[Thrushpelt blushes over his shoulder as he glances at Bluestar, who is walking by]

What if BlueStar chose TrushPelt instead OakHeart? by NightFall

NightFall wonders what wouldn’t have happened if Bluestar had loved Thrushpelt instead of Oakheart.

[Thrushpelt blushes over his shoulder as he glances at Bluestar, who is walking by]
Art by diinocuddlez
[Thrushpelt blushes over his shoulder as he glances at Bluestar, who is walking by]

Hi everyone! This is NightFall and what you are reading is my first article! I’ll do my best to make it interesting for you, I hope you like it and I can’t wait to write more!
So my question is, What if BlueStar chose TrushPelt instead of Oakheart?
I’ve always loved the Blue x Oak ship but I’ve always been very upset how TrushPelt was rejected. unfortunately I understand that BlueStar never loved TrushPelt, but what if it did?
First of all there would never have been MossKit, Mistykit and StoneKit…actually if they had never been born Mosskit would never have died. Besides MistyKit and Stonekit would never reach RiverClan and StoneFur would never die while MistyStar would never become leader…that means HawkFrost as leader for RiverClan… thanks but no!
I always cried a lot when I read SnowFur’s death but if BlueStar had never fallen in love with OakHeart, Snowfur would never have run away and consequently never met the ShadowClan intruders…SnowFur would never have died!
Also crucially for BlueStar, it would have been much easier to fall in love with TrushPelt as he was of his own clan…wouldn’t he have suffered for having to make a choice, clan or love? and he should never have to choose between clan and its cubs.
In short, if BlueStar had chosen TrushPelt everything would have been different and I must say that TrushPelt actually deserved a chance but what I liked is that unlike AshFur, after being rejected he managed to go on while still continuing to love BlueStar. But the fact that he couldn’t find anyone like BlueStar I’m very sorry because he deserved to have a partner who appreciated and loved him.
I should probably write another article on why it would have been easier without OakHeart XD, but kidding aside OakHeart is one of my favorite toms so I’ve always felt that the special edition BlueStar would never be the same without him. I know I digress but I can’t help but digress LOL. Speaking of this, I’ll ask you a question… what do you think would be a perfect match for TrushPelt?
Let me know what you think in the comments but I think it would be LeopardFoot because after losing PineStar she needed a sweet companion to cheer her up…plus TigerStar really needed a father figure like TrushPelt to sweeten him…
What can I say? Thank you for reading my article…if I forgot something tell me, see you in the next article!
NightFall

Fan Articles

20 comments

  • WOW!! Nightfall, you did keep me entertained wile reading that but ya what if- o I just thought of something!!!! What if it was the opposite so like (This might sound crazy) Bluefur liked thistleclaw and had no ambition for leadership but then Snowfur wasthe one who liked Oakheart and then SHE became Snowstar. ooooo what if it was called Snowstars prophecie.