Why StarClan is Unfair and Wrong Sometimes by Lightningpaw

Lightningpaw discusses why StarClan’s judgement is wrong.

Hello everyone, I’m Lightningpaw! Today I’m going to explain why in my opinion StarClan is unfair.

1. When Leafpool died, StarClan hesitated to take her in
This is completely ridiculous! Leafpool has kits, and because she’s a medicine cat, they hesitate?!?! Yellowfang had kits and she was a medicine cat and they let her in!

2. Mapleshade
Mapleshade did do some very bad things, but that was because she was wronged! She really thought her kits were talking to her from StarClan and wanted her to avenge them! On one paw, it is true that she did sort of deserve going to the Dark Forest, but she also deserved going to StarClan on another paw! In the end of Mapleshade’s Vengeance, it says something meaning that she was fine with it, but what if she weren’t? Then she would have stayed there miserable because of an accident! She really thought her kits wanted her to get revenge!

3. Ashfur going to StarClan
Really StarClan? This, in my opinion, is a definite one-way for Ashfur into the Dark Forest. Ashfur attempted murder to several cats at once (Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, Squirrelflight, Jayfeather) and they let him in to StarClan?!?! Then, they say in defense ‘he only loved to much.’ but did he really even love Squirrelflight? Attempting to murder your true love isn’t really showing love for them. Plus, you don’t kill innocent cats just because they’re Squirrelflight’s! This is more obsession! In my opinion, he should have gone straight to the Dark Forest.

4. Juniperclaw going to the Dark Forest
Juniperclaw poisoned the SkyClan prey pile with deathberries, but he thought it was for the good of his clan! That reminds you of Mudclaw, doesn’t it? Well, Mudclaw is a WindClan cat that started a rebellion in his clan because he thought it was for the Clan’s own good. And he went to StarClan.
Well, Juniperclaw didn’t. Ok, he poisoned the prey pile, but only for the good of his clan! And then, he tried to make up for it by sacrifising himself by saving Violetshine and her kits! That definitely makes up for it! But, of course, he still goes to the Dark Forest.

5. Quick Water
So this one I’m more in between as Quick Water was good for her entire life, but in Shadowstar’s