Ask the Experts

We know you’ve all got some Warriors-related questions you need answered. Who was Snowtuft? How many kits did Mousefur have? What did the original ThunderClan camp look like?

If so, this is the page to ask!

We’ve dusted away some leaves and made a home in this part of BlogClan territory for you to ask these kinds of questions. We’re positive there will be an expert hanging around here with the answers you seek.

Just remember: if it is not written, it is not canon.

Feel free to post your questions in a comment below, and wait for your answer!

This page is focused on published books, so we ask that people avoid asking questions about future books or anything else unknown on this page. Kate will not answer questions about future storylines on this page – no exceptions, we’re afraid to say!

If you have any questions about BlogClan rather than Warriors, you probably want to head over to the BlogTeam Den, where members of BlogTeam will be happy to answer your questions and offer help!

14,877 comments

  • All right. Here are my questions.:
    1. Are the tribe and the clans related? (I think so, but I’m not quite sure.)
    2. Why is Cinderpelt the only cat who was reincarnated?
    3. How come there are so many Thunderclan protagonists?

    That’s all I have for right now, but if I think of any other questions I’ll ask them. Bye! <3

    • 1. Yes, they are. Shaded Moss led a group of travelling tribe cats to the modern territory, about halfway through. After a car took away his breathing rights, Tall Shadow took his place and led the group the rest of the way. She became the leader of Shadowclan, and the cats repopulated through the generations from there.

      2. Character Development. The Erins felt that she deserved to do so, to flesh out and finish off Cinderpelt’s character development.

      3. Firestar. In one way or another, all of the TC protagonists relate back to Firestar in one way or another.

  • Will Cloudtail or Mothwing go to StarClan? Neither believe that StarClan is ‘good’ but Hawkfrost went to the DF so… That confused me

    • I believe they will likely go to StarClan, as StarClan doesn’t seem to depend on cats having faith in it for them to need to go there. However there is also the chance that they might prefer to just remain as ghosts travelling around the lake !

    • Although at this point, Mothwing does believe in StarClan. She just doesn’t believe that StarClan is infallible or always has the best interests of the Clans in mind.

  • Also, on the topic of Jayfeather’s stick, was his attachment to it enough to kill Thornclaw, or did I read that scene wrong?

  • I’m wondering, because I’m not sure, what were the names of Lionblaze’s and Cinderheart’s kits? (I’m writing an article and I need to know)