Revising an old opinion+a little moonpaw by Bristleflight

Bristleflight takes a look at the protagonists of A Starless Clan and Moonpaw of Changing Skies.

Heya it’s Bristleflight
Awhile back I saw discussion of how the asc protagonists were just copied off tbc protagonists but now there stories are completely different.
In the first book “River” they did not do a very good job introducing the characters. I also thought they where just ripping them off, but the newest book thunder has fixed that problem. I still think Nighthearts story’s meh and sunxnight is rushed but I like it a bit better now. I still like bristlexroot more. But what I really want to talk about is Frostpaw. I loved her in this book. She has really set herself apart from shadowsight. I like shadowsight but his story lacked depth with the characters who were abusing him for no reason. Frostpaw has many personal connections she thought were strong but everyone was using her. Yes thunder had problems but all warriors books do. Also I think she got spayed lol.

Now sunbeam, she got to bound with thunderclan. It was so nice how supportive lots of them where. There was not alot of ground breaking stuff going on at the clans but it was nice just seeing her be. And then her mother is a jerk. I don’t like Berryheart one bit.

Ok now Nightheart, he is definitely growing up but I feel like he is quit pointless. Idk his whole struggle of self identity is weird like he is nothing like firestar so why does he think everyone thinks that. Also sparkpelt changed heart really quickly.

This next part is written half a year later I found this article on the drafts!

Anyways so my points still stand but I actually really really love Frostpaw now and I think none of them are really like tbc povs anymore. I also don’t hate shadowsight anymore which I used to for some reason. I still like Frostpaw better. Btw I haven’t read wind so no spoilers in the comments plez.

I want to briefly talk about moonpaw. First off she ain’t a chimaera cat. I saw a really good video on it. Second, I hope she diverges from a shadowsight storyline. Or Frostpaw. But in my next article I’m going to be discussing a theory so stay tuned folks. It’s a theory for arc ten. Which I know is so far away we haven’t even started arc nine yet but it seem plausible.