moon, picking herbs for the Medicine Cat, or picking the Elders’ ticks for a moon. I wonder why Bluestar always gives him special treatment (I’m not criticizing Bluestar, she is my favorite cat in the whole entire Warriors universe). When he gave prey to Yellowfang, a ShadowClan cat, and later led her into camp, his (light) punishment for breaking the Warrior Code was only to take care of Yellowfang for a moon. Just a moon! That’s RIDICULOUS! ( Sorry I was yelling, I was just too angry) The authors should make him get some more severe punishments sometimes.
2) He somehow doesn’t struggle with leadership, even though the times he leads ThunderClan though is one of the hardest
This is another really, really big flaw with him. Every decision he makes seems to be the right one and his plans always seem to work! The Warriors authors made a perfect leader for nothing! Why? I think it’s because they wanted to create a kittypet hero to show that kittypets can be leaders and/or heroes/heroines. Yet, they don’t have to be perfect. The authors could make a cat that wasn’t perfect, but he/she could be underestimated at the beginning and turn out to save the clan in an urgent situation or something. That would be way better than having a perfect cat.
That’s all for today’s article. Hope you enjoyed and have a purrfect day!
– Sunshinepaw
great article I hate Firestar (first comment?)
Great article! Firestar is a Gary-Sue sometimes.
Agree
Great article! I don’t rly loo ikr Firestar anymore, he got WAY too Gary Stu-ish for me
May I mention how dumb he becomes after TPB lol.
Firestar isn’t dumb! He’s actually very smart! Yes, he made some some questionable decisions after TPB, but that doesn’t make him dumb! He is my favorite character, and he does not deserve to be hated on bc he is right. Though, I do agree with Sunshinepaw, the Erin’s could have tried to make him at least a little less perfect.
I agree! He’s not dumb, he’s just a bit of a gary-sue(okay, not a bit).
My point is for a fully trained warrior [Or a grown adult, who has gone through school], it was dumb of him to do some of the things he did [Like fighting ShadowClan for no actually good reason just because Ivypaw, a kid told you]
With that Ivypaw point, yes, her sister Dovepaw had magical powers to see and hear everything, but that’s because she was part of the three. The fourth cat prophecy hadn’t existed in Fading Echoes.
Now thinking about it, that was a pretty dumb thing for Firestar to do
I agree. Firestar was AWESOME, but he was, as you said, a little too perfect toward the end.
Great article! I love Firestar, but he’s a bit of a Gary Sue.
Great article! I agree with what you said. I think my biggest flaw with him is that he’s overpowered in the TPB and a bit of a gary-sue. I still love him though
i love firestar, and don’t totally agree, but i understand ur points. amazing article!
I don’t completely agree, but that’s because I love Firestar. Sure, he’s made some bad decisions and he’s slightly over-perfect, but he’s not dumb! The authors could have made him less perfect, but if Firestar was real, that wouldn’t be his fault. Being a little more perfect than preferable isn’t something that he had a choice on. It’s the authors that made that decision.
No offense, though, this is a great article!
The whole rant thing was for the Firestar haters.
I don’t think Firey’s perfect. Firestar is FAR too nosy. Great article tho
I like Firestar! Great article!
Great Article!!
Basically Firestar’s only flaw is having no flaws.