Leaders and if they were great or not by Goldenpaw

Hi, goldenpaw here and today I will talk about the leaders and if they were good leaders.
1: bluestar. She gave away her kits to become leader. Kinda makes her seem like tigerclaw but seeing as the alternate was thistleclaw, not so much. She is a wise, strong and kind leader who is dedicated to her clan.
2: Firestar. The ultimate leader. He fed riverclan during the floods, brough windclan back, helped drive out brokenstar from shadowclan, and get tigerclaw exiled from thunderclan. Great accoplishments.Oh, and he lead the clans against boodclan. All in all, a noble leader.
3: Brokenstar. Killed his fathernto become leader. He drove windclan out of their territory. Killed kits, and then blamed it on a MEDICINE CAT. He literally got driven out of his own clan, because he was that bad. Not a great leader.
4: Tigerstar(the first one). Got exiled from his own clan and became leader of shadowclan. Tried to tare his old clan apart with dogs(not caring that his mate was in that clan). He killed brindleface and runningwind. Then, the mousebrain tried to work with scourge, even though he had tried to kill him when he was an apprentice. A terrible leader.
5: Mistystar. A nice half clan cat. Don’t judge me on this vague description okay.
6: Leopardstar. She let her own deputy die. Not so much a great leader.
7: Tallstar. Old and friendly. His can got driven out of their territory by a shadowclan patrol, so not that great of a leader at that time. Changing onewhisker to deputy before he died was wise though.
8: Onestar. Rude to firestar, even though he was his old friend and is the reason why onestar is not dead. Alright, he was nice to help thunderclan with the fight against the badgers.
The best leader is easily firestar. The guy helped all the clans in his lifetime, even when it was against the warrior code. The worst leader was definetly tigerstar. Tried to wipe out thunderclan. Even when he was dead, he sought revenge on the clans. I hope you liked this article.