Coralpaw defends Hawkheart in Bluestar’s Prophecy.
Hello and welcome to this article. Oh, and I don’t like hawkheart, I just put the heart emoji on the title because his name says HawkHEART. Well anyways in this article we are going to be defending Hawkheart because I saw a lot of people blaming him for Moonflowers death.
Goosefeather
In my opinion it is Goosefeather’s fault that his sister died, I think he interpreted the sing wrong, and even if it was not his fault, he could have just though it was not logic because the clans where at peace right now and Windclan did not seem to be planning something. Goosefeather also knew that his “sign” ment they had to attack in the middle of the camp, which was clearly dumb and very stupid, like, your definitely going be without wounds and death when attacking a clan’s camp. You don’t know the area and they are used to their camp.
Pinestar
I feel like Pinestar did not even think about the results of the battle and what it would give them to kill their herb supply. Would it be worth it to eliminate their herb supply? I bet that if they had not gone to battle Thunderclan would be even better than they were before.
Hawkheart
Ok, Hawkheart DID kill Moonflower but she just destroyed his herbs. Those herbs where precious because he probably needed them after the battle. People say that he could just have gotten other herbs but here, all of his classmates were hurt and needed herbs, so he was on his own to pick herbs. He probably needed a bunch of herbs and different types of them.Now look, he is on his 0wn, and there is max of herbs he can take in his mouth to bring to his classmates and when medicine cats go picking herbs, they always take a warrior with them because they could meet foxes and badgers and all the warriors where hurt sol it would be dangerous. You may say he was a senior and strong warrior, but no cat can survive against a fox, do, or badger on their own.
Thank you for reading this article, sorry it was short. Please do not take any offence, this was just my opinion. I hope you enjoyed reading this article, have a nice day!
-Coralpaw/wish/Coral that blooms in a midnight wish
Good article, but Hawkheart should’ve just chased her away, not killed her. Even the Warrior Code says that’s wrong.
Great article! You made some great points!
Great article! I don’t like Hakheart and do acknowledge that he killed Moonflower, but I do feel like Goosefeather caused Moonflower’s death which is a big reason I don’t like him.
Cool article! I’m a 100% Hawkheart supporter
Great article!
I agree! But why did Hawkheart taunt Bluepaw when he knew he killed her mom? He said “Well if it isn’t the kit warrior. Are you an apprentice at last?” I was like DUDE that’s a crime making fun of the daughter of your victim. Hawkheart wasn’t even solemn about killing Moonflower, being really rough and unsorrowful about killing someone’s mom! I
I disagree about Hawkheart. He had no right to kill Moonflower regardless if she was destroying the medicine stash. The Warrior Code states that a Warrior must show mercy on others, and yet it’s shown in Bluestar’s Prophecy of him mauling her to shreds. He then taunts Bluepaw later and shows no remorse for what he did.
He broke the code, and yes, what Moonflower did was incredibly wrong(for that, yes, I blame Goosefeather and Pinestar). But that does not give Hawkheart the right to kill someone. Plus, he’s a medicine cat, and they usually stay out of conflict.
Great article regardless though! ^^
Great article! I disagree though.
I think that at that moment Hawkheart was so furious about Moonflower trying to destroy the herbs that he just killed her and was rude to her children but then later he calmed down and realized what he did. STOP HATING HAWKHEART! It’s kind of like when Lionblaze killed Russetfur. ALSO HAWKHEART HAS A COOL NAME!!!!! 🦅❤
I always think Hawkheart and Goosefeather are kinda bros. And goosefeather must had known what would happen(that’s his curse, unless his brain infection had started before that). So the whole thing must be more complicated than we thought