Why Star Flower Was A Terrible Cat by Juniperpaw and Jackdawpaw

Juniperpaw and Jackdawpaw discuss why they dislike Star Flower.

Hello! We’re here to discuss a subject that we think is not mentioned enough in the fandom: Star Flower!
Juniperpaw:
Okay, so to begin with I feel that the way she was just plainly forgiven (especially by Thunder) after barely any time is beyond wrong. Like… She basically snatched Thunder’s heart, betrayed everyone, and then the worst part: she got with Thunder’s DAD. And that was after she dismissed Thunder like he was some clingy and immature kit, like HE was in the wrong? She barely even apologized for breaking his heart, and he was straight up head over heels in love with her.
All she said was “I liked you, but Clear Sky and I have so much more in common.” The point with a partner is that they should have different qualities than you, so that you can make up for each other. For example if one of you has unbelievable trouble with waking up in the morning and the other one is the complete opposite, they can help you get up and establish healthy habits/routines. Then for example if the early bird has trouble with overeating or something, the night owl can help them get into a healthier routine. But if both have excruciating trouble with for example going to bed early, they both end up getting five hours of sleep!
Jackdawpaw:
True words, Juniperpaw! I totally agree on all of your points. I do not like Star Flower, either. The worst thing about her was probably her relationship with Clear Sky, but another of her actions that made me dislike her a lot was the betrayal she made in the first place. She kind of flirted with Thunder and completely stole his heart. He was so obsessed with her, he ignored Lightning Tail’s suspicions about her. And then, turns out, she was a spy all the time. And she was One Eye’s daughter! (Okay, sure, she couldn’t help who her father was, but she COULD decide where her loyalties lay.) Everything he told her, she told One Eye. And then, all she said was a half-hearted “sorry.”
The fact that she was loyal to the obviously very cruel One Eye is bad itself, without this whole Thunder-love-thing. He was her father, sure, but that doesn’t mean he had to be her role model. Take Tawnypelt, for an example. Her father was Tigerstar, but she has stated that she was happy he was dead because he was an evil cat and she knew that. She did not want to be like him, unlike Star Flower, who seemed to think everything One Eye did was good.
Juniperpaw:
Agreed! That was everything we had in mind, thank you for reading.
Jackdawpaw:
Yep! May StarClan light your path, always! Jackdawpaw out!
Juniperpaw:
Juniperpaw out!