Are they redeemed? by Honeyfrost

Honeyfrost wonders whether these characters redeemed themselves in their lives.

Just another quick article by Honeyfrost! Have these characters redeemed themselves, or are they still neither bad nor good?

Of course, we must focus on Clear Sky (Tbh I hate him iykyk). Many people seem to think that he is “Redeemed” after The First Battle, but have we really looked into this fact, and is it true? No. He is not. Yes, I do get the fact that during the First Battle, he got over himself and actually asked for help but..does this really count as redeeming one’s self?

Next unto Breezepelt. Okay, so not gonna lie on this one, I really don’t hate him. But I do hate his character. He has committed more crime than, I believe, almost any other cat did. After the murder of Beetlewhisker, Breezepelt PRAISED the killers. He was his FRIEND, for StarClan’s sake!
“Breezepelt?” Brokenstar turned to the WindClan warrior, who was peering at Beetlewhisker’s body through narrowed eyes. “Did you hear me?” Brokenstar growled quietly. “Why would I leave the strongest Clan?” Breezepelt lifted his head. “My Clan wastes too much time looking after the sick and old. If you led us, we’d never have to beg another Clan for help again.” – Last Hope.

After this, Breezepelt covers up the murder/death of Antpelt (Shouldn’t have to quote this one?) Then moving on, Breeze attacks his own father during the Great Battle, and than later turns and leaves his trainees for dead.
“No!” As Breezepelt reared up to attack a WindClan warrior, Ivypool launched herself at him. Smashing into Breezepelt’s flank, she sent him flying. “You can’t fight for the Dark Forest!” “Are you crazy?” Breezepelt struggled free and stared at her. “This is what we’ve been training for!” “But you can’t believe that this is right!” Suddenly claws raked Ivypool’s cheek. Pain shot through her and she staggered sideways. Thistleclaw loomed over her, his lip curled to show long, yellow teeth. “Traitor!” “I’m no traitor!” Ivypool hissed. “I’ve been loyal to my Clan all along! I only came to the Dark Forest to find out what you were planning!” Her heart froze as Hawkfrost appeared behind Thistleclaw’s shoulder. Then Snowtuft landed beside her, his eyes darkening with hate. “We won’t fight for you either!” Birchfall flung himself at a Dark Forest tabby.Applefur lunged for a ragged tom. “I fight for the Clans!” Rage flared in Hawkfrost’s gaze. “Then we shall kill you first, before we destroy your wretched Clans!” – Chapter 25.

Ivypool was attacked RIGHT IN FRONT of Breezepelt, but he just allows it. If Breezepelt actually CARED, two cats could still be living. Hollyleaf sprung herself at Hawkfrost to save Ivypool, one cat gone. Also this is the last scene of Applefur (who is a confirmed victim)

Should I do a Breezepelt-only article?