[a headshot of Oakheart holding a fish in his mouth]

Under rated cats vs. Overrated cats by Zealpelt

Zealpelt lists some of the most underrated and the most overrated characters from the series.

[a headshot of Oakheart holding a fish in his mouth]
Art by AgentBudgie/Wings-Of-North (?)
[a headshot of Oakheart holding a fish in his mouth]

Hello aging this is Zealpelt, today I will be doing under rated cats v.s over rated cats! First up over rated cats.

Firestar. Don’t get me wrong I love him but every person likes him a bit too much. I don’t want to be a firestar hater but he’s just had so much attention. Like I know he is like the very first warrior cat and he becomes a leader but he just gets to much credit I think someone like Honeyfern should get more credit.

Squirrelflight. I don’t mean to hate on Firestar’s bloodline but she’s just kind of annoying. I liked her all the way till a starless clan then she was a complete jerk, like how she is trying to steal Bramblestar’s place as leader. And don’t tell me it was Bramblestar’s choice because I refuse to believe that! After the dark forest Bramblestar just was not himself but I think its just a way to make Squirrelflight leader.

Twig Branch. Why you’re probably wondering well every person chooses her over Violet Shine not that I have anything against that but Violetshine his bedder in my opinion. And onething that annoyed me was Twig Branch called Violetshine sentence because she had a dream about Needletail. TwigBranch called VioletShine sentenced for crying out loud!

Now for under rated cats.

1.Brightheart. And I am not just putting her on this list because she is one of my top ten favorites, it’s because she got half her face ripped off and only was really in the story for like two books. Her story just ended with Cloudtail and that was it! She could have been even a cooler cat!

2. Feathertail. And I know she is one of my favorites too but she made such a great sacrifice. And the reason she’s underrated is because no
one talked about her after the new prophecy. It was like every one forgot about her!

3. Oakheart. I just feel like he was never fully appreciated. And in the only books he was in he was appreciated in was Bluestar’s prophecy because she loved him, and in Crookedstar’s promise he got a spot light is because of Rainflower. I just feel like thats not fare.

Well that’s it I hope I didn’t cause any negative emotions. 😁 And this is just my opinion.

Fan Articles


  • Brackentuft the snow cat ❄️ | Brackie/Bracken/Tufty | 🎶 All I want for Christmaaas is yooouuu 🎶 | Happy holidays! 🎄🎁 | Mento to the totally radical Rowanpaw!!! | She/Her says:

    Great article! Firestar is VERY overrated.

  • 🌿Leafpaw/shine🌿| Leaf that shines under the sunlight| looking for a mentor| She/her| Leafy hopes there's snow| says:

    YESSS!!!! Twigbranch is SO OVERATED

  • 🏝️Oakpaw/swamp🏝️she/her🤌🤌Oaky is LOVING the winter vibes! 🥶❄️☃️⛄️🛷🎄🎶🎵Don’t give up on me ‘cause I’m just in a rut🎵🎶 says:

    YES YES YESSSSSS OAKHEART (hehe he’s like my fav character) BUT HE IS LITERALLY DA BESTTTTT (づ ̄ 3 ̄)づ
    oh right he’s dead. whoopsies.
    AnYWAys great article!!!

  • i really like your article but it was kind of mean about what you said about firestar, he is the main cat in the first books and i am squirrelpaw so what you said about her is kind of mean because she was also a main cat people love the main cats bc they make the story come to life no hard feelings but i really dont like what you said about firestar and squirrelflight the but the rest of the story is great 🙂

  • I agree with some of it, and being a twigbranch lover, now ive noticed more about her cause finleap to swap clans. Still, feathertail is soooooooo underated

Latest Art

More BlogClan Art