Petalpaw rates characters from the first arc.

Hello! Petalpaw here with her first (i don’t know if the other one was posted??) article!! Today I am going to be rating Warriors from the first series- The prophecy begins! Let’s get to it!
–
Firepaw/heart/star – 8/10
Please don’t be mad. I gave a 9/10 because I feel like he got involved with literally everything at some point. He and Graypaw (at the time) went to bring back WindClan by themselves with no other help. After Cinderpaw got hurt on the thunderpath, Fireheart tells Bluestar that Tigerclaw meant for her to get hurt instead of Cinderpaw. Almost instantly, Tigerstar was exiled, and Fireheart took his place. Seems a bit unfair right?
He also liked someone that was waay older than him and had a hard time letting go of her death. “Firestar realizes that he can have no future with Spottedleaf and then decides to have Sandstorm as his mate.” According to the Wiki.
–
Graypaw/stripe – 10/10
He is extremely loyal! Even though he mated with a RiverClan cat, that in no way drove him from being loyal to his friend and his friend. When Firepaw nearly died from Brokenstar’s rouge group, Graypaw defended the weak Firepaw by attacking and killing him. He also saves his half-sister Sorrelpaw from death when he caught Darkstripe feeding her deathberries.
–
Spottedleaf – 7/10
Now. Hear me out. I didn’t really like Spottedleaf. Yeah, she is a good medicene cat. But the thing is, she was a little creepy. She had a small crush on Firepaw, who was waay younger than her. She said, “she and Firestar could never have been mates,” and before she leaves, she whispers to Firestar’s ear, “wishing things could have been different.” Kinda showing that Spottedleaf wishes she was his mate.
Also, the way I found her a bit creepy is that Spottedleaf really never stopped visiting Firepaw/heart’s dreams. Really, she never stopped. Almost like she was stalking him…
–
Yellowfang – 10000/10
She was defiantly one of my favorites for sure. She may be grumpy but amazing. I was so sad when she had died ;-;. Yellowfang saved so many lives! Yellowfang is extremely smart in herbs and taught Cinderpaw well.
–
That is all for now! Comment if you want me to rate more characters! Its June 28. I wonder what day it will be when this is posted…
Great Article!!
great article!! I like yellowfang when shes alive but they ruined her in starclan
I 100% agree Shadeleap. The Erin’s really butchered some cats, like Yellowfang & OneWHISKER.
Sorry I just—I loved OneWHISKER so much and they just completely ruined him
But they did the opposite with Breezepelt in Crowfeather’s trial. But Onewhisker 😭 I loved him.
I agree!
great article
Amazing article! Keep going!
Great article! I agree with these ratings, but I’d give graystripe a 8/10 since being with silverstream resulted in him leaving brackenpaw/fur’s training
Great article! I love Yellowfang too, I just got annoyed with her in Leafpool’s Wish and a lot when she was in StarClan 🙁
Great article! Firestar is a little too perfect. Graystripe is so loyal and goofy! Nothing to say for Spottedleaf. And I love Yellowfang’s sharp comments! (Most of the time).
Great article! Agreed 🙂
Great article!
I agree, except for Graystripe. I’m probably biased, but he fights Firestar in fire and ice, but then, when he has to do it to prove his loyalty, Graystripe opts out. I love the article though, and the idea.
Awesome article, Petalpaw! This certainly was a blast from the past! 😛
I’d give:
Firestar: 10/10
He’s a REALLY great character! He’s loyal and brave. He’s in my top 5 favorites!
Graystripe: 10/10
I LOVE him! He’s a great warrior! He’s ALSO in my top 5 favorites!
Spottedleaf: 1000000/10
OMG HOW COULD SHE GET SO MUCH HATE?! She’s a really great medicine cat! So what if she had a small crush on Firepaw? I mean, it’s not as if they’re mates, or anything! Also, she’s NOT creepy! Why does mostly everyone think that? It’s not like Sandstorm, who goes to him every single time he’s alone (Sorry everyone I like Sandstorm just not the SandxFire ship, that ship ruined her)!
Also, I mean why does everyone care about an age gap? I mean like, come on, everyone! Just because there’s an age gap doesn’t mean they can’t be a good ship! Even Sandstorm has an age gap with Firestar but NO ONE cares about that! If Sandstorm and Firestar were human, Sandstorm would be like 5 years older than Firestar!
Yellowfang: 10/10
I really like her fiery personality and fierce comments! She’s a great character! I mean, that I know of (I haven’t read all the books yet!)