![[Stonefur and Mistyfoot look at each other while sitting]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/stonefur_and_mistyfoot_by_maple_heart_db61j1k-fullview-740x648.png)
Fan ArticlesNightkit shares their thoughts on RiverClan’s reaction to Mistyfoot and Stonefur.
![[Stonefur and Mistyfoot look at each other while sitting]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/stonefur_and_mistyfoot_by_maple_heart_db61j1k-fullview-300x263.png)
[Stonefur and Mistyfoot look at each other while sitting]
Hi Nightkit here! Today I am going to be ranting about how everyone was super dumb about Mistyfoot and Stonefur.
Credits to Scarletkit for making an article that inspired me (Why Mistystar and Stonefur were obviously ThunderClan)
Once upon a time, there was this one queen called Bluefur. She had three kits, Mistykit, Stonekit, and Mosskit. Letโs pretend Mosskit isnโt there. They mysteriously went missing in the middle of the night. To conclude it, some of ThunderClanโs kits went missing, and later in RiverClan there were two new apprentices called Mistypaw and Stonepaw that looked exactly like Bluefurโs kits and had the same names and the same genders and also became apprentices exactly when Bluefurโs kits would have been apprenticed.
Seriously, how did nobody in ThunderClan recognize them? Also, cats are able to remember things that happened when they were like just born, and Mistykit and Stonekit were at LEAST a moon old. Why couldnโt they remember Bluefur at all? Wouldnโt they ask why they were in the RiverClan camp? Wouldnโt they ask about Bluefur? Apparently they could not remember a single thing about ThunderClan and completely forgot about Bluefur.
Oakheart knew that Windflight, Bluefurโs Clanmate, was half WindClan when Bluefur did not, so other cats might also know mysterious things. What if someone in ThunderClan knew that Graypoolโs kits died? Wouldnโt they be suspicious? Tigerclaw quickly spread rumors around the camp that Ravenpaw was a traitor, even leading to Frostfur attacking Ravenpaw, so why didnโt anyone figure it out or suspect it or start rumors?
When Bluefur told everyone that a fox or something had taken her kits, cats looked around and sniffed around to see if they could find any trace of the kits or a predator.
They did not find anything at all.
And they did not care. They just went on living their lives as if nothing had happened.
ALSO
Graypool smelled ThunderClan on the kits.
Nobody else did.
Graypool has an overpowered nose.
But seriously. Graypool smelled ThunderClan on them, and nobody else did? Iโm really surprised that NOBODY suspected anything. Crookedstar only found out when Mapleshade told him, and only then did he realize that their mother was Bluefur. But then, a random kittypet joined the Clans and figured it out immediately!
And now here are some cats that remembered their kithood:
– Firestar
– Whitestorm
– Squirrelstar
– Crookedstar
– Darktail
So that is a bunch of stuff about that situation and goodbye and my fingers are getting tired!
๐ฉต๐ฆ
Eagleflight (Aquila)๐๐ถ
โห๐ซงหยฐ pineblossom (she/her) โจ๐๐ช you're my favorite flavor, bubble gum ๐ฟ๐ โ
mentor to skyshimmer! ๐จ๐ซ๐ท![[an orange-and-white cat tears at a newspaper with its teeth and paws]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/gok3h17lx9l51.jpg)
Embers of an Autumn Dawn | Emberdawn
๐๐บ๐ฆ Scorchpaw/light ๐ปโ๏ธ We'll all be gone for the summer, we're on surfari to stay ๐ถ๐ฆ Running for Senior Warrior ๐๐ฟ๐ฌ
![[Tawnypelt and Brambleclaw walk side by side, each looking in the opposite direction of each other]](https://blogclan.katecary.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/tawnypelt-brambleclaw-bedupolker.jpg)
Great article! I think kits can remember stuff from early in their lives, but Stonekit and Mistykit were probably too young. Also, Graypool could smell ThunderClan because she got the kits very soon after they’d been there; after a while, the TC scent is replaced by RC :3
Anyways, so I politely disagree with you, but yeah you made some good points ๐
I completely agree, I mean like youโd think that runningwind and Mousefur would have recognised them since they were in the nusery at the same time? Lol
And two moons older, meaning they’d have a much better memory compared to those two.
Great article! Very, very good points! :)) I think that the reason why Graypool smelled ThunderClan on Mistykit and Stonekitโs fur when nobody else did was because she was the second RiverClan cat to come in contact with them after Oakheart, and then she groomed away their ThunderClan scent so nobody else could detect it. ๐ <3
No one in ThunderClan recognized them because by the time they were apprentices, they probably didn’t have their ThunderClan scent as when they did when they were kits. Great article!
YES but STILL there are two ThunderClan kits that go missing that are both blue-gray with blue eyes called Mistykit and Stonekit and then EXACTLY when they would have become apprentices RiverClan suddenly has two new apprentices that are blue-gray with blue eyes called Mistypaw and Stonepaw. ALSO they have the same genders AND they are siblings.
Honestly, the least Bluefur could’ve done was change the names, but NOOOO, they just HAD to have the same names, and Bluefur just had to hope that her Clanmates were dumb enough to believe those two weren’t the missing kits. Maybe that’s why Sunstar chose Bluefur to be deputy and how he died so quickly: Bluefur was holding ThunderClan’s brain cells hostage until she became leader. meaning no discovering of secret surviving kits and a quick trip to leadership.
nice article
Great article, I completely agree!
Except when you say cats can remember stuff from their birth, that’s not true. Cats have a horrible memory and sometimes even forget things that happened the exact day before. For example, when my aunt’s cat saw her siblings after not seeing them for half a year or something, she even completely forgot who they were.
But still, awesome article!
I meant in warriors, not in real life. Warriors is not very realistic ๐
Great article – I agree with some of your points. I also found it strange that no cat in any of the Clans raised suspicion about Mistykit and Stonekit growing up in RiverClan when they were supposed to have been eaten by a fox (I think? Itโs been a long time since Iโve read Bluestarโs Prophecy), especially in ThunderClan, where the queens would have been helping to look after Bluefurโs kits for about half a moon.
It was a badger that ‘ate’ them ๐
Great article!!!!