![[a side profile design of Ashfur running towards the right]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/ashfur__thunderclan__by_skyperch_de3izrj-pre-740x413.png)
Fan ArticlesHollykit shares their opinion on Leafpool and Squirrelflight’s trial.
![[image description: a grey cat with lighter and darker markings in profile view]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/ashfur__thunderclan__by_skyperch_de3izrj-pre-300x168.png)
[image description: a grey cat with lighter and darker markings in profile view]
Hello! Hollykit with another article. You’ve seen the title, and though it may seem obvious, this goes deeper than you might think.
So, Leafpool and Squirrelflight are crushed by a rock and are sent to StarClan for judgement to see if they can go in or not. Now, dedicated readers know that this is going to take a while, as Squirrelflight and Leafpool have done some un-StarClan worthy things.
StarClan go straight to accusing Leafpool of having kits when she’s not supposed to, and Squirrelflight of lying to her Clan about the code-breaking kits. Uh, Yellowfang? You told Squirrelflight to have those kits because she was “infertile.” Also, when Jayfeather asks what Ashfur’s in StarClan, Yellowfang says “He did what he did out of love.” So did Leafpool. Leafpool was mates with Crowfeather out of love. Leafpool had kits out of love. Squirrelflight offering to harbor Leafpool’s kits was so sweet of her, and StarClan had to judge her because of that? Anyway, Leafpool and Squirrelflight were (and are, actually) very loyal to their Clan before and afterwards. So I suppose loyalty and respect to your Clan does not account for code-breaking things you did, even if you didn’t enjoy doing them? Your entrance is judged?
Next up, Ashfur! (This is kinda linked to the Leafpool and Squirelflight one.) Anyway, after he’s killed by Hollyleaf, he goes to (after attempted murder on Firestar and Squirrelflight along with Hollyleaf, Lionblaze and Jayfeather)… StarClan! Yup. After conspiring with Hawkfrost to attempt to kill Firestar because he wanted to let Squirrelflight know how much pain he was in after she rejected him (please) and attempting to kill Squirrelflight’s kits because he, again, wanted her to know how much pain he was in after she left him for Brambleclaw, goes to StarClan. We all shook our heads when we read the scene of Jayfeather seeing Ashfur in StarClan. He broke up with Squirrelflight moons ago! Ashfur and Leafpool did things for the same reason. Why should Ashfur go to StarClan while Leafpool’s judged?
Well, my article might be cut off by now. Hollykit out!
Goldenfawn
Embers of a Winter Dawn (Emberdawn)
🤍🪷 Lilybreeze 🪷🤍
✧˖°🍾⋆˙⟡ pineblossom (she/her) 🦢💫🩰 what are you doing new year's eve? 🌨️🧸🕯️mentor to skyshimmer! 🌲⋆✴︎˚｡⋆
![[a fluffy full-body design of Larksong sitting with his colour palette]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/larksong-warriorcatsdatabase-385x300.jpg)
🚦💵💰 “I've played these games before!” | squid games edition silverdusk 🌊 hyun-ju (my wife) 💗💗 she/her 🗾🍹💚
I feel like there have been a lot of articles about StarClan and StarClan’s judgement and stuff… I really like this one tho, I never thought about how Leafpool broke the code out of love too!
wow speedy moddo
I agree with the whole Starclan stuff, but it’s getting boring with these kind of Starclan arguments…… Hello people we need new content here!
great article! how come it says “by Hollykit” when it’s by Petalkit, though?
fixed!
Actually, Petalkit was my old purrsona, so that’s me. I asked for the title to be changed to “by Hollykit”, so it should be kept to “by Hollykit”. 🙂
articles
Can it be returned to “by Hollykit”? 😛
Done!
Thanks! 😀
Great article! I totally agree!
StarClan are just stupid when it comes to judging cats. They sent Juniperclaw to the DF and Ashfur to StarClan. I’m going to do an article on judging too when I’m not busy
STARCLAN IS THE WORST!!! Their rules, their actions, and even their judgments are the worst! (I’ll make a article about this soon.
Great article! StarClan needs to be more fair…
What Squirrelflight and Leafpool did was out of love, similar to Ashfur. Yet he got in easily and they almost went to the Dark Forest. AND Yellowfang is being hypocritical here. She also had a lot when she wasn’t supposed to as well, but her’s almost destroyed the Clans. Two thirds of Leafpool’s kits helped save the Clans. StarClan needs to get its act together. Sorry ‘bout the rant, mods. I read the article and needed to say something.
Yup, Yellowfang’s judgement leaves a lot to be desired….
…but I must point out, where Ashfur is concerned, Yellowfang’s decision to let him in was likely affected by her own troubled past. Her norm (her relationship with Raggedpelt/star) was essentially an abusive relationship, and she was never told how wrong it was, so thus she believes that Ashfur was in the right, and not awful or creepy at all! No, not in the slightest, Yellow…poor Yellowfang.
But yeah, StarClan’s judgement is still awful because they gave her the power to make that decision, without thinking about her past and what she was likely to do, which was poorly thought out and just MOUSEBRAINED.
(sorry for the rant guys)