Why Oakstar is the worst cat in warriors that ever lived by Silkflower

Silkflower shares their opinions on Oakstar.

Hello, kits, apprentices, warriors, medicine cats, deputies, leaders, and meditators. I’m Silkflower and in the article, I’m going to tell you why Oakstar is the worst, but I don’t know that much about him, but I just read like 1/4 of a book when I started to hate him, so here we go!

1, because he exiled Mapleshade.

Mapleshade wasn’t a good cat, because she was a villain, but she was a queen! show her some respect! And Oakstar could of just waited until her kits were old enough to actually survive out there! And it was his fault that Frecklewish, Ravenwing, and Appledusk got killed. I’ll tell you why. He exiled Mapleshade, causing her kits to drown in the river. (even though it was part Mapleshade’s fault) And it caused Appledusk to cheat on her to stay in RiverClan, causing her to get mad and she kept hallucinating about her kits drowning so she killed those cats to silence her kits’ cries. Appledusk shouldn’t have cheated on her though.

2, he started EVERYTHING

So when Mapleshade was exiled, she died and went to the dark forest. she ruined Crookedstar’s life, but she wouldn’t have even been there of Oakstar Haden’t exiled her. And also ruined Crookedstar’s life by changing his name. It was Goosefeather that caused him to fall onto the stone, but he was trained by Mapleshade, so I think Mapleshade’s the one who made him do that. And again, it was Oakstar who exiled Mapleshade causing her to end up in the dark forest. and Goosefeather turned into this crazy cat who kept thinking that everything was a sign. like the burning branch, it was true, but he could have just told Bluepaw (later Bluestar) that she should be careful around the river, so she wouldn’t be scared of the river. she could have been much more happier with Oakheart if Goosefeather hadn’t told her that. as for Thistleclaw, who was trained in the dark forest, was probably trained by Mapleshade, and when he died, he planned with Mapleshade for the whole attack on the living world thing with Ashfur, causing Bristlefrost to die, and ruined Bristle X Root. I was so looking forward to having Rootspring join ThunderClan to be with Bristlefrost! but no! she had to die! and if Oakstar hadn’t exiled Mapleshade, it would have never have happened! so there! he started everything!

3, defending Oakstar… kind of?

I don’t know what to do in defending, so I will do defending based on what I know about him. well, he was leader, so that’s gotta be something, because if he wasn’t a good warrior, why would he become deputy? Also, it was understandable to exile Mapleshade, but he shouldn’t have exiled her in the middle of a storm. And he could have just kept Mapleshade under security. Because Mapleshade was a good cat, until she cat exiled and cheated on. so I guess Oakstar made a pretty dumb choice, but some cats are just dumb, and I’m guessing that Oakstar was one of the very very very very very very very very very very very very very dumb cats, but that doesn’t make sense to make him deputy, but whatever, he was dumb, and that’s it.