Warrior cats + The Greatest Showman by Flintleaf

Flintleaf compares Warriors characters with The Greatest Showman’s plot.

Official promotional material for The Greatest Showman

Hello! It’s me with yet ANOTHER greatest showman article. Today I will discuss what warrior cats or the greatest showman would’ve been like with some characters from each book/movie included. First I would like to share what would happen if Phineas’ circus was replaced with warrior cats. Trapeze artists- WD wheeler-Swiftpaw. Anne wheeler-Brightheart. Moving on from trapeze we have “The Irish Giant” who should be replaced by Tigerstar since the books described him to be quite large. Next up is “Dog boy” who definetly should be replaced by Samwize even though he looks nothing like him. I wanted a dog that I knew the name of.

Here comes the main character, Phineas Taylor Barnum. He’s the owner of the circus so he must be a leader, and with his relationship with Charity, he should be Firestar. And Charity should be Sandstorm. But how could I forget, now I know nothing could replace Phillip Carlyle as my faviroute character, so let’s see how this goes. Phillip Carlyle’s partner is Phineas and Phillip (I think) Soon became the circus’ owner so Phillip could be Bramblestar!

Here we go again, now I was thinking Mr Bennet and Tigerstar but I already used that so Mr Bennet and Scourge! I don’t really know why I would like Mr Bennet to be replaced, he’s actually quite fun. BUT SCOURGE………………..

Now we move on to Phineas’ (Firestar’s) family tree. Luckily Phineas also has two daughters and no sons so Squirrelflight-Caroline and Leafpool-Helen. Of course Charity is Sandstorm. Now here’s the thing, before I said Phillip was Bramblestar
I’d say he was Crowfeather because of his relationship with Anne Wheeler and how it’s kinda forbidden. His parents(clan) don’t approve of it but that doesn’t
stop him. They even made an entire song representing that (Rewrite the stars)
You know i want you
It’s not a seceret I try to hide
I know you want me
So don’t keep saying our hands our tied
You claim it’s not in the cards
And fate is pulling you
Miles away
And out of reach from me
But you’re here in my heart
So who can stop me if I decide that you’re my destiny?
What if we rewrite the stars
Say you were made to be mine
Nothing could keep us apart
You’d be the one
I was meant to find
It’s up to you
And it’s up to me
No one can say what we get to be
What if we rewrite the stars
Changin’ the world to be ours…
(Then Anne Wheeler comes in and does HER solo and then they sing together)
So yeah, he’s Crowfeather OR Bramblestar

And Jenny Lind is Spottedleaf!
Literally, Jenny Lind had feelings for Phineas but he already had a wife and two children, Spottedleaf is sort of similar?

Hope you enjoyed, feel free to give feedback!

Fan Articles


  • Brackenpaw/tuft who can't wait for the new Owl House episodes! Huntlow forever!!!!!!!!!(A.K.A. Lilypaw and Cricketpaw) says:

    Great article!

  • I enjoyed this article! I haven’t actually seen The Greatest Showman , but I know a TON about it and have heard all the songs, and really, really wanna watch it. <3
    My favorite part of the article was when you said Phillip Carlyle’s your favorite Greatest Showman character, because he’s my favorite as well! 💙