[Appledusk and Reedshine walk together while a ghostly Mapleshade watches]

My opinions on the cast of Mapleshade’s Vengeance – Part II by Mysticpaw

Mysticpaw shares the rest of their opinion on characters from Mapleshade’s Vengeance.

[Appledusk and Reedshine walk together while a ghostly Mapleshade watches]
Art by SunClaw (Warriors Amino)
[Appledusk and Reedshine walk together while a ghostly Mapleshade watches]

SPOILER ALERT!! If you haven’t read Mapleshade’s Vengeance, please read it before reading both my Mapleshade articles, ‘My opinions on Mapleshade and the characters in her novella’ and this one! Please be clear that this is my opinion, and you might have completely different viewpoints, but don’t rant about why in the comments. Without further ado, let’s get on with it!
-Mystic

If you haven’t read my first article, go check it out! In that, I stated my opinions on Mapleshade and some of the cast of her novella.

Larchkit, Petalkit, and Patchkit
All three were the real victims of the novella. I absolutely adore all three of them, and they did not deserve to drown. I love everything about them. Patchkit’s adorable relationship with his mom, Petalkit’s never give up personality, and Larchkit’s funny quotes. All that personality and character, in just an approximately (according to the Warrior Wiki) 2 moon old kit. Sorry, what was I saying? I always lose track. Anyway, some quotes to remember the kits by:
“Those are bad words! You’re not supposed to say that!”
-Larchkit

“I’m going to watch that badger eat you first!”
-Petalkit

“No! I want to stay with you forever and ever! Even when I’m an apprentice!”
-Patchkit

Oakstar
Oakstar. You. Piece. Of. Mouse. Dung. Oakstar is the worst leader of ThunderClan in my opinion, and you’ll see why when I explain. He had the audacity to banish a queen and her kits, knowing full well THAT THE KITS WERE STILL NURSING AND FAR TOO SMALL TO GO OUT OF CAMP, LET ALONE GO FOREVER! Okay, sorry for overreacting guys. If any cat deserved the Dark Forest, it’s Frecklewish’s dad, not her. He doesn’t deserve StarClan, and I hope some cat chases him out.

Reedshine
In the comments of many Mapleshade fanarts I have visited on DeviantArt, people (actively) shut down Appledusk and Reedshine with cussing, and I strongly agree with them. (Big no on the cussing though) Wait, what did I mean to cover? Oh, yeah, I remember now. Reedshine could have at least been mad that Appledusk was meeting in secret with Mapleshade. But no. She forgives him and happily starts up a relationship. Yep, you heard me right. It really annoys me that Apple acted all noble and justified (HE WAS NOT!) and Reedshine was stupid enough to believe him.

Fan Articles

11 comments