[a realistic full-body design of Mallownose sitting with his colour palette]

Who is the bad guy of A Starless Clan? by Brokenkit

Brokenkit wonders who the main antagonist of A Starless Clan is.

[a realistic full-body design of Mallownose sitting with his colour palette]
Art by Jayie-The-Hufflepuff
[a realistic full-body design of Mallownose sitting with his colour palette]

Hey! ‘Tis me, Brokenkit, and seeing my first article got me hyped up, so uh, new theory!

In ASC, we don’t know the bad guy. But I think I do. It’s… MALLOWNOSE!!!
“Oh, Brokenkit, you mousebrain! He’s minor!” Well, in the FNAF movie, a minor character was William Afton. He was the big bad. Mallownose is in his right to be bad. When Frostpaw comes from the Moonpool back after Curlfeather gets ripped apart by dogs, Mallownose tells her to try again. He knows there are dogs there! If Frostpaw dies, RiverClan will crumble. No authority, (Mistystar and Reedwhisker are dead) and no StarClan. (Mothwing is an Athiest)

It’s unlikely (But possible) that Mallow is the main villain. I do think he has something going on.
Here’s a list of more evil cats.
Berryheart (Says some sus things to her daughter)
Lightleap (Runs when she hears Reedwhisker’s scream)
Splashtail (IS LITTERALLY CONFIMED)
Duskfur (Is the last one screaming at Mistystar)
Curlfeather (Is Duskfur’s daughter)
Most RiverClan backround cats (I just don’t trust them)

Let’s hope that Frostpaw and Sunbeam get corrupted. Their moms are both on the list! (Poor Nightheart loses his crush and cries and wallows in self pity. man I hate him)
I know my theory is VERY far-fetched, but I have a good feeling, to be honest. (And yes I am FatCATBABYmew on scratch so I am not thieving cause I am him. The world doesn’t work like that.)

I think there’s probably an very, VERY small chance I’m correct. So, for StarClan’s (And RiverClan’s) sake, lemme be right! Feel free to argue with me in the comments. I want to hear your opinions on young adult romance books about cats! Just… Don’t make a whole different article disagreeing with me and then linking to it in the comments. So, bye! I hope you don’t scream links to your disagreement articles in the comments, and if you do, I’m totally not mad if I re-word several points from this article!

Brokenkit OUT!!! *Dabs, sprouts and flies to the sunset*

I HOPE YOU ENJOYED MY 1% THEORY! BYE!

Fan Articles

11 comments